Full Text
FAO No.490/99 Sh. Sri Ram ........Appellant through: Mr. M.L.Bhargava, Advocate
DATE OF DECISION
09.04.2008
JUDGMENT
1. Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes
2. To be referred to the Reporter or not? Yes
3. Whether judgment should be reported in Digest? Yes: PRADEEP NANDRAJOG, J.(Oral)
1. Heard learned counsel for the parties. The matter in issue is short.
2. Consignment booked by the appellant was delivered in a damaged condition. The finding that the railway authorities are responsible for what happened has attained finality. I may only note that the consignment was perishable food items and the wagon was delivered after 50 days of dispatch. In the interregnum the consignment was infested with insects. FAO 490/99 2008:DHC:1323
3. On 16.6.1994 the railway authorities issued an assessment certificate assessing 10% loss to 98 bags and 15% loss to 70 bags. The appellant got the goods inspected and analysed from two independent merchants, namely, M/s Lahori Mal Sons and M/s Premier Cereals Ltd. The former assessed the damage between 60% to 65%. The latter assessed the damaged between 62% to 67%.
4. The two reports were duly proved as Ex.AW-2/10 and Ex.AW-2/11.
5. The impugned order has noted the fact of appellant producing the two valuation reports but while concluding the issue has not even discussed, much less referred, to the two reports.
6. I find no reasons in the impugned order as to why recompense has been ordered treating 10% loss in respect of 98 bags and 15% loss in respect of 70 bags.
7. Para 1846 of the Railway Commercial Manual provides as under:- “Should there by any difference between the consignee and Railway Official granting open delivery or assessing damages, two independent and respectable persons should be called in and their opinions or point or the points under the dispute should be obtained in writing. The recorded opinion should be forwarded to claim office alongwith other papers.”
8. Under the circumstances, there is no option but to set aside the impugned order dated 29.6.1999 and remit the matter for fresh consideration and determination by the Railway Claims Tribunal. Needless to state, the Railway Claims Tribunal would deal with the reports Ex.AW-2/10 and AW-2/11. A reasoned order would be passed discussing the evidence on record pertaining to percentage loss/damage. The assessment certificate dated 16.6.1994 issued by the railway authorities would be discussed viz-a-viz Ex.AW-2/10 and AW-2/11.
9. Parties are directed to appear before the Railway Claims Tribunal on 19.5.2008. On a formal application being filed, relevant record would be traced and the claim petition would be re-decided in accordance with law.
10. No costs.
11. Copy of the order be supplied dasti to learned counsel for the parties. April 09, 2008 PRADEEP NANDRAJOG, J. pu