Full Text
Date of Decision: 29th April, 2008
SWARAN LATA ..... Petitioner
Through Mr.Surinder Anand, Advocate.
Through Mr.V.K.Makhija, Sr.Advocate with Mr.Inderjeet Sharma, Advocate.
JUDGMENT
1. Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? YES
2. To be referred to the Reporter or not? YES
3. Whether the judgment should be reported YES in the Digest? % 29.4.2008 Mr. Justice S. Ravindra Bhat (Open Court)
1. Heard counsel for the parties.
2. Mr.V.K.Makhija, learned senior counsel for the respondent had relies upon the judgment and order of the Division Bench dated 7.4.2008 whereby the Appeal against the decision of this Court's order dated 18.11.2006 in IA 10301/2006 was allowed. This Court had, after noticing the previous proceedings which led to the grant of TEST.CAS. 47/2005 1 of 7 2008:DHC:1480 probate in probate case No.34/1988, by a judgment and order of this Court dated 2.3.2005, in respect of the Will dated 15.6.1984 (of late Shri Sudarshan Lal), overruled the objections of the present respondent regarding the maintainability of the proceedings. The respondent had, in IA 10302/2006, sought for review and recall of the Court's order dated 4.8.2006. The application was dismissed by a speaking order, as also the petitioner's application IA 1001/2006 for framing additional issues was filed.
3. The respondent carried the matter in an appeal to the Division Bench. In the appeal, the respondent (who was appellant) contended that the present proceedings under Section 263 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925, for revocation and annulment of the probate were not maintainable and that the order made by this Court had to be set aside.
4. The Division Bench took into account the order of the learned Single Judge, the Division Bench in the previous case ( Probate Case No. 34/1988 concerning the same will) as well as the order of the Supreme Court. In paragraph 16, the Division Bench observed as follows:-
5. It was later concluded after citing several authorities in support of the proposition that when matter is substantially an issue and parties have been given full opportunity in that regard, the findings on such issue would continue to bind them. The Court concluded as follows:- “We have also carefully seen the endorsement in the original Will as well as the endorsement in the certified copy issued by the Registrar's Office as placed on record in the new testamentary case and we are of the view that there is no discrepancy. While in the registered Will, it has clearly been mentioned that the said Will had been presented by the appellant, Shri P.P.Sharma, in the Registrar's copy in the column “presented by” the “of” thereby mentioning that the document pertains to the Will of Shri Sudershan Lal. In TEST.CAS. 47/2005 3 of 7 any event, Mr.Sudershan Lal could not have presented the Will for registration as admittedly the Will was registered on 18th May, 1987 i.e. much after the death of the testator. The new ground being urged by Mr.Chandhiok in support of his contention that the said Will was forged is only an additional evidence on old grounds. The said Will and the endorsement on its back page were always available on the record of the earlier Probate Case. The respondent cannot be exempt from proof of having exhausted due diligence in presenting her objection to the earlier Probate Case. Consequently, we do not find that the new ground being urged by Mr.Chandhiok is even prima facie enough to warrant a finding that the Letter of Administration was obtained fraudulently by making a false suggestion or by concealing something material from the record.
20. Another point urged by Mr.Chandhiok, which we would refer to only as a “talking point” is that one of the pages carries the name of Mr.Madan Mohan, Advocate. This, he said, represents Mr.M.M.Sharma. We are not inclined to agree with Mr.Chandhiok. Mr.M.M.Sharma is a distinct individual who has separately signed down below at the back of the said Will.
21. In our view the genuineness of the Will having been upheld right upto the Supreme Court, the respondent's endeavour to lead fresh evidence on the ground that the said Will is a forged and fabricated document is clearly barred by principles of res judicata and by principles re-litigation.”
5. This Court also considered the previous judgment in the probate case No.34/1988. That was a contested proceeding where the present petitioner was a respondent and objector, following issues TEST.CAS. 47/2005 4 of 7 have been framed for consideration in the said probate case No.34/1988:-