Mirza Zahid Beg & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors.

Delhi High Court · 02 May 2008 · 2008:DHC:1528-DB
A.K. Sikri; J.M. Malik
WP(C) No. 484/1988
2008:DHC:1528-DB
service_law appeal_allowed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court held that Lower Division Clerks in District Courts are entitled to pay parity with their counterparts in the High Court under the constitutional principle of equal pay for equal work and directed payment of arrears.

Full Text
Translation output
WP(C) No. 484/1988 HIGH COURT OF DELHI WP(C) No.484/1988
Date of Decision: 02.05.2008 #Mirza Zahid Beg & Ors. ....Petitioners
! Through: Mr.P.S. Bindra with Ms.Mike Desai
VERSUS
$Union of India & Ors. .....Respondents ^ Through Mr.Rajinder Nischal for respondent No.1/UOI.
Mr.V.K. Tandon for respondent No.4
CORAM :- THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE A.K.SIKRI THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE J.M. MALIK
1.Whether Reporters of Local papers may be allowed to see the
JUDGMENT
?
2.To be referred to the Reporter or not? 3.Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest?
A.K. SIKRI, J. (Oral)
:

1. When this writ petition was filed by the five petitioners in the year 1988 they were working as Lower Division Clerks in the Tis Hazari Courts, Delhi. The Appointing Authority of the 2008:DHC:1528-DB petitioners is the District and Sessions Judge, Delhi and the service conditions of the petitioners were governed by Punjab Courts Act and Vol. I of Chapter 18A of the Punjab High Court Rules as extended to Delhi. The petitioners, as per the recommendations of the 3rd Pay Commission were given the pay scale of Rs.260-400/-, which was the pay scale recommended for Lower Division Clerks. Even their counterparts working in Delhi High Court were placed in the same pay scale of Rs.260-400/-. This very pay scale of Rs.260-400/- was given to Restorers as well in the High Court.

2. The Restorers of the High Court filed WP(C) No.1376/1984 claiming parity with Restorers of the High Court of Punjab and Haryana as well as the High Court of Himachal Pradesh, who were given the pay scale of Rs.400-600/-. This writ petition was allowed by this Court vide judgment dated 3.2.1986 in the case of Kamalanand v. Union of India & Ors.. The consequence of the said judgment, which was implemented by the respondents, was that the Restorers of this Court started getting pay scale of Rs.400-600/-.

3. Subsequently, LDCs of this Court filed WP(C) No.1865/1986, which was also allowed by the High Court vide its judgment dated 11.11.1986 holding that they would be entitled to the same benefit as the Restorers. There was further revision in the pay scales with effect from 1.1.1986 after the 4th Pay Commission‟s recommendations were implemented by the Government. On the basis of pay scale of Rs.400-600/- given to the Restorers and LDCs in compliance with the aforesaid judgment, the Restorers and LDCs of this Court were given the replacement scale of Rs.1,350-2,200/-.

4. The corresponding benefit was not extended to the petitioners herein, i.e. LDCs working in the District Court and they continued to get the pay scale of Rs.260-400/-. Consequently, they were given the revision in the pay scale of Rs.950-1,500/-, which was the revised pay scale recommended by the 4th Pay Commission for those who were in the pre-revised pay scale of Rs.260-400/-.

5. In the aforesaid backdrop, the case of the petitioners is that they be given pay scale of Rs.400-600/- with effect from 1.1.1978 to 31.12.1985 along with arrears and revised pay scale of Rs.1,350-2,200 with effect from 1.1.1986 along with arrears. We may note that the petitioners had made representation in this behalf, which was rejected by the District and Sessions Judge vide communication dated 27.1.1988. In this communication the petitioners were informed that the representation of the petitioner addressed to the Secretary (L&J), Delhi Administration, was examined and for the following reasons the representation was rejected:- “On examination of the proposal, it reveals that the pay scale of Rs.260-400 to the LDCs and Restorers of the D&SJ is as per the Pay Scale recommended by the Third Central Pay Commission and approved by the Govt. of India. The pay scale applicable to the Staff of the District & Session Judge cannot be equated with the pay scale sanctioned to the staff of the Punjab and Haryana High Court. In view of this, we do not find any justification to the case of Restorers for equation with the scale prevailing in the Punjab and Haryana High Court, and as such regret our inability to agree to this proposal.”

6. The case of the petitioners is that they are entitled to seek parity with their counterparts working in the High Court as the work done by them is identical; the mode of recruitment is also the same; before the judgment given by this Court in the aforesaid case, the LDCs of the District Court as well as the High Court were treated at par and were getting the same pay scale and that on the basis of rationale and reasoning given by this Court, their cases would also be covered and therefore, they are entitled to the same benefit on the principles of equality.

7. Perusal of the judgment of this Court in Kamla Nand (supra) would reveal that after taking note of relevant facts, following features available therein: (a) the post of restorer of this Court carried pay scale of Rs.80-110/- until 1970. In May 1970, the post of Restorer was made equivalent to that of LDC in this Court and therefore, the Restorers also started getting the pay scale of Rs.110- 180/-, which was admissible to the LDCs; (b) after the implementation of 3rd Pay Commission report, this pay scale was revised to Rs.260-400/-. However, for reasons which were not clear, the Restorers in Punjab and Haryana High Court as well as the Himachal Pradesh High Court started getting the pay scale of Rs.400-600/-;

(c) the duties of the Restorer in Delhi as well as Punjab and

Haryana High Court or Himachal Pradesh High Court were, by and large, identical. Punjab and Haryana High Court as well as Himachal Pradesh High Court were the successor and Predecessor of the Delhi High Court.

8. On the basis of the aforesaid factual premise, the Court held that not only on the ground that two High Courts where the Restorers were getting higher pay scale were the successor and predecessor of this Court but also on the principles of „equal pay for equal work‟ which is made a constitutional goal of Article 39(d) of the Constitution of India, the Restorers of this Court would be entitled to the same pay scale. We may reproduce the relevant portion from the said judgment:-

“11. But that is not the end of the matter because executive action in the matter of employment, as indeed, in other matters, must also satisfy the test of being “just, fair and reasonable”. A claim to parity in the matter of scale of pay by those working under a State with a person carrying out similar work in an institutional under the Central Government in a city like Delhi would perhaps fail because even though both are doing equal work but having regard to the higher cost of living index applicable to Delhi and the financial constraints of the State revenues, the disparity could not be unfair or unreasonable. But could the reverse be true? A claim of parity by someone working in the Central Administration in Delhi with those employee in similar institution in States in places like Chandigarh or Simla must succeed because such a disparity is bound to be looked upon as being neither fair nor reasonable. In industrial law, the principle of “equal pay for equal work” is recognized subject to the doctrine of “region-cum-industry”, the reason being that the different regions of the country have different indexes of living and different industries have the different capacity to pay, even though it is recognized that the matter of payment of minimum wages to a worker, the capacity to pay is irrelevant. But how does one justify in the context of an allegation of arbitrariness and discrimination denial of a scale of pay to someone working in a city
like Delhi, under the Central Government or the Delhi Administration on the basis of which a similarly situated person is being paid in a similar institution in cities like Chandigarh or Simla, where the cost of living indexes are admittedly lower than that obtaining in Delhi. While the case of a reverse claim, one would be justified in saying that they are not similarly situated, such a distinguishing feature would not be available where a claim to parity is sought with those working in similar situations in less costly areas as in the present case. It appears to us that the principle of “equal pay for equal work” would be squarely available to the petitioner, particularly, having regard to the admitted fact that of the two High Court, in relation to which parity is claimed, one was a predecessor of this court and the other its successor. In the circumstances, to pay to the Restorers of this Court on a scale which is Lower than the scale applicable to their counterparts in the two High Courts referred to above, could not but be termed arbitrary and discriminatory. If the matter was before an expert body like the Pay Commission, it would perhaps be inclined to consider that if the scale of pay applicable to the other two High Courts is a fair basis, those working in similar posts in a city like Delhi would be entitled to a still higher scale of pay but that is not the claim of the petitioner nor are we in a position in which we may embark on the work of fixation of pay scales which involves a variety of technical factors, as indeed, would require consideration supporting material and such an exercise is neither necessary nor possible in the present case.”

9. Likewise, while allowing the claim of the LDCs vide its judgment dated 11.11.1986 in Civil Writ No.1865/1986, the Court made the following pertinent observations:- “Notice of this Writ petition has been served on the respondents and they have filed a reply. It is not contested in the reply that the posts of Lower Division Clerks and the Restorers are equal in status. On the other hand, it has been clearly stated that, except that the Restorers have to work in Court Rooms while the Lower Division Clerks work in the office, in all other respect the two posts are equal and are so described in the various rules. In view of this admitted position, the petitioners are entitled to their prayer in the writ petition. We, therefore, allow the writ petition and direct the respondents to revise the pay scales of the petitioners and other Lower Division Clerks working in Delhi High Court and the same in the same pay scale of Rs.400-600 as Restorers with effect from the same date.”

10. In view of the aforesaid position there is no reason to deny the benefit of same pay scale to the LDCs of District Court which is the pay scale of the LDCs enjoyed by the High Court staff. It is more so when the pay scales granted to the LDCs of District Court as well as Delhi High Court pursuant to Third Pay Commission was the same. Because of this reason we are also not agreeable with the reason given by the District and Sessions Judge in his communication dated 27.1.1988. In this communication reason given is that the pay scale applicable to the staff of District and Sessions Judge cannot be equated with the pay scale sanctioned to the staff of the Punjab and Haryana High Court. What is missed out is that these pay scales were same at one point of time. Thus, even if the pay scales are to be compared with the staff of the District and Sessions Courts in Punjab and Haryana, the position is same. We may point out at this stage that as the pay scale of the LDCs working in Delhi High Court was revised on the parity of the pay scales of their counter-parts in High Court of Punjab & Haryana as well as High Court of Himachal Pradesh, we wanted to find out as to what is the pay scale of LDCs in the District Courts in Punjab & Haryana. Learned counsel for the petitioner has placed before us the material in the form of appointment letters issued to such staff in Punjab & Haryana as well as notice inviting applications for the post of LDCs in District Courts as per which the pay scale in the year 1999 were Rs.3,120- 5,160/-. We are informed that the said pay scale has since been revised to Rs.5,000-8,100/-, which is more than the pay scale admissible to the LDCs of this Court which is Rs.4500-125-7000/-. In these circumstances whether we compare the case of the petitioners with the LDCs of this Court or with the LDCs of Punjab & Haryana and Himachal Pradesh High Courts, there is no reason to deny the benefit of the same pay scale to the petitioners i.e. Rs.4500-125- 7000/-.

11. We may state that we are conscious of the fact that fixation of pay scale is normally a executive function. These aspects are normally to be examined by the Pay Commissions or expert bodies. Comparison requires various considerations, including the responsibilities, educational qualifications, mode of appointment etc. However, at the same time when it is found that there is a complete and wholesome identity between the two groups and denying benefit of pay scale to one group, which is enjoyed by another group, would amount to invidious discrimination, courts can step in and remove such discrimination. We find that present case falls in this category. We, therefore, make the Rule absolute and allow this writ petition. The District and Session Judge is directed to grant the aforesaid pay scale to the petitioners w.e.f. 1.1.1996. The arrears of pay shall also be worked out and paid to the petitioners within three months from today. No costs.

12,742 characters total

(A.K. SIKRI) JUDGE May 02, 2008 (J.M. MALIK ) hp/skk JUDGE