Full Text
CM Appl. No.14500/2006 in WP(C) No.5812/2005
Date of Decision: 02.05.2008 #Col. Ratan Chakravorty ......Petitioner
! Through: Dr.Shyamla Pappu, Senior Advocate With Mr.S.K. Sharma and Mr.R. Krishnamoorti
JUDGMENT
2.To be referred to the Reporter or not? 3.Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest?
A.K. SIKRI, J.
:
1. Col. Ratan Chakravorty, while serving Indian Army, was court martialled for certain charges. On the basis of findings arrived at by the General Court Martial, sentence was pronounced on 26.4.2004 whereby he was awarded the sentence of cashiering and rigorous imprisonment for two years. The petitioner filed pre-confirmation petition on 23.9.2003, 2008:DHC:1538-DB which was supplemented by another petition dated 14.3.2005. Thereafter, on 24.3.2005 the petitioner’s wife also made representation to the Chief of Army Staff. As no decision was taken on the said petitions for quite some time, present petition was filed by the petitioner on 7.4.2005 for quashing of the proceedings as without jurisdiction and setting aside the findings and sentence of the General Court Martial dated 24.6.2004. We may, however, mention that the petitioner has amended the writ petition as, in the meantime, sentence awarded to the petitioner had been confirmed by the GOI-C, Western Command, Chandimandir dated24.3.2005 and the post-confirmation petition was also dismissed vide orders dated 26.5.2006 passed by the Central Government. In the amendment, challenge to these orders is also incorporated.
2. Show cause notice in this petition was issued pursuant to which the respondents have filed the counter affidavit. Rejoinder thereto has also been filed by the petitioner. After filing of the petition, the petitioner has filed CM Appl. No.14500/2006 in which prayer is made to the effect that the respondents be directed to release DSOP Fund of Rs.8,90,349/as shown in the salary slip of August 2005 of the petitioner. It is also prayed that the respondents be directed to pay the Army Group Insurance Fund amount immediately and since these amounts are withheld illegally, interest @ 18% per annum is also demanded. It is stated by the petitioner in this application that he received salary in his bank account till 31.7.2005 and his monthly contribution to provident fund was deducted at source by the respondent No.7. The balance in the provident fund as on 31.7.2005 was Rs.8,90,349/-, which was duly reflected in the statement of pay for February, 2006. No salary, however, was paid for the period 1.8.2005 to 4.9.2005.
3. It may be mentioned that though the petitioner was cashiered from service vide orders dated 26.4.2004, since he was also awarded rigorous imprisonment for two years, he was kept in military custody from 5.9.2003 to 4.9.2005. During this period he was paid the salary till 31.7.2005, which was credited in his account but no salary is paid from 1.8.2005 to 4.9.2005, the date of his release. The respondents, however, realized that the petitioner was not entitled to payment of any salary after imposition of the aforesaid sentence as he ceased to be in service. Therefore, vide letter dated 24.2.2006, respondent No.7 directed the petitioner to deposit Rs.6,15,106/- on account of the said salary already paid to him wrongly for the period from 5.7.2003 to 31.7.2005. Since the provident fund was also deducted from the salary paid to him for the aforesaid period, the amount of provident fund deducted during this period is also reduced and the petitioner is informed that balance amount of Rs.6,93,768/- only is payable as provident fund dues is payable to him and against this amount, recovery of Rs.6,15,106/- is sought. The amount of provident fund is withheld because of non-deposit of the said salary erroneously paid to the petitioner.
4. The argument of the petitioner is that the respondents have no right to recover the said amount or for that matter ask the petitioner to pay back the said amount of Rs.6,15,106/- to the respondents. The submissions of the learned counsel for the petitioner in this behalf are as under:a) Provident fund is not the public money. It is the petitioner’s own contribution to provident fund which is deducted at source and put in provident fund account every month. Therefore, no deductions can be made by the respondents from the provident fund account of the petitioner as per the law. b) During the entire period of custody, no directions were passed by the ‘prescribed officer’ or Government of India in terms of Section 93 of the Army Act, Note 6 clause (b) of Army Act Sec. 90(b), Army Rules 194 and
205. Withholding or deduction made from salary as well as provident fund of the petitioner by the respondents at this stage and that too with retrospective date, are not only illegal but violative of Army Act Section 61. Authority to withhold pay and allowances arises only when there is an order by the prescribed officer under Section 93 and in the absence of such an order, no withholding of pay and allowances is permissible, much less a deduction of pay and allowances already paid from provident fund amount accrued to the petitioner’s benefit. c) In reply to this application the respondents have themselves stated in para 9 that “sanction to waive over payment of pay and allowance has been called for from Headquarters 65, Inf. Bde C/o 56 APO.” Therefore, the respondents are themselves contemplating waiver of the recovery.
5. In so far as Army Group Insurance is concerned, it was pointed out that though the amount in this behalf is paid in February 2007, but the same is done after a lapse of 17 months since the release from the military custody. Moreover, Rs.30,070/- have been wrongly deducted therefrom.
6. Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents submitted that after the petitioner was taken to military custody on 5.9.2003 he was not entitled for any pay and allowances during the period of military custody, i.e. from 5.9.2003 to 4.9.2005. However, the respondents inadvertently released his pay and allowances. Therefore, the respondents are entitled to recover this amount in terms of Section 90(b) of the Army Act, which reads as under:-
7. It is also argued that even Rule 205 of the Army Act, 1954 authorises such deductions, relevant portion whereof is extracted below:- “205. Authorised deductions. The following deductions may be made from the pay, non-effective pay and all other emoluments payable to a person subject to the Act namely:- (a) Upon the general or special order of the Central Government, any sum required to meet any public claim that may be against him, any regimental debt that may be due from him or any regimental claim. (b) ….. Explanation: - (i) “Public claim” means any public debt or disallowance including any over-issue; or a deficiency or irregular expenditure of public money or store of which, after due investigation, no explanation satisfactory to the Central Government is given by the person who is responsible for the same.
(ii) The aforesaid deductions shall be in addition to those specified in the Act.
8. It is further submitted that the petitioner is not entitled to Rs.8,90,349/as claimed by him to be shown in the Statement of Account for the year August 2005. This amount included the DSOP Fund subscription and interest thereon for the period of petitioner’s military custody. Since he was not entitled to pay and allowances for the said period, there was no question of any contribution being made to the DSOP fund for the said period. Therefore, the recovery on account of fund contribution for this period was credited back and not taken into account while finalizing the DSOP Fund amount. It is submitted that after making deductions of the amount wrongly contributed by the respondents towards the DSOP Fund for the said period, the petitioner’s DSOP Fund balance became Rs.6,93,768/-. Therefore, in no event the petitioner can claim anything more than this amount. Even the said amount could not be paid to him since he had already received the amount of Rs.6,80,091/- in excess in the form of pay and allowances for the period of his military custody, to which he was not entitled. In terms of Section 90(b) and Rule 205, respondents are entitled to set off or deduct this amount against his DSOP balance. Therefore, he is only entitled to Rs.13,677/- being the difference between Rs.6,93,768/- and Rs.6,80,091/-.
9. No doubt, under Section 90(b) of the Army Act there can be deductions from pay and allowances for every day while such a person is in custody or under suspension from duty, if he is ultimately convicted by a criminal court or court martial. However, Section 93 deals with pay and allowances during trial and stipulates:- “Pay and Allowances during trial.-In the case of any person subject to this Act who is in custody or under suspension from duty on a charge for an offence, the prescribed officer may direct that the whole or any part of the pay and allowance of such person shall be withheld, pending the result of his trial on the charge against him, in order to give effect to the provisions of clause (b) of sections 90 and 91.”
10. Thus, there has to be an order by the competent officer who would “direct that whole or any part of the pay and allowances for the said period be withheld.” No such order has been produced by the respondents. Further Army Rule 168, inter alia, stipulates that when dismissal is combined with imprisonment, which is to be carried out in a military prison or in military custody or with field punishment, the dismissal shall not take effect until the date on which the prisoner is released from a military prison or from military custody or until the completion of field punishment. No doubt, the petitioner was cashiered on 26.4.2004, at the same time he was given sentence of two years rigorous imprisonment as well and remained in the military custody till 4.9.2005. As per Rule 168, order of cashiering would take effect from 4.9.2005.
11. Even if it is presumed that the petitioner is paid the salary and allowances for the period from 5.7.2003 to 31.7.2005 wrongly, the question is as to whether such an amount can be deducted from the provident fund dues payable to the petitioner? Normal principle of law is no such deduction can be made from the provident fund. The respondent, however, have taken shelter under Section 90(b) of the Army Act and Rule 205 of the Army Rules, 1954. In so far as deduction under 90(b) of the Army Act is concerned, we have already pointed out that no specific orders in this behalf are passed under Section 93 of the Act, which was necessary. Rule 205 of the Army Rules would also not come to the rescue of the respondents. This rule deals with ‘authorised deductions’, namely, any sum required to meet any public claim that may be against the concerned official. Public claim is specifically defined to mean any public debt or disallowance, including any over-issue.
12. There is a further condition that a specific order, general or special, is to be passed by the Central Government for such deductions. Again, it is nowhere stated as to whether any such order has been passed. On the contrary, in the correspondence of the respondents it is mentioned that case for waiver of recovery is recommended to the Central Government. In view of the aforesaid facts, which appear on record, the respondents cannot make recovery of the said amount of Rs.6,80,091/- from the provident fund payable to the petitioner. It is clear from the letter dated 17.10.2005 wherein it is stated as under:- “No recovery of Rs.119816/- has been made from DSOP fund account as standby you. The matter has been referred to higher authorities for detailed clarification and information and publication of Part II orders for all casualities. Further action to restore your pay and allowances will be taken on receipt of reply from Army HQRS, New Delhi.”
13. Likewise, in the communication dated 24/28 April 2006 addressed by the Senior Accounts Officer to the Commandant it is, inter alia, recorded as under:- “The matter may please be referred to your administrative authorities and obtain and forward sanction to waive the overpayment of pay and allowances from 05/07/2003 to 31/07/2005 as the officer has already been dismissed from service. The reason for not intimating audit authorities immediately duly publishing the part II order stating that the officer was placed under military custody on 05/09/2003 may please be intimated which resulted in to overpayment of pay and allowances. It is your primary duty to intimate audit authorities the said fact at that time.”
14. What is accepted here is that factum of the petitioner’s placement under military custody was not communicated because of which requisite order in Part II could not be published. This, thus, accepts that there was no such order published. In these circumstances, the Commandant was advised that the matter be referred to administrative authorities and sanction obtained to waive the over-payment of pay and allowances. In these circumstances, we allow the prayer made in this application with direction to the respondents to pay the amount of Rs.6,93,768/- due to the petitioner along with interest accrued thereon without insisting on any payment from him. However, liberty is granted to the respondents to file appropriate recovery proceedings in case it is found that the payment made was erroneous. The amount shall be paid to the petitioner within two weeks along with interest which has accrued thereon.
15. In so far as the Army Group Insurance is concerned, it is admitted that the payment has since been made. Though the petitioner has alleged that some amount is recovered from him wrongly, we are not in a position to decide the question as to whether the recovery is proper or not in the absence of any pleadings in this behalf. Therefore, no direction can be given in this behalf. Liberty is, however, granted to the petitioner to file requisite application with proper particulars. This application stands disposed of in the aforesaid terms.
(A.K. SIKRI) JUDGE May 02, 2008 (VEENA BIRBAL) HP.