Jinesh Kumar Jain v. Delhi Development Authority

Delhi High Court · 14 May 2008 · 2008:DHC:1638-DB
THE CHIEF JUSTICE; DR. JUSTICE S. MURALIDHAR
LPA No.85/2008
2008:DHC:1638-DB
property appeal_allowed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court allowed the appeal and quashed the cancellation of a DDA flat allotment, holding that the authority must give reasoned orders when refusing condonation of delay where the allottee has paid the full amount with interest.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
LPA No.85/2008 JINESH KUMAR JAIN ..... Appellant
Through: Mr.Anil Sapra, Advocate
VERSUS
DELHI DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY ..... Respondent
Through Mr.Gaurav Sarin, Advocate
CORAM:
HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE S.MURALIDHAR
JUDGMENT

1. Whether reporters of the local papers be allowed to see the judgment ? Yes

2. To be referred to the Reporter or not ? No

3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? No % JUDGMENT 14.05.2008 ADMIT.

1. Learned counsel for the respondent waives service of notice. By consent of the parties, the appeal is taken up for final hearing.

2. This appeal under Clause 10 of the Letters Patent is against the order dated 21st January, 2008 passed by the learned single Judge in WP(C) No.474/2008 whereby the writ petition filed by the appellant was (LPA No.85/2008) 2008:DHC:1638-DB dismissed in limine.

3. Brief facts leading to the filing of the present appeal are as follows: The respondent-DDA floated a housing scheme named the ‘New Pattern Registration Scheme – 1979’ in the year 1979 thereby offering the public to get themselves registered thereunder and own flats to be constructed by the DDA. The said Scheme formulated three categories of registrants, namely, MIG, LIG and Janta depending upon the income range of the registrants. In the case of MIG category, DDA fixed a sum of Rs.4,500/- as the registration amount to be deposited at the time of registration under the said category of the Scheme. It was further declared by DDA that the likely cost of the flats to be constructed under the said Scheme would be Rs.42,000/- for MIG flats, Rs.18,000/- for LIG flats and Rs.8,000/- for Janta flats. The appellant got himself registered under the said Scheme for allotment of a MIG flat and deposited a sum of Rs.4,500/- with DDA and he was allotted Registration No.26355 vide deposit receipt dated 27th September, 1979. Initially allotment of the flats under the said Scheme was made by draw of lots wherein all the applicants who were registered under the said Scheme were placed in the draw of lots which were held on the availability of flats with DDA under the respective categories and those successful out of the entire registrants were allotted the flats. However, in the year 1986 DDA allotted priority numbers to the registrants of each category under the said Scheme and allotment of flats was then decided to be made on the basis of seniority as per the priority numbers so allotted according to the availability of the flats in a particular category at a particular point of time. The draw of lots was consequently held only for allotting specific flats to the registrants whose priority had matured according to the number of flats available. In pursuance of the same, the appellant was consequently allotted Priority Number 37020 by DDA. When the priority of the appellant was matured in accordance with his seniority, he was alloted a MIG Flat bearing No.542, Pocket-A, Sector-13, Phase-2, Dwarka, New Delhi on Hire Purchase basis and a Demand-cum-Allotment letter block dated 25th September, 2003-30th September, 2003 was issued to him. As per the said Demand-cum- Allotment letter the total disposal cost of the said flat was Rs.8,94,570/and the appellant was called upon to pay a sum of Rs.5,56,925/- by 29th January, 2004 as initial cost and thereafter was required to pay monthly instalments of Rs.6,618/- per month for 120 months commencing from 10th January, 2004. According to the appellant since the flat was allotted after a long period of 24 years and that too at a cost many times higher than indicated at the time of launching of the said Scheme, the appellant was caught unaware of for paying such huge cost in such a short span of time. The appellant had retired from service with the Delhi Vidyut Board in January, 2001 and was short of funds at the said point of time. However, since the appellant was in desperate need of an accommodation, he deposited a sum of Rs.2,00,000/- on 28th January, 2004 vide challan No.52210 with the Central Bank, Vikas Sadan, New Delhi as part payment of the aforesaid flat. Further, the appellant also deposited another sum of Rs.13,600/- vide challan No.52209 dated 5th February, 2004 towards monthly instalments for the months of January and February, 2004. The appellant by his letter dated 17th February, 2004 requested DDA for extension of time to deposit the balance amount towards the initial cost of the said flat alloted to him as the appellant at that time was not having adequate funds. DDA vide its letter dated 3rd March, 2004 directed the appellant to deposit the remaining initial cost of the said MIG flat so that possession of the said flat could be issued to him. As the appellant was still unable to raise funds, he requested for further extension of time for deposit of the balance initial cost of the flat vide his letter dated 26th August, 2004. Again, a similar request was made by the appellant vide letter dated 24th February, 2005. On 20th June, 2005 the appellant deposited a sum of Rs.3,60,000/-vide challan No.18769 towards the balance initial cost of the flat. By letter dated 21st June, 2005 the appellant requested DDA to inform him about the amount payable so that possession of the flat could be taken. Vide letter dated 2nd September, 2005 DDA directed the appellant to appear before Assistant Director (MIG)(H) along with the documentary proof of identification and to deposit up to date monthly instalments towards cost of the flat alloted to him. Pursuant thereto, the appellant deposited another sum of Rs.1,30,000/- vide challan No.18770 towards monthly instalments for the period from March, 2004 to September, 2005. According to the appellant, after the deposit of the said amount when he met the concerned officer of the DDA intimating him about the said deposit, he was advised to deposit the interest for the delayed period as well to enable the DDA to regularise the delay in deposit of the demanded amounts. Consequently, the appellant deposited a sum of Rs.63,000/- vide challan No.18771 dated 27th September, 2005 towards interest for belated payment of the balance cost of the said flat. The appellant thereafter vide his letters dated 11th November, 2005 and 8th May, 2006 informed the DDA about the deposit of the complete cost of the flat, interest for delayed payment of the initial payment and installments from January, 2004 to September, 2005 and requested the DDA for issuance of possession letter of the aforesaid flat immediately. DDA however vide their letter dated 15th November, 2006 informed the appellant that his request for regularisation of the period had been examined by the Competent Authority and the same was not acceded to. The appellant was further directed to apply for refund of the deposited amounts after submitting the relevant documents as mentioned in the said letter. The appellant thereafter again by his letter dated 7th November, 2007 requested the Vice Chairman of the DDA to hand over possession of the flat allotted to him since the appellant had already made full payment of the initial cost along with interest and had paid various monthly instalments as well. But DDA failed and neglected to pay any heed to the various requests of the appellant.

4. Aggrieved, the appellant filed WP(C) No.474/2008 praying for issuance of writ in the nature of Certiorari or any other appropriate writ, order or direction, quashing the cancellation of the allotment of the appellant with respect to the MIG flat bearing No.542, Pocket-A, Sector- 13, Phase-II, Dwarka, New Delhi. The writ petition filed by the appellant was dismissed by the learned single Judge vide order dated 21st January, 2008 holding that there was delay of 480 days in depositing the initial amount by the appellant and that the Vice Chairman, DDA had taken a considered decision in terms of the policy guide lines on the request of the appellant for condonation of delay and further that the order of cancellation was communicated to the appellant vide letter dated 15th November, 2006 whereas the writ petition was filed only on 17th January, 2008 and as such there was no merit in the writ petition. In the present appeal, the appellant challenges the judgment and order of the learned single Judge.

5. Learned counsel appearing for the appellant strenuously contended that the Vice Chairman, DDA, failed to consider that the appellant had made substantial payments within the stipulated period and had also made requests vide his various letters for extension of time for deposit of the balance initial amount towards the flat alloted to him. The said requests were never rejected by the DDA and on the contrary DDA had been calling upon the appellant to make further payments and such payments made by the appellant were duly accepted by DDA without any objection to the same. Learned counsel submitted that under similar circumstances, delay of over 15th months in making deposit of the demand in various other cases has been condoned by the Competent Authority. He cited the case of Mr.D.L.Sachdeva resident of 3-C/40-B, GF, New Rohtak Road, New Delhi wherein the Demand-cum-Allotment letter was issued vide letter block dated 20th February, 1999 - 24th February, 1999 whereby the net amount was payable on or before 25th May, 1999. The said Mr.Sachdeva deposited the amount in instalments starting from 16th march, 1999 and the last one on 6th November, 2000. After cancelling the allotment in the first instance, the DDA re-examined his case and restored the allotment and issued a fresh demand-cum-allotment letter in favour of Mr.Sachdeva. Learned counsel submitted that the appellant who is a heart patient had been waiting to own and possess a residential accommodation for the last more than 28 years and the same is being illegally denied to him by DDA.

6. In reply, the learned counsel appearing for DDA submitted that by virtue of the policy decision taken vide letter dated 1st June, 2000 the Competent Authority empowered to condone the delay of more than 1½ years is the Vice Chairman and for the period over three years is the Chairman. He however submitted that such condonation of delay is subject to the allottee depositing 50% of the demanded amount to get the relief. He submitted that in the present case the amount was deposited after 1½ years and thus 50% of the demand was not deposited within the stipulated period and consequently the Vice Chairman has no power to regularise the delay in depositing the amount.

7. Before adverting to the submissions made by the learned counsel for the parties, we may refer to the relevant Office Orders/Circulars issued by the DDA. Office Order No.PS/C(H)/DDA/2000 dated 1st June, 2000 reads as follows: “OFFICE ORDER While issuing allotment letters to the registrants of various schemes of DDA, a demand is raised to the concerned allottees specifying the amount to be paid with due dates of payment. However, we had seen in practice that on account of problems faced by the concerned allottees, we get various requests for extension of time to deposit the amount and to condone the delay. In DDA we examine the cases on merit and in certain cases delay is regularised. However, there are no clear cut guidelines while accepting/rejecting the requests for condonation of delay. At present, as per the circular NO.HAU-IX/Delay/98/DDA/10-N dated March 31, 1999 (placed below) the competent authority to regularise the delay is as per the given table:- Period of Delay Designation i) upto 30 days Jt/Dy. Directors ii) Beyond 30 days but upto 90 days Directors (Hsg) iii) Beyond 90 days but upto 1 year Commissioner (Hsg) iv) Beyond 1 year but upto 1 year 6 months Principal Commissioner v) More than 1 year 6 months Vice Chairman [In case where allottees default for a proportion upto 10% of the total demanded amount, regularisation of delay/restoration of allotment is done at the level of Commissioner (Housing) irrespective of the period of delay]. To reduce the subjectivity and to have some policy guidelines in this regard, the matter was discussed by the undersigned with V.C. on 29.5.2000. Accordingly, here are some points which may render a case fit for consideration/condonation of delay:-

(i) In cases where the bread winner of the family dies putting the family members in a vulnerable condition in depositing the entitle demanded amount.

(ii) If the allottee has deposited the confirmation amount as well as 25% of the total demanded amount and if the request for extension of time is upto one year.

(iii) In case where the extension has been requested for the second or more times, where the condonation is for a period of more than a year i.e. where competent authority is the Vice Chairman, the allottee should deposit at least 50% of the demanded amount to get the relief. (Emphasis supplied)

(iv) If the flat is in those areas which are not very popular and DDA is finding difficult to sell the houses for occupation e.g. In places like Narela

(v) DDA colonies where we are not in a position to provide even the basic amenities like water and electricity to the inhabitants resulting into complaints by the allottees e.g. in Dwarka.

18,859 characters total

(vi) Where defaulted amount is very small say 10%

(vii) If the allolttee comes out with the plan that he/she has applied for loan from financial institution to deposit the demanded amount with the DDA, he/she should furnish the proof given by the concerned financial institution clearly indicating that the loan would be disbursed to the applicant within a period of one year.

(viii) If it is established that in processing the case delay has been by DDA and very little time was left for the allottee to deposit the amount. All usual charges will continue to be levied in the cases where condonation will be granted. This issues with the approval of V.C.”

8. A further Resolution came to be passed by the Housing Department, DDA vide item No.29/05 clarifying the policy for restoration of cancelled DDA flats. The same is as follows: “The Authority vide its resolution No.46/2001 (Appendix-A) has resolved as under:

(i) These decisions shall only to the future cases of restoration where DDA is at fault.

(ii) The Commissioner (II) shall be competent to approve restoration for delay in payment upto one year.

(iii) No restoration shall be normally allowed where delays are beyond one year. However, the Vice Chairman, DDA, shall be competent to approve restoration for delays upto three years, in deserving cases. (Emphasis supplied)

(iv) Restoration beyond three years can be permitted only in extremely deserving cases by the Vice Chairman with the prior approval of Chairman. (Emphasis supplied) It has been observed that as per above stipulation (i), restoration is to be done where DDA is at fault which shows that where the allottee is at fault, no restoration is allowed. This is contrary to the stipulations mentioned as Sl.No.(ii to iv) of the said resolution as the Vice Chairman and the Chairman DDA are the only Competent Authority in deserving /extremely cases. In the cases where DDA is at fault, then DDA has to restore the allotment of flats and in the cases where allottee are at fault, those can be considered under the category of deserving/extremely deserving cases. As such the matter needs reconsideration by the Authority.

PROPOSAL It is proposed that so far as the competency and period is concerned, there is no need to reconsider the Authority Resolution NO.46/2001 but the stipulation (i) in it need to be deleted to be in conformity with stipulations at Sl.No.(ii to iv). The expression ‘where DDA is at fault’ is to be deleted.”

9. Our attention was drawn to the order dated 6th July, 2007 passed in WP(C) No.8627/2006 titled Hari Kishan Madan v. DDA wherein this Court held that the policy decision taken on 31st August, 2001 makes a distinction between ‘deserving cases’ where delay can be condoned by the Vice Chairman for defaults beyond one year and six months and in most deserving cases where cases of delay beyond three years can be condoned with prior approval of Chairman. The Court categorically held that authority to extend time exists under the resolution dated 31st August, 2001 but the same has to be exercised in deserving cases or most deserving cases as stipulated. In paragraph 5 of the said order the Court observed as follows:

“5. This Court is of the considered view that the earlier order dated 21st March, 2007 has not merited the consideration it deserved at the hands of the DDA. The view expressed that the case is not covered by the policy dated 1.6.2000 is not correct since the instances mentioned therein were only illustrative. Secondly, under the revised policy of 31.8.2001 the Vice Chairman,DDA had to form a definitive opinion that the case was either a ‘deserving case’ or not. That opinion is not available on file. Thirdly, the mere statement that the facts of the present case are not the same as those in Harbans Kaur’s case does not satisfy the requirement of the policy. No two cases can have identical facts. The reference to that case was only to enable the Vice Chairman to form an opinion on whether the case was a ‘deserving case.”

10. In the present case the authority has not followed the direction while dealing with the request made by the appellant for condonation of the delay in depositing the balance initial amount. In the impugned order dated 15th November, 2006 it has been merely stated that the regularisation of the period has been examined by the Competent Authority and the same was not acceded to. It is virtually a nonspeaking order not setting out any reason as to why the present case does not qualify for condonation of delay in payment. In the present case, the application for allotment was made as far back as in 1979. The appellant is a heart patient and had to wait for more than 28 years for his turn for allotment of the flat. The appellant had just retired from service and was not in a position to deposit the entire amount though he had deposited an amount of Rs.[2] lacs in the first instance. The appellant had thereafter deposited the entire amount with interest for the delayed period and had also deposited monthly instalments upto date as per the allotment letter. In the facts and circumstances of the case particularly when the appellant had deposited the entire amount with interest and complied with the terms and conditions of the allotment letter, it would be highly unjust to deny him the relief of condonation of delay. In our opinion this is a deserving case for condonation of delay.

11. In the result, the appeal is allowed and the impugned order dated 21st January, 2008 is set aside. Cancellation of the allotment is quashed and DDA is directed to hand over possession of MIG flat bearing No.542, Pocket-A, Sector-13, Phase-II, Dwarka, New Delhi to the appellant subject to payment of balance monthly instalments falling due after September, 2005, on completion of all other necessary formalities.

CHIEF JUSTICE S.MURALIDHAR MAY 14, 2008 JUDGE “v”