Full Text
LPA NO.1750/2005
Date of Decision: 15th May, 2008
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION OF DELHI …..APPELLANT
Through: Ms.Amita Gupta with Ms.Archana, Advocates
Through: None
HON’BLE DR. JUSTICE S.MURALIDHAR
1.Whether reporters of the local news papers be allowed to see the
JUDGMENT
2.To be referred to the Reporter or not ?
3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest ? AJIT PRAKASH SHAH, CJ (Oral) CM No.11637/2005 Heard. For the reasons stated in the application, we allow the same. Delay in filing the appeal stands condoned. The application stands disposed of. LPA 1750/2006 & CM 11638/2005
1. This appeal is filed by the Municipal Corporation of Delhi (MCD for short) against the order dated 1st December, 2004 passed by the learned Single Judge dismissing the writ petition filed by the MCD (LPA 1750/2005) 2008:DHC:1659-DB challenging the order of the Tribunal directing for refund of excess amount deposited with interest @ 15% p.a.. A review petition filed by the MCD was also dismissed.
2. The facts leading to the filing of the appeal are few and may be shortly stated: The respondent had filed an appeal against the assessment order passed by the MCD. The respondent had deposited tax which was required to be paid as per the assessment order. The appeal succeeded and the matter was remanded for refixation of the rateable value. After the rateable value was refixed, the demand of tax was redetermined. It came to light that the respondent had deposited excess tax. The respondent made a request for refund of excess tax to MCD which was declined. Respondent therefore approached the Tribunal by way of an application under Section 144 CPC seeking restitution. Restitution was allowed with interest by order dated 29th September, 2004 which was challenged by the MCD by filing a writ petition. The writ petition was dismissed by the learned Single Judge by order dated 1st December, 2004 which is under challenge in the present appeal.
3. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant –MCD submitted that if any excess tax paid by the assessee is to be refunded, then MCD can adjust the excess tax towards payment of tax for future years, but in the present case excess amount was wrongly directed to be refunded to the assessee. The submission is without any merit. There is no provision in the Delhi Municipal Corporation Act, 1957 permitting adjustment of excess tax towards future payment. If the assessee had paid excess tax required by law to be paid as a condition precedent for the assessee to avail the right of appeal and if the assessee succeeds the excess tax is liable to be refunded.
4. The second submission of the learned counsel for the MCD is that the Tribunal ought not have directed payment of interest on the amount of refund and, in any event, the interest granted @ 15% p.a. is excessive and unreasonable. We are afraid that this contention of the counsel is also without any merit. When the MCD is enjoying the amount of excess tax which the MCD was not entitled to have, then there is no reason why the assessee should be deprived of the benefit of the interest which otherwise he was entitled to if he had deposited the said amount in bank or invested in the market. The MCD has used this amount and the assessee was deprived of the same. It is also required to be noted that in this case that during the relevant time the MCD used to charge interest @ 22% p.a. for delayed payment of tax. In the facts and circumstances of the case we feel that interest @ 15% p.a. cannot be said to be excessive or unreasonable.
5. We may add that a Division Bench of the Gujarat High Court in Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation v. Vireshchand Chandrakant Desai (AIR 2002 Gujarat 379) has held that the order of grant of refund of excess amount is not enough and the Corporation is liable to pay interest @ 15% p.a. on the amount refunded.
6. Under the circumstances, we do not see any reason to interfere with the order of the learned Single Judge. Consequently, the appeal is dismissed. The pending application also stands closed.
CHIEF JUSTICE S.MURALIDHAR (Judge) MAY 15, 2008 “v”