Full Text
A.A. No.95/2008 & O.M.P. No. 141/2008
Date of Decision: 15.5.2008 SATYABRAT SHARMA ..... Petitioner
Through Mr.Suresh Sharma
Through Nemo
JUDGMENT
1. Whether Reporters of Local papers may be allowed to see the Judgment? No
2. To be referred to the Reporter or not? No
3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? No HIMA KOHLI, J. (ORAL)
1. The present petition is filed by the petitioner under Section 11 (5) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (in short `the Act‟) for appointment of an arbitrator to adjudicate the disputes interse the parties. Counsel for the petitioner submits that the petitioner is running a business of printing, publication and sale of books in Hindi language and is the proprietor of the firm, M/s Kitab 2008:DHC:1654 Ghar Prakashan. He submits that the respondent, who is an author, requested the petitioner to publish his novel, whereafter several meetings and conversations took place between the parties and finally an agreement dated 31.1.2007, was executed between the parties. He submits that the aforesaid agreement contained an Arbitration Clause being Clause No.17, which stipulates that the Courts in Delhi will have the power to adjudicate upon the disputes between the parties.
2. Counsel for the petitioner submits that the respondent forwarded to the petitioner a CD of the novel and the petitioner was required to give a print out of the novel to the respondent for his approval. It is stated that a print out of the novel was forwarded to the respondent for approval but the respondent all of a sudden asked the petitioner to stop the printing/ publishing of his novel. A perusal of the petition shows that the petitioner has not furnished any details as to the nature of the disputes that have arisen between the petitioner and the respondent, monetary or otherwise, except for making an ambiguous statement in para 7 (d) of the petition to the effect that the respondent was reminded about the Arbitration Agreement existing between the parties since the petitioner was threatened of the criminal action by the respondent.
3. In the course of arguments, counsel for the petitioner was called upon to indicate from the records, the letter/request addressed by the petitioner to the respondent, thereby invoking the Arbitration Clause governing the parties, and calling upon him to agree on a named Arbitrator. Counsel for the petitioner places reliance on the term „request‟ as used in Section 11 (5) of the Act, and in that light submits that the provisions of Section 11 (5) do not mandate the petitioner to give any written request to the respondent for invocation of the arbitration clause. Counsel for the petitioner draws the attention of this Court to the last para of the legal notice dated 1.2.2008 addressed to him on behalf of the respondent wherein it is stated that “lastly, my client strictly state that neither you should send any mediator or any person to arbitrate in the matter in future. This is for your information and record.” He states that receipt of the said legal notice was a sufficient ground in itself for the petitioner to invoke the provisions of Section 11 (5) of the Act. In support of his contention that filing of the present petition itself may be deemed to be sufficient notice, counsel for the petitioner refers to a judgment reported at 98 (III) AD Delhi 378 entitled ABG Heavy Industries Versus Indian Oil Corporation.
4. I have heard the counsel for the petitioner. It is pertinent to note that while notice was issued on the aforesaid petition on 3.3.2008, and the respondent was served by registered AD post, however, a refusal report was received by this Court as a result of which the respondent was proceeded against ex-parte vide order dated 6.5.2008. On the said date, during the course of submissions, counsel for the petitioner was called upon to address arguments on the maintainability of the present petition in view of failure on the part of the petitioner to place any document on record whereby the petitioner had called upon the respondent to appoint an Arbitrator within 30 days from the date of receipt of a request to the said effect made by him before filing the present petition. The stand of the petitioner, as indicated above, is that the threat extended by the respondent in the legal notice and refusal to accept notice of the present petition show the conduct of the respondent and his belligerency, and are sufficient to deem service on him as envisaged in the statute.
5. A perusal of the provisions of Section 11 (5) of the Act shows that in case there is no agreement arrived at between the parties, as referred to in sub-section (2) of Section 11, and if parties fail to appoint an Arbitrator within 30 days from the receipt of a request to do so from the other party, the appointment shall be made, upon the request of a party, by the Chief Justice or any person or Institution designated by him. The contention of the counsel for the petitioner that „request‟ as envisaged under the provisions of Subsection (5) of Section 11 does not require the petitioner to send a written request, is on the face of it untenable for the reason that receipt of the said request is the basis of calculating the period of 30 days as fixed under the Statute. Failure on the part of the petitioner to indicate the date of request is sufficient reason to oust the present petition. The interpretation as sought to be given by the petitioner to the provision, if accepted would frustrate the entire object inasmuch as the period of 30 days which are stipulated by the Statute to be given by one party to the other for appointment of an arbitrator can never be calculated in the absence of any request in writing. Hence the distinction sought to be made by counsel for the petitioner between the provisions of Sections 11 (4) and 11 (5) insofar as receipt of request is concerned, cannot be so drawn.
6. The other plea raised on behalf of the petitioner that filing of the present petition itself is sufficient notice to the respondent is also devoid of merits. Merely because a notice was issued to the respondent by the Court in the present petition, when in fact it was not brought to the notice of the Court by the petitioner that he had not served a prior notice on the respondent for appointment of an arbitrator as mandated under Section 11 (5) of the Act, cannot be a ground for the petitioner to make good his own wrong. The petitioner has to stand or fall on his own legs and cannot seek the crutches of a Court notice to try and make up his own default. If the requirements of law as stipulated under the provisions of Section 11 (5) of the Act were not met by the petitioner prior to institution of the petition, the same cannot be made good merely because notice was issued by the Court on the petition. The petitioner cannot also take advantage of the legal notice issued by the respondent to him as the same cannot be made the basis of institution of a petition under Section 11 (5) of the Act.
7. For the aforesaid reasons, in the absence of any proof placed on the record by the petitioner of dispatch of a request to the respondent for appointment of an Arbitrator, to enable the Court to calculate expiry of 30 days therefrom and draw an assumption of refusal to act on the part of the respondent, the AA No.95/2008 is liable to be rejected. Incidentally, though it is not relevant to decide the arbitration petition, but it may be noticed that the petitioner has failed to give the particulars of the disputes which he states have arisen with the respondent, for the purpose of invoking the arbitration clause. Accordingly, AA No.95/2008 is dismissed as not being maintainable for want of compliance of the provisions of Section 11 (5) of the Act.
8. As regards OMP No.141/2008, filed by the petitioner under Section 9 of the Act, for grant of interim measures though for purposes of filing such an application, the same is not dependent on the pendency of any arbitration proceedings or an application for appointment of an arbitrator, the same being maintainable even prior to invocation of the arbitration clause, the petitioner has not been able to make out a prima facie case for grant of any interim relief at this stage. Considering the fact that A.A. No.95/2008 has been dismissed, the present application is also disposed of while declining the relief sought for by the petitioner, as the averments made in the application are rather sketchy and unsubstantiated with material facts.
9. Needless to state that dismissal of the present petitions shall not bar the petitioner from invoking the provisions of Section 9 of the Act by filing a more substantive application and from invoking the provisions of Section 11 (5) of the Act after following the due process as mandated in the statute and filing fresh petitions, if necessary, for the same reliefs. HIMA KOHLI,J MAY 15, 2008 `ns‟/rb/sk