Vishwanath Bharat v. Ritu Bharat

Delhi High Court · 07 May 2008 · 2008:DHC:1569
Siddharth Mridul
Civil Misc.(Main) No. 505/2008
2008:DHC:1569
civil petition_dismissed

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court upheld the Trial Court's dismissal of a maintenance compromise application and review petition, holding that an electronic recording without a signed written agreement does not constitute a valid compromise under Order 23 Rule 3 CPC.

Full Text
Translation output
CM(M) No. 505/2008 HIGH COURT OF DELHI Civil Misc.(Main) No. 505/2008
Reserved on : 25th April, 2008
Date of Decision: 7th May, 2008 # VISHWANATH BHARAT ..... Petitioner
! Through: Mr.Vijay Tandon, Adv.
VERSUS
$ RITU BHARAT ..... Respondent ^ Through: None
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SIDDHARTH MRIDUL
JUDGMENT

1. Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?

2. To be referred to the Reporter or not?

3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest?

JUDGMENT

SIDDHARTH MRIDUL, J. The present petition, under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, assails the common order dated 26th February, 2008 passed by the Additional District Judge, Delhi in Suit No. 99/1999 whereby the learned Trial Court dismissed the applications for review as well as under Order 23 Rule 3 respectively, filed by the petitioner-husband. 2008:DHC:1569

2. The petitioner states that the respondent-wife had instituted a suit under Section 18 of the Hindu Adoption and Maintenance Act, 1956 seeking therein maintenance @ Rs.2000/- per month. The learned Trial Court decided that application and granted interim maintenance @ Rs.2200/- per month vide an order dated 20th November, 2007. The petitioner herein filed an application for review of order granting interim maintenance (challenging quantum of maintenance). The petitioner states that during the pendency of the review petition, the petitioner negotiated for compromise, and according to him the parties came to settlement, whereby it was agreed that the petitioner pay a sum of Rs.1,50,000/- towards full and final settlement of all claims of the respondent towards past, present and future maintenance.

3. The petitioner states that the entire conversation pertaining to the negotiations for compromise, that took place on 10th December, 2007, was recorded by the petitioner in his MP-3 Player and transferred to his personal computer for generating a compact disk(CD). The petitioner, thereupon, filed an application under Order

4. The respondent-wife, filed a reply denying the factum of any settlement in respect of maintenance or otherwise having been arrived at between the parties. She further denied that she had agreed to receive a sum of Rs.1,50,000/- or any other amount from the defendant, in view of her past, present and future claims.

5. The Trial Court, after due consideration of the facts, submissions and judicial precedents, dismissed the application under Order 23 Rule 3, inter alia, reaching a finding that apparently the application had been filed by the petitioner-defendant alone under his signatures and that the amount purportedly settled had never been offered or deposited, even after a direction in this behalf dated 5th February, 2008. Further, that it was not clear from the terms of the purported settlement, as to in how much time the said liability was to be met. The learned Trial Court returned a finding that there was no completed agreement between the parties, since the provision required a compromise to be in writing and signed by all parties; and that in any event, in view of the decision of the Supreme Court in AIR 1988 SC 400; where it had been held that, where the parties enter into a compromise and a party resiles from the proposed compromise before it could be recorded, the compromise cannot be recorded in view of the resilience by a party; no compromise or settlement occasioning an application under Order 23 Rule 3 was validly concluded.

6. Vide the same order, the learned Trial Court Judge dismissed the application for review, holding that the order under review, dated 20th November, 2007, had taken into account all the relevant aspects before awarding interim maintenance to the respondent-wife. The learned Trial Court found that the order dated 20th November, 2007, apart from granting interim maintenance of Rs.2000/- per month, had also taken into consideration the application for provision for separate residence filed by respondent-wife and that it was in this background that a sum of Rs.2200/- per month was awarded to the respondentwife. The learned Trial Court held that a review is by no means an appeal in disguise whereby an arguably erroneous decision may be re-heard or corrected, but that it can only be entertained to correct patent error, which error was not evident in the order under review.

7. The learned Trial Court, while dismissing the application under Order 23 Rule 3 CPC, further imposed a cost of Rs.500/-, holding that the application had been filed to sidetrack the main issue and avoid paying interim maintenance, in a case that was 8½ years old. The learned Trial Court also dismissed the application for review with cost of Rs. 2000/- for the same reason.

8. Counsel, appearing on behalf of the petitioner, submitted that the electronic record of the negotiations, produced by him in support of the application under Order 23 Rule 3, is a document within the meaning of the Evidence Act, and that in an electronic voice recording the signature is not required in terms of the Evidence Act. Counsel urged that, in case the opposite party had denied the compromise, a duty was cast upon the learned Court, to decide the question about the validity and satisfaction as arrived at in the purported compromise, by summoning the alleged witness to the compromise and confronting both the respondent-wife as well as the alleged witness with the recorded conversation. The counsel also submitted that, the review petition ought to have been deferred till such time that the application moved under Order 23 Rule 3 had been decided, and further that the costs imposed were in the nature of a penalty and untenable in law.

9. I have gone through the impugned order and the judgments relied upon therein and heard submissions made by the learned counsel for the petitioner. The decision impugned in the present petition is an intra vires finding of fact and does not suffer from the vice of perversity or of being founded on no material whatsoever. The learned Trial Judge, after due consideration of the facts and circumstances of the case and judicial pronouncements, rightly came to the conclusion that for the provision of Order 23 Rule 3 to apply, there must be a completed agreement in writing between the parties and that in the present case, the basic requirement of a compromise, that it must be signed by all parties was conspicuous by its absence, and therefore the purported negotiations were of no avail to the petitioner. I see no error apparent in the finding returned by the learned Trial Court based on proper consideration of the facts and the law.

10. Insofar as the submissions of the learned counsel relating to the recording of evidence to decide the question of the factum of compromise after due enquiry is concerned, the same is specious and does not hold any water. The proviso to Order 23 Rule 3 provides that, the court shall decide the question, whether an adjustment or satisfaction has been arrived at, where it is alleged by one party and denied by the other, that a suit has been adjusted or the claim of the plaintiff has been satisfied. However, in the facts and circumstances as existed in the present case, the proviso did not call for or mandate a mini trial requiring evidence to be recorded to determine whether an adjustment or satisfaction had been arrived at. Particularly, since the provision itself postulates that the lawful agreement or compromise arrived at between the parties has to be in writing and signed by the parties thereto.

11. The submission made by the counsel for the petitioner, that the disputed recording was a document evidencing the settlement or compromise and consequently enforceable and therefore the learned Trial Judge ought to have summoned witness and recorded evidence to decide this issue, is without any merit whatsoever. In my considered opinion the power of superintendence conferred upon the High Court under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, invokes a duty on the High Court to keep the inferior courts and tribunals within the bound of their authority, and to see that they do what their duty requires, and that they do it in a legal manner. The power ought to be exercised, limited to correcting an error of law apparent on the face of the record or to set aside a finding which is perverse in law. There is no error apparent on the face of the record or perversity in the order impugned to warrant any interference by this Court. In view of the aforesaid, the present petition is devoid of merit and is consequently dismissed.

8,318 characters total

SIDDHARTH MRIDUL, J. May 7, 2008 mk