Full Text
A.A.No.426/2006 & IA No.11299/2006
Date of Decision: 05.05.2008 IN THE MATTER OF :
#MYCO ELECTRICALS (P) LTD. .Petitioner ! Through: Mr. K. R. Gupta with
Mr. S. K. Gupta and Ms. Kiran Dharma, Advocates
JUDGMENT
1. Whether Reporters of Local papers may be allowed to see the Judgment? No
2. To be referred to the Reporter or not? No
3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? No HIMA KOHLI, J. (ORAL) The present petition is preferred by the petitioner u/s 11(6) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996(hereinafter referred to as `the Act‟) praying inter alia for appointment of an independent arbitrator to decide the disputes arising out of and in connection with a tender opened on 1.12.2003 read with the purchase order dated 2008:DHC:1549 11.10.2006, whereafter, appearance was entered on behalf of the respondents and reply was filed.
2. The respondents have taken a preliminary objection as to the lack of territorial jurisdiction of this court to entertain the present petition on the ground that clause 2703 of the contract stipulates that the courts of the place from where the acceptance of tender has been issued shall alone have jurisdiction to decide any dispute arising out or in respect of the contract. Counsel for the respondents submits that in the present case, the tender was accepted and issued from Mumbai and hence the High Court at Mumbai alone has the jurisdiction to try and entertain the present petition or any proceeding arising out of, or in respect of the contract in question. Counsel for the respondents has relied on the following judgments:
1. Globe Transport Corporation v. Triveni Engineering Works & Anr., 1983 (4) SCC 707; 2 ONGC v. Utpal Kumar Basu & Ors., JT 1994 (5) SC 1; and
3. Bloom Dekor Ltd. v. Subhash Himatlal Desai & Ors., 1994 (6) SCC 322.
3. Per contra, learned counsel for the petitioner relies on clauses 2400-2401 of the contract to state that the said clauses have to be read in conjunction with clause 2703 and that the said clause 2703 cannot operate independent of clause 2401. He submits that the cause of action has arisen in the present case not only in Mumbai, but also at Delhi for the reason that the purchase order was received by the petitioner in Delhi and that the goods were to be dispatched from Delhi and inspection of the same was to be carried out by the respondent no.2 at Delhi.
4. Counsel for the petitioner relies on the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of A.B.C.Laminart Pvt.Ltd. and another Vs. A.P.Agencies, Salem reported as AIR 1989 1239 to state that if a contract is performed at a place where it is made, a suit in relation to the contract is to be filed there and nowhere else and that a suit can only be filed in a court within whose jurisdiction the acceptance was communicated. Thus, it is contended on behalf of the petitioner that a suit in respect of the breach can always be filed at a place where any part of the cause of action arises.
5. So as to adjudicate the dispute raised with regard relevant to refer to clauses 2400, 2401 and 2703 which are reproduced as under: “Clause 2400: Withholding and lien in respect of sums claimed. Clause 2401: Whenever any claim or claims for payment of a sum of money arises out of or under the contract against the Contractor, the Purchaser shall be entitled to withhold and also have a lien to retain such sum or sums in whole or in part from the security, if any, deposited by the Contractor and for the purpose aforesaid, the Purchaser shall be entitled to withhold the said cash security deposit or the security, if any, furnished as the case may be and also have a lien over the same pending finalization of adjudication of any such claim. In the event of the security being insufficient to cover the claimed amount or amounts or if no security has been taken from the Contractor, the Purchaser shall be entitled to withhold and have lien to retain to the extent of the such claimed amount or amounts referred to supra, from any sum or sums found payable or which at any time thereafter may become payable to the Contractor under the same contract or any other contract with the Purchaser or the Government pending finalization or adjudication of any such claim. It is an agreed term of the contract that the sum of money or moneys so withheld or retained under the lien referred to above, by the Purchaser will be kept withheld or retained as such by the Purchaser till the claim arising out of or under the contract is determined by the Arbitrator (if the contract is governed by the arbitration clause) or by the competent court as Contractor will have no claim for interest or damages whatsoever on any account in respect of such withholding or retention under the lien referred to supra and duly notified as such to the Contractor. Clause 2703 Jurisdiction of courts.- The Courts of the place from where the acceptance of tender has been issued shall alone have jurisdiction to decide any dispute arising out of or in respect of the contract.”
6. A perusal of the clauses 2400-2401 shows that the said clauses deal with the issues of withholding and lien in respect of sums claimed for payment of money arising out of a contract against the Contractor. In this context, clause 2401 mandates that the sums of money withheld or retained under lien shall be so withheld or retained by the Purchaser till the claim arising out of or under the contract is determined by the Arbitrator or by the competent Court as prescribed under clause 2703. Reliance placed by the counsel for the petitioner on the term „court‟ as defined under Section 2(1)(e) of the Act to state that it means a court having jurisdiction to decide the subject matter of a suit and as the courts in Delhi have the jurisdiction to entertain a suit, then the petitioner can file a petition under perusal of clause 2401, it in no manner circumscribes clause
2703. Clause 2703 is the only clause in the agreement governing the parties which deals with the jurisdiction aspect and makes it manifest that the parties thereto have by agreement consented to confer jurisdiction on a court within the local limits of which acceptance of tender was issued, namely, Mumbai.
7. There is no quarrel with the proposition of law put forth by the counsel for the petitioner that a suit can be filed where a part of the performance of the contract is to be made or where the contract is executed. However, in a case where parties chose to vest jurisdiction on a particular court and exclude by agreement, the jurisdiction of other courts, the aforesaid principle cannot come to the aid of the petitioner. As noted above, it is not a case where no part of cause of action has arisen in Mumbai.
8. It is not disputed by the petitioner that the acceptance of tender was issued from Mumbai. It is an admitted position that goods were to be supplied at Mumbai. It is not even the case of the petitioner that no part of cause of action accrued in the territorial jurisdiction of Mumbai and Court, within the local limits of which, nothing material occurred. Hence, it cannot be stated that the parties have chosen a particular Court for the purposes of conferring territorial jurisdiction, wherein no part of cause of action has accrued at all.
9. The plea of the counsel for the petitioner that part of the cause of action arose in Delhi as the goods were inspected in Delhi and payments were received at Delhi, is well answered by clause 2702 of the contract which makes it clear that irrespective of the place of delivery, the place of performance or place of the payment under the contract, the contract shall be deemed to have been made at the place from which the acceptance of tender has been issued.
10. The argument of the counsel for the respondents that the petitioner has independently impleaded the Ministry of Railways, Union of India as a party so as to vest jurisdiction on this Court is however devoid of merits as the counsel for the petitioner draws the attention of this Court to the first page of the contract which starts by describing the `Purchaser‟ as the President of India and the Indian Government is referred to as a party. However, this fact in by the Supreme Court in the case of ONGC Vs. Utpal Kumar Basu reported at JT 1994 (5) SC 1, the question of territorial jurisdiction must be decided on the facts pleaded in the petition. In the present case, when parties themselves have agreed to vest jurisdiction on a Court within the local limits of which the acceptance of tender was issued, the petitioner cannot be heard to state that the present petition for appointment of an arbitrator to adjudicate the disputes between the parties ought to be entertained by this Court.
11. In view of the aforesaid decision, it is held that the present petition cannot be entertained by this Court for want of territorial jurisdiction. However, the petitioner is at liberty to invoke the provisions of Section 11 of the Act by seeking appointment of an Arbitrator in terms of clause 2703 of the Contract. It is also clarified that the observations made hereinabove are only for the purposes of deciding the maintainability of the present petition in this Court and shall not be construed as an observation on the merits of the case.
12. The petition is dismissed along with the pending application. Interim order stands vacated. MAY 05, 2008 (HIMA KOHLI) rb JUDGE