Full Text
LPA 198/2008
Date of Decision: 9th May, 2008 Mr. Avtar Narain Behal ...Appellant
Through: Mr. Ratna Aggarwal, Advocate
Through: None.
JUDGMENT
1. Whether Reporters of Local papers may be allowed to see the Judgment?
2. To be referred to the Reporter or not?
3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? J.R. Midha, J. This case relates to the estate of late Shri Gopal Das Behal who expired on 4th July, 1990. The Respondent filed a petition for grant of probate/letters of administration in respect of the Will dated 19th October, 1972 read with codicil dated 25th April, 1990 executed by late Shri Gopal Das Behal before the District Judge, Delhi. The learned District Judge allowed the petition and granted letters of administration to the respondent vide judgment dated 16th October, 2003. The appellant filed an appeal being FAO No.420/2003 under Section 299 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 before the learned Single Judge which was dismissed on 31st March, 2008. The appellant has filed this LPA against the order of the learned Single Judge. The question arisen for our consideration is maintainability of this LPA in view of Section 100A of the Code of Civil Procedure. 2008:DHC:1590-DB Section 100A, as amended by the Amendment Act, 2002 made applicable w.e.f. 1st July, 2002, of the Code of Civil Procedure reads as under:- “Section 100A. No further appeal in certain cases.- Notwithstanding anything contained in any Letters Patent for any High Court or in any other instrument having the force of law or in any other instrument having the force of law or in any other law for the time being in force, where any appeal from an original or appellate decree or order is heard and decided by a Single Judge of a High Court, no further appeal shall lie from the judgment and decree of such Single Judge.” In the case of Satish Chander Sabharwal and Anr. Vs. State, 122 (2005) DLT 170 (DB), the Division Bench of this Court dealt with the same issue and held that no Letters Patent Appeal would be maintainable from the order passed by the Single Judge in the first appeal. The Division Bench dismissed the Letters Patent Appeal as nonmaintainable. The findings of the Division Bench in the said case are as under:-
The learned Counsel for the appellant has referred to and relied upon the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Subal Paul Vs. Malina Paul, AIR 2003 SC 1928 where the Supreme Court before the District Judge, Agartala, which was rejected against which the appellant preferred an appeal under Section 299 of the Indian Succession Act before the Guwahati High Court. The learned Single Judge of the High Court allowed the appeal and granted letter of administration against which the Letters Patent Appeal was preferred before the Bench of the High Court and the issue of maintainability of the appeal arose for consideration. The Hon’ble Supreme Court held that Letters Patent Appeal challenging the decision of Single Judge would be maintainable. It was held that Section 104 of the Code specifies the matters which would be appealable and no other and the appeals from orders are provided for in Order 43 Rule 1 of the Code which contain a full list of appealable orders. However, it does not contemplate orders or decrees passed under a special statute. Section 299 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 provides for appeals from the orders of District Judge before the High Court in accordance with the provisions of the Code. A final order passed in respect of proceedings under the said Act were, thus, held to be judgment within the meaning of Section 2(9) of the Code. Sub-section (2) of Section 104 of the code provides that no appeal shall lie from any order passed in appeal under that Section. It was, thus, held that if the appeal is provided under any other law, Section 104 of the Code would have no application. It was, thus, held that the Orders passed by learned Single Judge was appealable to the Letters Patent Bench. The judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Subal Paul’s case relates to the maintainability of the LPA filed prior to the amendment of concerned with the maintainability of the LPA in view of Section 100A amended by Amendment Act, 2002 applicable w.e.f. 1st July, 2002. The judgment of the Supreme Court in Subal Paul’s case has been considered by the Division Bench of this Court in Satish Chander Sabharwal’s case. However, it was distinguished on the ground that the learned Single Judge of the High Court in that case was hearing the proceedings under Section 299 of the Act. Para 14 of the judgment of the Division Bench of this Court is reproduced hereunder:-
The learned Counsel for the Appellant has pointed out that the learned Single Judge of the Guwahati High Court in Subal Paul’s case was not dealing with the original petition but was hearing the first appeal under Section 299 of the Succession Act, as in Satish Chander Sabharwal’s case and therefore, the distinction made in the later case is not correct. In view of this, it has to be determined as to whether the ratio of the judgment in Subal Paul’s case still holds the field after the amendment of Section 100A by Amendment Act, 2002. We are of the view that the aforesaid reasons given by the Division Bench of this Court in Satish Chander Sabharwal’s case on the basis of which the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Subal Paul’s case has been distinguished are not correct and, therefore, the matter requires consideration by a larger Bench. We, accordingly, refer the following question of law for determination by a larger Bench: “Whether the Letters Patent Appeal against the judgment of Single Judge of this Court in first appeal would be maintainable having regard to the provisions of Section 100A of the Code of Civil Procedure as amended by Amendment Act, 2002. The matter be listed before Hon’ble the Chief Justice for constituting a larger Bench on 11th July, 2008.
(J.R. MIDHA) JUDGE (A.K. SIKRI) May 9, 2008 JUDGE s.pal