Rajesh Gomes v. NDMC

Delhi High Court · 15 May 2008 · 2008:DHC:1653
Sanjiv Khanna
W.P.(C) 4844/1999
2008:DHC:1653
administrative appeal_allowed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court directed NDMC to conduct trade tests and regularize petitioners as LMV drivers based on prior service and policy, rejecting arbitrary re-dating of their regularization.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
W.P.(C) 4844/1999
RAJESH GOMES & ORS ..... Petitioners
Through Ms. Shobhna Takiyar, Adv.
VERSUS
NDMC & ORS ..... Respondents
Through Ms. Jyoti Singh, Adv.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJIV KHANNA O R D E R 15.05.2008
JUDGMENT

1. The petitioners have been working as drivers since 1987 and were initially enrolled as Temporary Muster Roll employees.

2. On 24.5.1993 a circular was issued asking Temporary Muster Roll employees to apply for posts of Light Motor Vehicle driver cum fitter against direct recruitment quota. Thereafter, in 1994 the petitioners were informed that they should appear for a trade test and if they qualify they shall be posted as Regular Muster Roll drivers.

3. The petitioners appeared in the said trade test and were appointed as Regular Muster Roll drivers on 17.8.1994.

4. Surprisingly, NDMC in 2002 again enrolled petitioners as Regular Muster Roll employees on the ground that they had completed 500 days of service as Temporary Muster Roll employees. NDMC lost sight of the 2008:DHC:1653 fact that they had already been posted as Regular Muster Roll employees pursuant to policy decision taken by them and after the petitioners had cleared the trade test in 1994. It is not understandable, why and how the petitioners are being treated as Regular Muster Roll employees w.e.f. 2002, when they had already been enrolled way back in 1994 as Regular Muster Roll employees -drivers.

5. The petitioners have made allegations that several others who are juniors to the petitioners have been regularised as drivers. I am not inclined to go into these aspects because the initial appointment of the petitioners was without a proper selection process. However, NDMC has taken a policy decision to regularize services of Regular Muster Roll employees-Drivers, depending upon the vacancy position. It is stated by the learned counsel for the NDMC that as and when regular posts are available Regular Muster Roll employees-Drivers are being appointed subject to their clearing trade test and approval from the Selection Committee. In this regard, attention of the Court has been drawn to the decision of a Division Bench in writ petition nos. 646/1994, 4125/1995 and 4760/1995 wherein after considering the facts and circumstances, which are almost identical to the present case, the following directions were given: “Learned counsel for the respondent states that he has been instructed to say that with respect to the above mentioned five petitioners, letters of appointment will be issued within a period of two weeks from today. Their joining the regular post, however, will be subject to their being medically fit. Within two weeks the respondent will issue the appointment letters to the aforesaid five petitioners as HMV Drivers, who on completing the formality of undergoing medical tests will join their respective post, as per the appointment letters. Insofar as remaining petitioners are concerned, learned counsel for the respondent states that trade test will be conducted on 18.11.1996 at 11.00 a.m. at NDMC workshop at Laxmi Bai Nagar, New Delhi. The suggestion is fair and reasonable. We direct the remaining petitioners to make available for the trade test on the specified date at the stated place. The trade test will be conducted as per the usual norms. Whosoever is declared successful in the trade test will be offered regular appointment of HMV Driver in respondent NDMC subject to the fulfilling of the other requirements, namely, of having a valid HMV Driving licence with no punishment for accident during the last two years and of being medically fit.”

6. Keeping in view the above facts and as the petitioners have been working as Drivers since 1987 and as Regular Muster Roll Employees since 1994, similar directions are issued in the present case also. Respondent/NDMC will conduct trade test within 8 weeks and on the petitioners clearing the trade test and on approval by the Selection Committee they will be appointed on regular basis as LMV Drivers depending upon vacancy position and subject to their satisfying all conditions mentioned in the order passed in Writ Petition No. 646/1994 and other cases. The writ petition is accordingly disposed of.

SANJIV KHANNA, J. MAY 15, 2008. Vld/P/vld