Full Text
LPA 49/2008
Sunita Baliyan …Appellant
Through: Mr.Varun Prasad, Advocate
Through: Mr.V.K. Tandon with Mr.Prem Mishra, Advocates
HON’BLE DR. JUSTICE S.MURALIDHAR
1.Whether reporters of the local newspapers be allowed to see the
JUDGMENT
2.To be referred to the Reporter or not ?no
3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest ?no
JUDGMENT
2. With the consent of the counsel appearing for the parties, the appeal is taken up for hearing.
3. This appeal under Clause 10 of the Letters Patent is directed against the order passed by the learned single Judge dated November 19, 2007 whereby the Civil Writ Petition No.7228/2007 filed by the appellant challenging the award dated March 20, 2006 passed by the Labour Court in ID No.175/2000 was dismissed in limine. LPA 49/2008 2008:DHC:1679-DB
4. Briefly stated, the facts leading to this appeal are as follows: The appellant was appointed as Anganwadi Worker with effect from May 19, 1997 and she had been performing the duties in Sangam Vihar Project at Anganwadi No.35 in Devli Village, Delhi. On November 5, 1998 she had gone on maternity leave, duly granted by the Supervisor Mr.Anil Sharma. The appellant extended her maternity leave upto January 25, 1999 and availed the same for two months and 20 days, though she was entitled to three months’ leave with pay. She went to join her duties on January 25, 1999, but was refused duties by Mr.Anil Sharma. It is claimed by the appellant that her services were terminated by way of refusal of duties, though she had gone on maternity leave and, as such, her termination from the services was a clear violation of Section 12 of The Maternity Benefits Act, 1961, hereinafter referred to as the “Act”. The appellant sent a demand notice dated July 12, 1999 to the respondent, but no action was taken. She had not been reinstated in service. She was being paid wages less than minimum wages prescribed under the Minimum Wages Act. It was alleged that she had been performing her duties continuously without break with effect from July 19, 1997 to November 5, 1998, when she proceeded on maternity leave. It was alleged that her juniors are still working with the management. She raised an industrial dispute against her termination, which came to be referred to the Labour Court in the following terms: “Whether the services of Smt.Sunita Baliyan have been terminated illegally and/or unjustifiably by the management and if so, to what relief is she entitled and what directions are necessary in this respect?” The respondent management contested the claim and filed its written statement taking a preliminary objection that the claimant was not a regular workman. On merit, it was claimed that she had not been terminated from the service. It was claimed that she absented herself from duties with effect from November 5, 1998 without any intimation or prior permission from the management. There was thus no question of violation of Section 12 of the Act. It was claimed that she was an honorary worker and was not entitled to any leave including maternity leave. It was denied that she applied for maternity leave. It was claimed that she applied for leave due to some urgent work with effect from November 1, 1998 to November 15, 1998, but the same was not granted to her, as she was not entitled to any leave. It was claimed that she was engaged against a leave vacancy as honorary worker and she is not entitled to the benefit of maternity leave under the Act. It was denied that her services had been terminated. The claim of the management was that she was absent from her service with effect from November 5,
1998. On the pleading of the parties, two issues were framed. The first issue framed was whether the claimant was an honorary worker, and the second issue was in terms of the reference made by the appropriate government. After hearing the parties, the first issue was decided in favour of the appellant. While deciding the second issue, the Labour Court referred to the provisions of Sections 6 and 12 of the Act, and noted that though the aforesaid provisions require a woman claiming entitlement to maternity benefit under the Act to give a notice in writing to the employer during her pregnancy or as soon as possible after delivery, in the present case, no material was placed on record by the appellant, of notice given to the respondent management claiming any maternity benefit. Hence, it was held that in the absence of any record that the appellant applied for leave, no benefit could be given to her. The plea of the appellant that her services were terminated by way of an oral order was also turned down on the ground that there was no material placed on the record that she made any representation against her illegal termination from service and that she raised her demand for the first time only on July 12, 1999. The Labour Court took notice of para 4 of Rule 4.21 of the General Guidelines applicable to the respondent management, which deals with Anganwadi Workers who are absent from duties and observed that the aforesaid Rule mandated that if any Anganwadi Worker was found absent without intimation, permission or application for a week at a time, the management shall serve 10 days’ notice to the defaulter and if she fails to report for duty within the stipulated period, her case shall be referred to the Headquarters for necessary action. It was observed in the impugned award that no notice was issued by the respondent management in terms of the aforesaid Rule and hence it was concluded that the services of the appellant were not terminated as yet and that the appellant absented herself from duties. The award of the Labour Court was challenged before the learned single Judge in the Writ Petition (Civil) No.7228/2007, which came to be dismissed by the learned single Judge in limine.
5. Mr.Varun Prasad, learned counsel appearing for the appellant, submitted that there is no dispute that the appellant was blessed with a child on November 21, 1998, she was discharged from the hospital on November 22, 1998 with advise to take complete bed rest at home for eight weeks. Every worker whether permanent or casual is entitled to three months’ leave under the Act during the pregnancy or after the pregnancy. He submitted that the Labour Court on his own and against the pleadings had come to the conclusion that no notice was given by the appellant to the respondent of her availing maternity leave. He pointed out that the case of the management was that casual / honorary workers are not entitled to the benefits of the Act and only regular workmen are entitled to the said benefits. It was not their case that they had no notice of the same, which is clear from the admission made in the written statement as well as in the cross examination of MW[1], Ms.Hem Lata. He submitted that even assuming that the appellant had absented herself, she should have been dealt with under Rule 4.21 and given notice and should have been proceeded departmentally before her services could have been terminated. He submitted that this is a case of proper maternity leave and the action of the management in refusing duties to her tantamount to her termination from service in clear violation of the Act.
6. In reply, Mr.V.K. Tandon, learned counsel appearing for the respondent, contended that none of the letters produced on record show that a request was made for seeking maternity leave in terms of Section 6 of the Act. In any case the last letter dated April 23, 1999 does not meet the requirement of Section 6 of the Act, for the reason that it was written almost five months after the delivery. He submitted that though the provisions of Section 6 does not mandate a woman to immediately intimate her employer of her pregnancy, but for claiming benefit of the Act it certainly calls upon her to give a notice in writing during her pregnancy or as soon as possible after the delivery. According to him, the provisions are intended to ensure that while a woman worker gets the maternity benefit, at the same time no inconvenience is caused to the establishment where she is engaged and adequate alternative arrangements can be made by the management to ensure that the work does not suffer in her absence. Learned counsel submitted that it is not a case of termination of the appellant, as the respondent management has not taken any steps against her in terms of Rule 4.21 of the General Guidelines governing the respondent management and the appellant had unauthorisedly absented herself from duty and, therefore, there is no ground to interfere with the award of the Labour Court.
7. Before adverting to the rival submissions made at the bar, we may take note of the admitted facts. It is not in dispute that the appellant was blessed with a boy on November 21, 1998 and she was discharged from the hospital on November 22, 1998. The provisions of the Act mandate that every worker is entitled to three months’ leave during the pregnancy or after pregnancy. It was the case of the management that a casual or honorary worker is not entitled to the benefit of the Act and only regular workmen are entitled to the said benefits. It was not their case that they had no notice, which is clear from the averments made by the respondent at paras 2,4,[5] and 6 of the written statement where it was admitted that the appellant had applied for leave, which was refused on the ground that she was a casual / honorary worker and she was not entitled to it. The relevant portion of the written statement is reproduced hereunder:-
8. We may also refer to the admission made by the management witness Ms.Hem Lata in cross examination:- “….. I do not know whether Anil Sharma concerned supervisor was allowed to workman to go for maternity leave or not. I did not see the record w.e.f. 05.11.98 upto 25.01.99 for availing maternity leave. It is correct that the monthly honorarium for paid wages in the month of Aug., Sept., and Oct., 1998 were paid. I cannot say when the payments were made to Smt.Sunita Walia. It is correct that management did not sent any letter for joining to Smt.Sunita Walian. I can’t say whether Smt.Sunita Walian was on maternity leave w.e.f. 05.11.98 upto 25.01.99. It is correct that I did not go through the document Ex.WW1/2, WW1/3 and 4. I cannot say about medical certificate Ex.WW1/6. I can’t say whether Sunita Walian was gainfully employed or not. It is wrong to say that I am deposing falsely.”
9. In view of the clear admissions made by the management in the written statement as well in the deposition, it is difficult to agree with the Labour Court that no notice for maternity benefit was given by the appellant. Even otherwise, the provisions of the Act do not prescribe any specific period for giving notice. The Labour Court completely ignored the representations of the appellant, which clearly prove that the respondent had sufficient notice of the appellant’s pregnancy.
10. At this stage, it is necessary to refer to the provisions of Section 12 of the Act, which read as follows:-
11. Learned counsel appearing for the appellant drew our attention to the decision of the Supreme Court in Municipal Corporation of Delhi v. Female Workers (Muster Roll) and Another AIR 2000 SC 1274, wherein the Supreme Court considered the availability of maternity benefits under the Maternity Benefits Act to muster roll employees. Upon a detailed consideration spirit and intendment of the statute as also the “Convention on the Elimination of all forms of discrimination against women”, the Court concluded as follows:
12. In Bharti Gupta (Ms.) v. Rail India Technical and Economical Services Limited (Rites) and Others 2005 VII AD (Delhi) 435, this Court was required to decide on an issue where an employee has been dismissed on account of pregnancy. Upon a detailed consideration of the provisions of the statute, this Court ruled that the grant of maternity benefits was as per the mandate of law. The Court held thus:
13. In the present case, the appellant had gone on maternity leave on November 5, 1998, which, according to her, was duly sanctioned by the Supervisor Mr.Anil Sharma and which was extended upto January 25, 1999 instead of November 15, 1998 as her baby was unwell. The appellant had availed of maternity leave for two months and 20 days though she was entitled to three months’ leave with pay. It is also seen from the correspondence placed on record that the appellant had approached the management for resumption of duties, but the Supervisor Mr.Anil Sharma did not allow her to resume duties and further representations made by her remained unanswered.
14. Para 4 of Rule 4.21 of the General Guidelines, which are applicable to the respondent management deal with Anganwadi Workers, who are absent from duty, reads as follows: “If any Anganwadi worker is found absent without any intimation, permission or application for a week at a time, the CDPO shall serve a ten days’ notice to the defaulter anganwadi worker and if she fails to report for duty within the stipulated period, then her case shall be referred to headquarters for necessary action.” It is an admitted position that the management did not send any letter to the appellant for joining in terms of para 4 of Rule
4.21 of the General Guidelines. We hasten to add that the aforesaid provision cannot be invoked for automatic termination of the workman without complying with principles of natural justice in the light of the decision of the Constitution Bench in the case of D.K. Yadav v. JMA Industries Ltd. 1993 II LLJ 696. The claim of the management that the appellant was appointed on ad hoc basis against the leave vacancy was explicitly rejected by the Labour Court. The management has not placed on record any document showing that she was appointed against a leave vacancy on ad hoc basis. In her cross examination she has denied that she was appointed on ad hoc basis against a leave vacancy. Ms.Hem Lata has admitted in her cross examination that no appointment letter was given to the appellant and no period was indicated at the time of her employment. She also admitted that the word “ad hoc” was not used while appointing her in the job. Consequently, the Labour Court has held that the appellant is a workman within the meaning of Section 2(s) of the Industrial Disputes Act.
15. For the reasons recorded herein above, the award of the Labour Court cannot be sustained. The award as well as the order under appeal are set aside. The appeal is allowed. The respondent is directed to reinstate the appellant forthwith as Anganwadi Worker with full back wages with continuity of service.
CHIEF JUSTICE S.MURALIDHAR, J May 16, 2008 “nm”