Zile Singh Tanwar & Co. v. Municipal Corporation of Delhi

Delhi High Court · 12 May 2008 · 2008:DHC:1607-DB
THE CHIEF JUSTICE; DR. JUSTICE S. MURALIDHAR
LPA No.226/2008
2008:DHC:1607-DB
administrative appeal_allowed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court quashed MCD's non-speaking orders debarring a contractor for non-execution of work without considering the contractor's explanation regarding regulatory sealing of its Hot Mix Plant.

Full Text
Translation output
LPA No.226/2008 HIGH COURT OF DELHI LPA No.226/2008
Zile Singh Tanwar & Co. & Anr. …..Appellants
Through: Ms.Radhika Chandrashekhar, Advocate
VERSUS
Municipal Corporation of Delhi and anr. …Respondents
Through: Mr.Sanjeev Sabharwal with Mr.Alok Singh, Advocates
CORAM:
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON’BLE DR. JUSTICE S.MURALIDHAR
JUDGMENT
12.05.2008 CM No.6947/2008 (exemption)
Allowed, subject to just exceptions.
CM No.6946/2008 (delay)
For the reasons stated in the application, the application is allowed. Delay in filing the appeal stands condoned. The appeal is taken on record.
Admit.
2008:DHC:1607-DB

2. Learned counsel appearing for the respondents waives service. By consent, the appeal is taken up for hearing.

3. The appellant, the original writ petitioner, filed the present writ petition seeking to quash the Circular / Letter No.G- IV/Engg(HQ)/2007/1187 dated 27.12.2007 and Circular No. G- IV/Engg(HQ)/2007/1188 dated 27.12.2007. By the impugned order the learned single Judge was pleased to dismiss the writ petition. Being aggrieved thereby the writ petitioner has preferred the present appeal.

4. The appellant firm is Class II Contractor and is registered with the first respondent – Municipal Corporation of Delhi (MCD for short) for executing the dense carpeting work in Delhi. It is stated that the appellant firm has undertaken several projects during the last 10 years for carpeting roads and has successfully completed the said projects.

5. It appears that MCD called for the tenders for executing the work of resurfacing of internal roads of Block-D, New Friends Colony and peripheral roads in Sri Niwaspuri in July/August, 2007. The appellant firm participated in the said tender and its tender was accepted and work order came to be issued in its favour. It is the case of the appellant that dense carpeting / resurfacing of roads require a very sophisticated mixture of concrete and bitumen and for this purpose the appellant is having a Hot Mix Plant at Village Bhondsi, Gurgaon. As Delhi Government do not permit installation of Hot Mix Plant in Delhi, the appellant was constrained to instal its Hot Mix Plant at Village Bhondsi, Gurgaon and he has been running the plant for the last about 8 – 9 years. It is further case of the appellant that during the month of August, 2007, Haryana State Pollution Control Board sealed the appellant’s Hot Mix Plant at Village Bhondsi, Gurgaon and subsequently the Haryana State Pollution Control Board issued a letter No.HSPCB/818 dated 21.8.2007 and sought compliance report from the appellant under the Air Act, 1981.

6. It is submitted that the appellant’s Hot Mix Plant is lying sealed from August, 2007 and, therefore, it was unable to execute the work, which was awarded by MCD. It appears that a show cause notice came to be issued to the appellant to which the appellant filed a reply pointing out that the Hot Mix Plant of the appellant was not operating due to closing of the unit and consequently the appellant was unable to perform the contract.

7. By two separate Circulars dated 22.12.2007, the Commissioner, MCD has debarred the appellant for tendering with MCD for a period of two years on account of non-execution of the work awarded against the work order No.EE-XXV/TC/CZ/07- 08/14 dated 13.7.2007 and work order No.EE-XXV/TC/CZ/07- 08/15 dated 1.8.2007. The Circular No.G-IV/Engg(HQ)/2007/1187 dated 27.12.2007 reads as under: “The Commissioner, MCD vide order dated 11.12.2007 has debarred M/s Zile Singh Tanwar & Co., Prop. Sh.Zile Singh Tanwar, R/o H.No.961, Rajpur More, Chatter Pur, New Delhi – 74 for tendering with MCD for a period of two years on account of non execution of work awarded against work order No. EE-XXV/TC/CZ/07-08/14 dated 13.7.2007. This is notified & circulated to all concerned for information and necessary action.”

8. The other Circular bearing No. G-IV/Engg(HQ)/2007/1188 dated 27.12.2007 is almost on the same line.

9. The learned single Judge dismissed the writ petition holding that it was for the petitioner to find alternative source and meet his contractual obligations.

10. Learned counsel appearing for the appellant contended that in August, 2007, the Haryana State Pollution Control Board sealed the appellant’s Hot Mix Plant at Village Bhondsi, Gurgaon and subsequently the Board issued a letter No.HSPCB/818 dated 21.8.2007 and sought compliance report from the appellant under the Air Act, 1981 and in spite of the appellant’s making several representations, the appellant’s Hot Mix Plan has not been de-sealed by the Board till date. Learned counsel submitted that as the MCD has passed a non-speaking order and has not looked into the explanation furnished by the appellant and the circumstances under which the appellant was unable to execute the aforesaid work.

11. Learned counsel for the MCD on the other hand submitted that the appellant has taken inconsistent stand before the MCD. First, he said that the work could not be started due to rainy season as the same was not suitable for road work. Thereafter the appellant came with another explanation that the work of resurfacing could not be started as the Hot Mix Plant belonging to the appellant had been sealed by Haryana State Pollution Control Board by their letter dated 21.8.2007. Learned counsel submitted that it was the responsibility of the appellant to comply with the pollution norms in terms of the Air Act, 1981.

12. We have given our anxious consideration to the rival submissions made at bar. In our opinion, the impugned order including the circulars issued by the MCD do not deal with the explanation furnished by the appellant. According to the appellant, because of the sealing of the Hot Mix Plant by the Haryana State Pollution Control Board, he could not complete the work and there is nothing to show that this explanation was considered by the authorities concerned. The orders in question are non-speaking orders and cannot be sustained.

13. In view of the above, the appeal is allowed. Circular No.G- IV/Engg(HQ)/2007/1187 dated 27.12.2007 and Circular No. G- IV/Engg(HQ)/2007/1188 dated 27.12.2007 are hereby quashed. The MCD is directed to consider the matter afresh in the light of the explanation furnished by the appellant along with documentary evidence and pass appropriate orders within a period of eight weeks from today.

CHIEF JUSTICE S.MURALIDHAR, J May 12, 2008 “nm”