Shri Satish Batra & anr. v. Unknown

Delhi High Court · 12 May 2008 · 2008:DHC:1608-DB
THE CHIEF JUSTICE; DR. JUSTICE S. MURALIDHAR
Company Appeal No.1/2008
2008:DHC:1608-DB
corporate appeal_dismissed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court dismissed the appeal of company directors held liable for unauthorized acceptance of share application money without Board approval under the Companies Act, 1956.

Full Text
Translation output
Company Appeal No.1/2008 HIGH COURT OF DELHI Company Appeal No.1/2008
Shri Satish Batra & anr. …..Appellants
Through: Ms.Pooja M. Saigal with Ms.Sonal Sinha, Advocates
VERSUS
Through: Mr.Dalip Mehra with Mr.R.R. Mishra, Advocates
CORAM:
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON’BLE DR. JUSTICE S.MURALIDHAR
JUDGMENT
12.05.2008 CM No.554/2008 & CM No.555/2008 Heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties on these applications filed by the appellants praying for condonation of delay in filing and refilling the appeal. For the reasons stated in these applications, delay in filing and refilling the appeal stands condoned.
The applications stand disposed of.
2008:DHC:1608-DB Co.App. No.1/2008 & CM 552/2007

1. The appellants are the Directors of M/s Vimal Plast (India) Private Limited. In an inspection carried out under Section 209 of the Companies Act, 1956, it was observed that the company has accepted huge amounts from Directors, shareholders, corporate bodies (companies) and from public ever since 1999. It was observed that there is no resolution of the Board passed at any point of time authorizing the management i.e. the Managing Director and Whole Time Director (WTD) to receive the application money. It was observed that the allotment of shares in the company cannot be done by the Managing Director or WTD as only the Board of Directors can allot the shares as provided under the Companies Act, 1956 and also under Article 7 of the Articles of Association of the Company. It was observed that the Managing Director or WTD was not authorized by the Board Resolution to receive application money for allotment of shares, but they had received application money on behalf of the company from various parties including Directors, shareholders, public and body corporates. Neither any information regarding receipt of share application money was given to the Board nor the proposal for allotment was put up before the Board by the management. A show cause notice came to be issued under Section 628 of the Companies Act, 1956 to which the company furnished its reply / explanation and stated, inter alia, that the amount shown under the head share application money during the period 31.3.2000 to 31.3.2005 in fact was current account transaction. It was stated that as there is no provision in the Companies Act, or in the Schedule VI to reflect the current account balances, the same had been reflected under the Head Share Application Money. The competent authority came to the conclusion that the company has violated the provisions of Section 628 of the Companies Act and every officer of the company who is in default is liable to be prosecuted under Section 629A of the Act and directed the office to launch prosecution for the aforesaid violation.

2. The appellant moved Company Petition No.53/2007 before the learned Company Judge for an order excusing the appellants from any liability for the alleged default as specified in Sections 628 and 629A of the Companies Act,

1956. Before the learned Company Judge it was contended that as against the share application money which was received by the Directors, the company as on date has allotted shares to almost all applicants. A defence was also taken that unsecured loans were in fact friendly and temporary loans based on oral agreements and, therefore, no interest was payable thereon and the acceptance of share application money from various companies during the period 31st March, 2000 to 31st March, 2005 were current account transaction and as such no specific disclosure requirement has been prescribed in Schedule VI.

3. Repelling this argument, the learned single Judge observed as under:

“9. From the averments made and considering the facts and totality of circumstances, it is difficult to infer that the petitioners have acted reasonably and that considering all the circumstances, it will be appropriate to excuse the petitioners.
10. Merely on the basis of the bald averments made by the petitioners, it will be difficult to infer that the amounts received were temporary loans based on oral agreements and no interest was payable thereon.
11. In the totality of facts and circumstances, it will not be appropriate to excuse the petitioners. The petitioners are also unable to show prima facie that they have acted in good faith and they have justifiable reasons to escape from the liability.”

4. We do not see any infirmity in the reasoning of the learned single Judge. It is well settled that the Court’s power to relieve the accused of an offence is exercised only when the Court is satisfied that though technically the person may be liable in respect of negligence, default, breach of duty, misfeasance or breach of trust, yet he acted honestly and reasonably. In the facts of the present case it is not possible to conclude that the Directors have acted honestly and reasonably. Recourse to Section 633 is thus clearly not permissible. The appeal has no merit and is dismissed. Chief Justice May 12, 2008 S. Muralidhar, J “nm”