Government of NCT of Delhi v. Association of Fire Service

Delhi High Court · 13 May 2008 · 2008:DHC:1627-DB
A. K. Sikri; J. R. Midha
WP(C) No. 6194/2001
2008:DHC:1627-DB
service_law appeal_allowed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court held that existing drivers are entitled to ACP benefits based on the higher pay scale under the 1994 trifurcation scheme, directing the Government to grant promotions and pay scale upgradations accordingly.

Full Text
Translation output
WP(C) No. 6194/2001 HIGH COURT OF DELHI WP(C) No. 6194/2001
Date of Decision: 13.05.2008 Government of NCT of Delhi ...Appellant
Through: Mr. V.K. Tandon, Advocate.
Ms. Manpreet Kaur, Advocate.
VERSUS
The Association of Fire Service …Respondent
(Drivers) Delhi Fire Service & Anr.
Through: Mr. S.K. Gupta, Advocate.
CORAM :- THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE A.K.SIKRI THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE J.R. MIDHA
JUDGMENT

1. Whether Reporters of Local papers may be allowed to see the Judgment?

2. To be referred to the Reporter or not?

3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? A.K. Sikri, J. The respondents herein who are working as drivers in the office of Chief Fire Officer, Delhi Fire Service, Govt. of NCT of Delhi have been granted the benefit of ACP by the learned Tribunal vide impugned judgment dated 9th July 2001. Challenging that order the present petition is filed by the Chief Fire Officer as well as Delhi Government. We may state at the outset that it is not in dispute that the respondents are entitled to benefit of ACP under the scheme 2008:DHC:1627-DB formulated for this purpose vide Office Memo dated 9th August 1999. The only question is as to which higher pay-scale under the said ACP Scheme would be admissible to the respondents. We will have to take note of some background facts in order to appreciate the nature of controversy, therefore, we proceed to discuss the necessary factual matrix in the present case. The post of driver with the petitioner, at the time when the respondents were appointed, was an isolated post. The Government decided to trifurcate the cadre of driver and orders dated 17.3.1994 were passed by the Municipal Corporation of Delhi (MCD), as Delhi Fire Service was under the MCD at that time. Vide notification of even date, the fire services was taken over by the Government of NCT of Delhi w.e.f. 10th November 1994. As per the aforesaid orders dated 17.3.1994, it was proposed that trifurcating the post of driver in the Delhi Fire Service in three different pay-scales and designation should also be changed in the following manner:-

1. (Sub-Officer Pay Scale Rs. 1600-50- 2300-EB-60-2660 + all allowances attached with the post). The driver placed in this pay scale be called Sub Officer (Driver).

2. (Leading Fireman pay scale Rs. 1320-30-2500-EB-40-2040 + all allowances attached with the post). be called Leading Fireman (Driver).

3. (Fireman pay scale Rs. 975-25- 1150-EB-30-1660 + all allowances attached with the post). be called Fireman (Driver). The aforesaid proposal was approved by the Standing Committee of MCD on 21.3.1994. As per the revised cadre of the drivers, after trifurcating in the manner mentioned above, the initial appointment of the drivers was to be made in the pay-scale of Rs. 975-1660 from where these drivers could get promotion/placement in the higher pay-scales of Rs. 1320- 2040 and Rs. 1600-2660, respectively. It was also provided in the scheme of trifurcation that the drivers would be given Grade-III scale and after rendering 10 years of service they would be eligible for Grade-II and thereafter Grade-I subject to certain conditions stipulated therein which relates to passing of prescribed test, benchmark of “Good” in the ACRs for the last three years, etc. We may point out at this stage that before this trifurcation took place the pay-scale prescribed for these drivers was Rs. 1320-2040 + some special pay and certain other allowances. At the time of introduction of the aforesaid scheme there were 290 sanctioned posts of drivers out of which 176 posts had been filled up which means 176 drivers were already in position. In respect of those drivers who were already working and getting the pay in the pay-scale of Rs. 1320-2040 + other allowances, following provision was made:- “As regards the personnel already working as drivers in Delhi Fire Service in the pay scale of Rs. 1320-30- 1500EB-40-2040 + other allowances attached with the post, they will be eligible for Grade-I on the said conditions noted at

┌──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│      Sl.No.    Pre-Revised Pay-Scales (Rs.)   Revised Pay-Scales (Rs.)   │
├──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
│      1.        1320-2000                      4000-6000                  │
│      2.        1600-2660                      5000-8000                  │
│      3.        2000-3500                      6500-10500                 │
│        The petitioner herein vide office order dated 5th July 2000       │
└──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘

By implementing the proposal about forty personnel working as driver in Delhi Fire Service will become eligible to sit for test for Grade-I.” Thus, it is clear from the above that though the fresh recruitments were to be made at driver Grade-III level, i.e., pay-scale of Rs. 975-1660 + allowances attached to the post, for existing drivers who were in the pay scale of Rs. 1320-2040, the replacement scale suggested was Grade-I i.e. Rs. 1300-2660. On the basis of the aforesaid scheme of trifurcation the existing drivers through association, namely, “Association of Fire Service” drivers claim the replacement pay-scale of Rs. 1600-2660. Since it was not granted by the department, the said association filed OA 2108/1996 before the Tribunal. This OA was decided vide judgment dated 24th January

2000. We find from the concluded para of the said judgment that while disposing of the OA following direction were given:- “11. In the result, we dispose of the OA with a direction that respondents will consider the case of the applicants in terms of their orders in regard to the granting of the pay scales enumerated above and also in terms of the scheme formulated by the Govt. of India is known as „Assured Career Progression Scheme‟ vide their OM No. 35034/1/97- Estt.(D), dated 9.8.1999. This would be done within a period of six months. No costs.” The Tribunal thus directed the petitioners herein to consider the case of the respondents in terms of their orders in regard to granting of pay-scales as per the scheme of trifurcation. Since by that time ACP scheme dated 9.8.1999 has also been promulgated, further directions were given to the petitioners herein to consider the case of the respondents herein in terms of the said scheme as well. The petitioners in compliance with the aforesaid directions of the Tribunal passed Office Order dated 5th July 2000. Since w.e.f. 1.1.1996 payscales were further revised, and in an order to understand the implication of this Office Order, it would be opposite to note the revised pay-scales which are as follows:- Sl.No. Pre-Revised Pay-Scales (Rs.) Revised Pay-Scales (Rs.)

1. 1320-2000 4000-6000

2. 1600-2660 5000-8000

3. 2000-3500 6500-10500 The petitioner herein vide office order dated 5th July 2000 treated the respondents in the existing pay-scale of Rs. 4000-6000 (pre-revised 1320-2000). On this basis, first upgradation under the ACP scheme after 12 years in the said scale is given to these officers in the pay-scale of Rs. 4500-7000 (the scale which is created as per the ACP for isolated post). Second ACP upgradation after 20 years in this scale is granted in the pay-scale of Rs. 5000-8000. The respondent association was not satisfied in the manner Tribunal‟s directions were implemented by issuing the aforesaid office order. The respondent pleaded that they should have been placed in the payscale of Rs. 1600-2660 as per the trifurcation scheme introduced in 1994, which was the replacement scale of Rs. 1320-2000. On that basis they should have been given upgradation in the next 2 payscales after 12 years/24 years of service. If the ACP is to be given on this basis then the respondents would be entitled to first upgradation in the pay-scale of Rs. 5000-8000 and second upgradation in the payscale of Rs. 6500-10500. Raising this grievance, respondents filed OA 1791/2000 which has been allowed by the Tribunal vide impugned judgment dated 9th July 2001 and against this present Writ Petition is preferred by the Government of NCT of Delhi and Chief Fire Officer, as mentioned above. From the aforesaid factual narration, it is clear that the controversy revolves around the issue as to whether the 2 ACPs are to be granted to the respondents taking the pay scale of Rs.1320 – 2000 (revised pay scale of Rs.4,000-6,000) or Rs.1,600 – 2,660/- (revised pay scale of Rs.5,000-8,000). It is the contention of Mr. Tandon learned counsel appearing for the petitioner that since the post of driver is an isolated post, there is a placement as per the ACP Scheme that the same shall be governed by Para – 7 of the terms and conditions for grant of benefits under the said scheme. As per this para, in case of isolated post, in the absence of defined hierarchical grades, financial upgradation shall be given by the Ministries/Departments concerned in the immediately next higher (standard/common) pay – scales as indicated in Annexure – II. On this premise, it is contended that the petitioners applied (Annexure – II) and gave them two upgradation after 12 years and 24 years of service by placing them in the pay scales of Rs. 4500-125-7000 and Rs.5000- 150-8000/- respectively. We are unable to accept this submission of Mr. Tandon. While contending this the petitioners lose sight of trifurcation scheme which was introduced in the year 1994 and was available in 1999 when the ACP Scheme was introduced. We have already extracted above the relevant portion of the said trifurcation scheme as per which the existing personnel already working as driver in the pay scale of Rs.1320 – 2040 were to be place in Grade – I on their fulfilling the conditions as stipulated therein. These conditions inter alia included rendering of 10 years of service as driver. Thus, all existing drivers who were appointed in the pay scale of Rs. 1320-2040 were to be given the pay scale of Rs.1600 – 2660 after 10 years of service and on satisfying the contention mentioned at Sl. No. 1 to 4 of that order namely passing of prescribe test and achieving the benchmark in their ACRs, as described above. This aspect is not even looked into by the petitioners while passing office order dated 5th July, 2000. The appropriate exercise therefore would have been in the following sequence: - (a) The existing drivers on completion of 10 years of service should have first been considered for promotion to Grade – I, i.e., in the pay scale of Rs.1600-2660 and those who qualify for the said promotion should have been given the pay scale of Rs.1600 – 2660 (revised pay scale of Rs.5,000 – 8,000). (b) Those who would be able to get promotion in the aforesaid manner would be entitled to upgradation of their pay scale after 12 years of service from the date of promotion and in the pay scale of Rs.6,500 – 10,500/-. It is obvious that after those who get promotion would not be entitled to the benefit of both the ACPs Scheme but would get only upgradation to next higher scale.

(c) Those existing drivers who are not able to get the promotion to the pay scale of Rs.1600-2660 would continue in the pay scale of Rs.1320-

2040. In their cases, the upgradation as given by the office order dated 5th July, 2000 would be just and proper. We may note from the impugned judgment of the learned tribunal that even the Tribunal has not discuss the matter in the aforesaid perspective and has simply directed that the first upgradation be given from Rs.4000-6000 to 5000-8000 and second upgradation to 6500 – 10500. The order of the Tribunal is modified and substituted by our aforesaid directions. Proper exercise shall be undertaken by the petitioners in this behalf and appropriate orders be passed within six months from today. We may clarify that we have discussed the issue of only those drivers who were in service in the year 1994 when the trifurcation took place. Those drivers who were appointed thereafter had to be placed in the pay scale of Rs.975-1660. This has been so held by the Tribunal in its judgment rendered in another case, i.e., the judgment dated 1st December, 1999 in OA No. 424/1996, the writ petition thereagainst was dismissed by this court and the judgment of this court was upheld by the Supreme Court. The writ petition is disposed of in the aforesaid directions There shall be no order. A.K. SIKRI, J. May 13, 2008 J.R. MIDHA, J. mk