Shashi Bhushan v. State

Delhi High Court · 19 May 2008 · 2008:DHC:1683
P.K. Bhasin
CRL. APPEAL NO. 243 OF 1999
2008:DHC:1683
criminal appeal_allowed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court acquitted two appellants convicted of kidnapping due to serious infirmities in prosecution evidence, emphasizing the necessity of reliable identification and corroboration beyond reasonable doubt.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
CRL. APPEAL NO. 243 OF 1999
Date of Decision: 19th May, 2008 # SHASHI BHUSHAN ...Appellant
! Through: Mr. G.P.Thareja and Mr. Subhash Sharma, Advocates
VERSUS
$ STATE ...Respondent ^ Through : Mr. M. N.Dudeja, APP
WITH
CRL. APPEAL NO. 383 OF 1999 # SANJAY SHARMA ...Appellant
! Through: Mr. Deepak Bhardwaj, Advocate
VERSUS
$ STATE ...Respondent ^ Through : Mr. M. N.Dudeja, APP
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE P.K.BHASIN
JUDGMENT

1. Whether Reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?(No) 2008:DHC:1683 Crl.A. nos. 243/99 & 383/99 2

2. To be referred to the Reporter or not?(No)

3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the digest?(No)

JUDGMENT

P.K.BHASIN, J: These appeals have been filed by the two convicted accused assailing the judgment dated 7th April, 1999 and order dated 8th April, 1999 passed by an Additional Sessions Judge, Delhi whereby both of them alongwith one Rajinder were held guilty of the commission of the offence punishable under Section 366 read with Section 34 IPC and have been awarded two years rigorous imprisonment and a fine also of Rs. 3000/- each with a default stipulation.

2. The relevant facts leading to the trial and conviction of the appellants have been noted by the learned trial court in para nos. 4-6 of the impugned judgment and the same are reproduced hereunder:- Crl.A. nos. 243/99 & 383/99 3 “……….On 19.10.89 at about 7.30 p.m. PW-2 Sunita went to have a stroll in the park opposite to her house in P & T Colony, Janak Puri. She was accompanied by her aunt Renuka(PW-3) and brother Rakesh. While she was standing at the gate of the park, a maruti van suddenly came and whisked her away. Since the incident had occurred suddenly, the digits of the registration number of the maruti van could not be noted. The letters “DAE” were, however, observed by Renuka and she mentioned the same in her report. The information of abduction of the prosecutrix was communicated to P.S. Janak Puri vide DD NO. 17/A. On receipt of DD No. 17-A SI Sultan Singh rushed to the spot. He recorded the statement of Renuka and sent rukka through HC Kishan Lal (PW- 10). In the meantime a wireless message was received that the girl had been recovered in the area of PP Tilak Vihar…..On 22.10.89 at about 6.00 p.m. accused Sanjay was arrested at C-2-B bus stop in pursuance of a secret information in the presence of the prosecutrix and her brother Raju. It is alleged that Sanjay led the police to Sagarpur bus stand and there accused Shashi Bhushan and Raj Pal were nabbed at about 8.00 p.m. The interrogation of the accused gave further clues to the police and they went to New Priya Travel Agency, Hari Nagar, Ghanta Ghar. A maruti van bearing No. DAE-6632 was found parked near the office of the travel agency and it was seized. Accused Rajinder was also there and he was arrested. …………..”

3. Initially FIR was registered under Section 363 IPC on the complaint of aunt of the kidnapped girl (PW-3 Renuka) who alongwith kidnapped girl’s brother Rakesh was allegedly with the minor girl Crl.A. nos. 243/99 & 383/99 4 Sunita at the time of the incident. Later on the statement of the kidnapped girl was also got recorded by the police under Section 164 Cr.P.C. in which she had named one Ramesh, whom she knew, as one of her kidnappers but he was not be arrested by the police. The police, however, arrested six other persons, including the two appellants. Appellant Sanjay @ Laddu was the first one to be arrested by the police on 22/10/89 on the pointing out of PW-12 Raj Kumar, another brother of the kidnapped girl, who as per the prosecution case knew Sanjay and had seen him sitting in a van on the day of the incident and he had also claimed to have chased that van on hearing the noise that his sister had been kidnapped. At the instance of Sanjay other accused persons were arrested. Test identification parade was held in respect of three persons, namely, Manoj Dang, Rajinder Singh and appellant Shashi Bhushan. Only Manoj participated in the test identification parade but the complainant did not identify him as one of the culprits. So, he was got discharged by the police. Accused Rajinder Singh and appellant Shashi Bhushan had refused to participate in the test identification. For accused Sanjay no TIP was held because he was arrested on the pointing out of the Crl.A. nos. 243/99 & 383/99 5 kidnapped girl and her brother Raj Kumar(PW-12). After investigation was over four accused were charge-sheeted in the Court of Magistrate while the case against the fifth accused, namely, Raj Pal @ Rana was filed in Juvenile Court. All the four accused were charged under Section 366/34 IPC. During the trial one of the accused, namely, Paramjit @ Padam @ Kalia absconded and so was declared a proclaimed offender. In order to establish the allegations against the accused persons the prosecution had relied upon the evidence of the complainant(PW-2) who had identified in Court all the three accused to be the persons who had alongwith their other associates kidnapped her. Corroboration of her testimony was sought from the refusal of two accused persons to participate in the test identification parade as also from the statement of accused Rajinder Singh under Section 313 Cr.P.C. to the effect that he was the driver of the van in which the complainant was kidnapped and that his co-accused Sanjay and Shashi Bhushan(the two appellants) were also in that van at that time. The learned trial Judge accepted the evidence of the complainant and the refusal of the two accused persons to participate in the test identification parade as well as the aforesaid admission of Crl.A. nos. 243/99 & 383/99 6 the accused Rajinder Singh, which was considered as his confession of the crime although he had also claimed that he was forced to drive the van to Tilak Vihar at the point of knife and accordingly the trial Court held the two appellants and Rajinder Singh guilty of the charge under Section 366 read with Section 34 IPC. Feeling aggrieved, these two appeals were filed. Third convicted accused Rajinder Singh does not appear to have challenged his conviction and the reason for that appears to be his own above-referred admission of certain facts during his statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C.

4. I have heard the counsel for the two appellants and the Additional Public Prosecutor for the State and during the course of hearing of the appeals relevant portions of prosecution evidence were also read out from both sides. Since these appeals arose out of the same judgment of the trial Court and were heard also analogously the same are being disposed of by this common judgment.

5. As noticed already, the prosecution case is that one of the kidnappers Ramesh was known to the kidnapped girl Sunita and one Crl.A. nos. 243/99 & 383/99 7 was known to her brother Raj Kumar(PW-12). Ramesh was not arrested by the police and the learned trial Judge has observed in his judgment that the prosecution has not explained as to why he was not arrested. In my view, this fact of the police not prosecuting the person who was named by the kidnapped girl herself as one of the culprits should have been considered by the trial Court to be a circumstance making the case against the appellants doubtful.

6. As far as appellant Sanjay is concerned, no doubt that as per the prosecution case he was known to PW-12 Raj Kumar and he has deposed that this accused was arrested in his presence and also in the presence of his sister Sunita(PW-2) but, in my view, on the basis of this statement alone of PW-12 involvement of Sanjay in the kidnapping of Sunita cannot be said to have been established beyond reasonable doubt because PW-12 did not claim that he had seen Sunita being taken in the van in which he had seen Sanjay sitting some time before the incident going towards the P & T Colony where they were living. His statement was only to the effect that when he was going to the market he had seen Sanjay going towards P &T Crl.A. nos. 243/99 & 383/99 8 Colony in a van and when he returned back from the market he had heard that his sister had been kidnapped and also that before his return his sister had been taken away. This witness was crossexamined by the prosecutor on the ground that he had resiled from his police statement. During the cross-examination he stated that when he had come back from the market he had seen the same van(in which he had seen Sanjay sitting) at the gate of their colony and also that he had tried to intercept that van on hearing noise. From this statement of PW-12 learned prosecutor wanted me to infer that at least Sanjay’s involvement is definitely made out. I am afraid I am unable to come to any such conclusion. If actually this witness had seen accused Sanjay sitting in the van in which his sister Sunita was kidnapped he would have immediately given the name of Sanjay to the police since he knew Sanjay, as claimed by him in his chiefexamination itself. However, he did not do that. He stated in his crossexamination on behalf of the accused that on the day of the incident he had not made any statement to the police. He stated in his chiefexamination that next of the incident at about 11 a.m. his statement was recorded by the police at his house but in cross-examination he Crl.A. nos. 243/99 & 383/99 9 stated that his statement was recorded by the police on 22/10/89. There was thus unduly long delay in giving the name of accused Sanjay to the police by PW-12 Raj Kumar and the delay has remained unexplained and that fact certainly makes his version doubtful.

7. In fact even the arrest of appellant-accused Sanjay Sharma on the pointing out of PW-12, as claimed by him as well as by the investigating officer PW-13 Head Constable Ghanshyam, becomes doubtful since PW-2 Sunita, who was also as per the prosecution case present with the police team at the time of his arrest has not claimed in her evidence that he was arrested in her presence. In any case these two witnesses have not claimed that at that time Sunita had identified Sanjay to be one of the culprits. In fact, in her statement in Court PW-2 Sunita had categorically claimed that when she had gone to the police station on the next day of the incident accused Sanjay was sitting there. She was not cross-examined by the prosecutor on this part of her statement which is quite significant because the kidnapped girl herself having not claimed that Sanjay Sharma was arrested on her pointing out the identification of this accused in Crl.A. nos. 243/99 & 383/99 10 Court by PW-2 Sunita as one of her kidnappers became meaningless in the absence of a prior test identification parade after his arrest. So, the submission of the learned prosecutor that test identification parade in respect of accused Sanjay Sharma was not got arranged because he was arrested on the pointing out of the kidnapped herself cannot be accepted. Identity of an accused in these types of cases where the accused was not known to the victims of crime is of utmost importance and there has to be reliable evidence about the identity of the accused being tried. Prior test identification parade has always been considered to be quite essential in respect of an accused who is stranger to the victim and in the absence of that corroborative piece of evidence dock identification of the accused is normally not attached any value. In the present case there is no circumstance which could make up the deficiency in the prosecution which is there because of the absence of test identification in respect of accused Sanjay Sharma. In fact, the statement of the kidnapped girl that she had seen accused Sanjay at the police station next day of the incident makes the entire prosecution case highly doubtful because the prosecution case as projected during the trial through the evidence of Crl.A. nos. 243/99 & 383/99 11 PW-12 Raj Kumar and PW-13 Head Constable Ghanshyam was that Sanjay was arrested on 22/10/89. Despite all these serious infirmities in the prosecution case staring in the eyes of the Court the learned trial Judge did not deal with them in right perspective and simply observed that folly of the investigating officer in calling the prosecutrix to the police station when suspects were present and which he did to give an opportunity to the accused to claim during the trial that they had been shown to the prosecutrix could not affect the credibility of the kidnapped girl. There is no doubt that follies committed by the investigating agency during investigation stage should not be allowed to benefit the accused if there is reliable evidence against the accused. However, this was not a case of folly of the investigating officer. It is the kidnapped girl herself who had claimed and which statement of hers was not challenged by the prosecution as not correct that on 20/10/89 accused Sanjay Sharma had been seen by her at the police station when it was the prosecution case that Sanjay was arrested on 22/10/89. If she was to be considered to be a reliable witness then this statement of hers also had to be considered as true by the trial Court. In my view, the Crl.A. nos. 243/99 & 383/99 12 appreciation of the evidence led by the prosecution by the learned trial Judge was not proper. The prosecution is supposed to establish its case beyond reasonable doubt and in my considered view the aforesaid infirmities in the prosecution case certainly entitled appellant-accused Sanjay Sharma to the benefit of doubt.

8. Coming now to the case against appellant-accused Shashi Bhushan, I find that he has also been convicted on the basis of evidence of the kidnapped girl who had identified him also in Court as one of the kidnappers. And corroboration of her evidence had been sought from his refusal to participate in the test identification parade held after his arrest. This accused did admit that he had refused to participate in the test identification parade but he had also sought to justify that by claiming that he had been shown before that to the witnesses at the police station. This accused was admittedly not known to the kidnapped girl and that is why after his arrest test identification parade was got arranged by the police. The trial Court has also observed that such an identification parade is mandatory. If a suspect is identified during such a parade and later on also during Crl.A. nos. 243/99 & 383/99 13 the evidence in Court then his prior identification certainly becomes of great corroborative value and if the suspect refuses to participate in the identification parade without any just cause then that refusal also becomes a circumstance of great corroborative value for the prosecution. However, in case of refusal of an accused to join the identification parade he is only to show from the circumstances surfacing during prosecution evidence or otherwise by adducing some evidence that there could be a possibility of his being shown to the identifying witnesses before holding of the identification parade. In the present case, he has claimed that he was shown to the prosecutrix by the police before the identification parade and so he had refused to participate in that parade. As per PW-14 Sub-Inspector Sultan Singh PW-2 Sunita had come to the police station alongwith her father on 23/10/89 at about 10.15 a.m. and at that time accused Rajinder Singh and Sanjay Sharma were present there and she had identified Rajinder Singh. Although he also claimed that Shashi Bhushan at that time was not there as he had been sent for his medical examination but there is no proof in that regard. In any case, as observed already, what has to be seen by the Court is whether Crl.A. nos. 243/99 & 383/99 14 there was a possibility of an accused being shown to the witnesses before the test identification parade. In the present case the prosecution has not been able to rule out the possibility of the prosecutrix seeing the accused at the police station during her visit there. That possibility is very much there and so refusal of this accused to participate in the TIP cannot be said to be unjustified.

9. Learned prosecutor had also submitted that the testimony of the kidnapped girl gets corroborated even from the statement of the third convicted accused Rajinder Singh recorded under Section 313 Cr.P.C. and the same had been rightly relied upon by the trial Court not only against Rajinder Singh but also against the present two appellants. In my view, the learned trial Judge totally went wrong on this aspect. Accused Rajinder Singh had not made any confession of the crime during his statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C. On the contrary, he specifically claimed that he was not involved in the kidnapping of Sunita. His plea was that he was forced by one of the persons in the van at the point of knife to drive away his van. From this statement of Rajinder Singh it cannot be said that he had Crl.A. nos. 243/99 & 383/99 15 inculpated himself in the crime for which he was tried along with his co –accused persons. His statement was totally exculpatory and consequently could not be treated as a confession. Consequently, the two appellants could not be made liable for the crime of kidnapping on the basis of the said statement made by their coaccused Rajinder Singh under Section 313 Cr.P.C. In view of this conclusion, I need not go into the question as to whether the statement of Rajinder Singh even if it had amounted to his confession could be used against co-accused persons by invoking Section 30 of the Indian Evidence Act in the absence of any charge having been framed against the accused persons under Section 120-B IPC and also because of that statement of his having not been put to the appellants in their statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C., as was also the submission of the counsel for the appellants.

10. For the fore-going reasons, I am of the view that both these appeals deserve to be allowed since the guilt of both the appellants cannot be said to have been established beyond reasonable doubt. Crl.A. nos. 243/99 & 383/99 16

11. In the result, both these appeals are allowed and the impugned judgment dated 7.4.1999 as also the order on sentence dated 8.4.1999 are set-aside and the appellants-accused stand acquitted. Their bail bonds stand cancelled and sureties discharged. May 19, 2008 P.K.BHASIN,J sh