Full Text
W.P.(C) 3853/2008
Date of Decision: 19 th May 2008 MITTAL PROCESSORS P.LTD. & ANR ..... Petitioner
Through Mr. Jayant Bhushan, Senior Advocate with
Mr. Amit Kumar, Jay Bansal, Advocates.
Through Mr. Ajay Arora & Mr. Kapil Dutta, Advocates.
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V.K. SHALI
JUDGMENT
1. Whether the Reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes
2. To be referred to the Reporter or not? Yes
3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? Yes % JUDGMENT WP(C) 3853/2008 2008:DHC:1690-DB MUKUL MUDGAL, J. (Oral) CM No. 72421/2008(exemption) Allowed, subject to all just exceptions. The application stands disposed of. W.P.(C) 3853/2008 & CM 74202/2008 (stay)
1. Admit. With the consent of the learned counsel for the parties, this writ petition is taken up for final hearing. This writ petition challenges the notice dated 25 th April 2008 issued by the Municipal Corporation of Delhi, inviting tenders for supply of 7,90,736 meters of cloth for uniform of the school children for the year 2008-09. In respect of an earlier tender dated 23 rd December, 2004 and pursuant to some investigations made by the CBI by its letter dated 13 th March 2006, the following suggestions were made to the MCD which read as follows: “In view of the above the following suggestions are made for implementation / guidance in case for future purchase of uniform cloth:
1. While framing the tender conditions it may be specified that only bonafide composite textile Mills having the entire manufacturing process under one roof, would be eligible to participate. This will ensure that only reputed mills participate in the tender and prevent small scale unorganized mills in getting the order.
2. The sample of the cloth to be sent for testing should be clearly specified in consultation with the experts of BIS and the testing to be got done from will reputed, Government approved and NABL accredited laboratories.”
2. The petitioner claims to be a composite textile mill manufacturing the cloth. It was a successful bidder in the last tender floated by the respondents and has also given a bid in pursuance to the tender and notice dated 25 th April 2008 which is sought to be challenged in the present writ. The challenge to the aforesaid tender by the petitioner is on the ground that while the second suggestion of the CBI's letter dated 13 th May 2006 has indeed been incorporated in the tender conditions by the respondent MCD, the first suggestion which required the restricting of tenders only to the bonafide composite textile mills having the entire manufacturing process under one roof, (so as to prohibit the small scale unorganized mills from bidding) was not accepted.
3. Shri Jayant Bhushan, the learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioner submitted that this Court ought to issue notice and enquire from the respondents at least into the reasons which led to the exclusion of the first suggestion of the CBI for not incorporating the second suggestion of the CBI. It was urged that the respondent being a State could not act arbitrarily and discard he suggestions given by the CBI without recording reasons even though it may or may not be disclosed to the petitioner.
4. The learned counsel for the petitioner further submitted that he is supported in this regard by the judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of M/s Hochtief Gammon v. State of Orissa & ors. (1975) 2 SCC 649, in particular, paragraph 13 thereof which reads as follows:
5. In our view, undoubtedly, such an administrative order obviously cannot avoid scrutiny of the Court to enquire whether reasons exist. In the present case, the ratio of the above decision would not be applicable as the above decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court arose from the fact as to the refusal of the Government to record reasons for not making a reference under Section 10 (1)(d) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. In our view, in the present case, it cannot be said that the MCD had not applied its mind to the suggestions made by the CBI. The very fact that out of two suggestions given by the CBI, one has been accepted by the MCD, demonstrates that the MCD was alive to the recommendations made by the CBI. The second recommendation which has been accepted was to the effect that cloth to be supplied by the bidder should be approved by the Government and the NABL accredited laboratories. As a matter of fact the tender conditions lay down that before the tender is awarded such an inspection can be got done at the expense of the bidder himself. Further, during the subsistence of the contract also the tenderer could get the said testing done again. Therefore, the important recommendation has already been accepted and incorporated in the tender. Looked from another angle, these are only recommendations and therefore they may or may not be accepted. The learned counsel for the petitioner is also contending that they also want to know as to whether the second recommendation was considered or not. They very fact one of the conditions was accepted goes to show that both of them must have been considered by the Respondent. Further, by accepting the second recommendation it would eliminate the small scale manufacturers who who though may not have composite textile mill may be still maintaining good quality control so far as the cloth is concerned. There is no law which requires the MCD to accept all suggestions made by the MCD we have already noticed that the MCD had given consideration to the CBI's suggestions though not in toto.
6. Therefore, we see good reason for the respondent/MCD not to accept the second condition as it would eliminate one particular class of manufacturers altogether from bidding which may not be good for the respondent as it would generate a monopoly ousting small scale industry which would run counter to public interest. Therefore, we do not find force in the argument of the learned counsel for the petitioner. It has been held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Directorate of Education and ors. v. Educomp Datamatics Ltd. and ors., (2004) 4 SCC 19, as follows:
7. We are satisfied that the above position of law fully applies to the facts of the present case, accordingly, we find no merit in the writ petition and the same is dismissed. No order as to costs.
MUKUL MUDGAL, J
V. K. SHALI, J