Full Text
W.P.(C) 3120/1996
RAMJI LAL SHARMA ..... Petitioner
Through Mr. S N Shukla, Advocate
Through Mr. L K Garg, Advocate for respondents no.1 and 2
Ms. Kajal Sharma, Advocate for respondents no.3 to
JUDGMENT
1. The petitioner Ramji Lal Sharma was appointed as a language teacher (Sanskrit) Grade-II on 6.1.1971 in the Anglo-Sanskrit V.J. Higher Secondary School, Daryaganj. The said school is an aided school which was/is run and managed by Shri Ram Education Foundation. The said foundation was also managing another school called Commercial Higher Secondary School. Both the schools had a common seniority list and the employees including teachers could be transferred and promoted from one school to the other.
2. In 1974, post of Post-Graduate Teacher (Sanskrit) fell vacant in 2008:DHC:1724 Commercial Higher Secondary School, but the petitioner was not appointed. One Mr. J D Gautam, junior to the petitioner was appointed to the post of post-graduate teacher as a case of direct recruitment. The petitioner made representations against his non-promotion/appointment. He also wrote to the Department of Education.
3. After about 12 years on 4.3.1987, it was decided to create a post of post-graduate teacher (Sanskrit) in lieu of one post of TGT (Sanskrit) and give notional promotion to the petitioner retrospectively to the said post with effect from 12.4.1974. The promotion of the petitioner to Post- Graduate Teacher (Sanskrit) was also approved by Directorate of Education on 11.6.1987. Minutes of the meeting held on 4.3.1987, pursuant to which it was agreed that the petitioner would be granted notional promotion, records the reason why the petitioner was granted notional promotion with effect from 12.4.1974. Shri Ram Education Foundation was maintaining a common seniority list of the two schools mentioned above. It however, appears that after enforcement of the Delhi School Education Act, 1973 separate seniority list for teachers of the two schools was directed to be maintained by the Directorate of Education. This was challenged by Shri Ram Education Foundation in a writ petition before the High Court. Shri Ram Education Foundation succeeded by judgment dated 2nd May, 1984. It may be noted here that the post of Post-Graduate Teacher (Sanskrit) had fallen vacant in 1974 in Commercial Higher Secondary School, and the petitioner at that time was working in Anglo-Sanskrit V.J. Higher Secondary School.
4. The petitioner filed the present writ petition on 12th August, 1996 seeking two reliefs. Firstly, the petitioner is entitled to senior scale pay after completing 12 years of notional service as a post-graduate teacher from 7.12.1974 till 7.12.1986. The second prayer made by the petitioner is for grant of notional increments with effect from 7.12.1974.
5. With regard to notional increments I may note that Deputy Director of Education vide letter dated 22.7.1992, had ordered that increments should be calculated from the date of notional promotion i.e. 7.12.1974. This direction has been reiterated by the Education Officer in his subsequent letter dated 19.12.1994. The same stand has been reiterated by the Directorate of Education in the counter affidavit. The Directorate of Education grants aid to the extent of 95% to the school. The respondent school being an aided school should normally follow the said directions. Once it is accepted that the petitioner was wrongly denied promotion with effect from 7.12.1974, while fixing pay scale, notional increments which were otherwise due should be taken into consideration. As the petitioner has filed present writ petition on 12th August, 1996, the petitioner will be entitled to the arrears on this account for the period on or after 1st August, 1993 onwards till the date of his retirement on 30th September, 2001.
6. With regard to the first prayer, I will like to refer to the relevant scheme in question which was introduced with effect from 12th August, 1989. It appears that in view of stagnation, teachers were granted senior scale pay after 12 years of service in their respective cadre. The relevant portion of the circular is as under: “3. The revised Pay Scales will be admissible subject to the following conditions:i) While Senior Scale will be granted after 12 years to Primary School Teachers, Trained Graduate Teachers/Headmasters of Middle Schools, the Selection will be granted after 12 years service in the senior scale of the respective cadre. For the Vice- Principals/Headmasters of Secondary Schools, there will be only Senior Scale after 12 years and no Selection Scale. ii) The number of posts in the Selection Scale for Primary School Teacher, Trained Graduate Teacher/Headmasters of Primary School, Post Graduate Teacher/Headmasters of Middle School will be restricted to 20% of the number of posts in the Senior Scale of the respective cadre. iii) The Senior Scale and Selection Scale will be given after screening regarding their satisfactory performance by an appropriate DPC. iv) Every teacher would be required to participate in an inservice training programme of at least three weeks duration before he/she/crosses an EB or is promoted to Senior Scale or Selection Scale, i.e., once in every six years, provided that where arrangements for such training cannot be made, the appointing authority may exempt a category of teachers for a specific period of time. v) Although for purposes of grant of Selection Scale Primary School Teachers and Trained Graduate Teachers will be required to obtain higher qualification, they will not be required to shift to an institution of higher level. vi) Appointment to the post of Principals, Vice-Principals and Headmasters will be made in all schools on the basis of merit.”
7. A number of conditions had to be satisfied before a senior scale could be granted. There was also restriction on the number of posts in the senior scale to the extent of 20%. The petitioner was granted notional promotion in 1987 with retrospective effect from 1974. He was not to be paid arrears. His salary in the grade of Post Graduate was fixed in 1987. He started effectively working in the scale of Post-Graduate teacher in
1987. Keeping all these aspects in mind, I feel the petitioner should be given benefit of senior scale with effect from 1st March, 1999, that is, 12 years after the petitioner was appointed as a Post Graduate Teacher (Sanskrit). I may mention here that the petitioner in his prayer clause has prayed that he should be granted senior scale of pay with effect from 1.1.1987. The writ petition, as pointed out above was filed only on 12th August, 1996. The petitioner, in fact, had not worked at the said post from 1974 till 1987.
8. The respondents will calculate the arrears and make payment of the balance amount within a period of 10 weeks from the date copy of this order is received. In case the petitioner is entitled to increased or higher pension the same shall also be calculated and will be paid within a period of 6 weeks thereafter. In case payments are not made within 8 weeks and further time of 6 weeks as stipulated above, the petitioner will be entitled to interest on the principal amount payable to him at the rate of 8% per annum from the date of the judgment. The petitioner will be also entitled to costs which are assessed at Rs.5,000/-. The cost will be paid by the respondent no.2. The writ petition is disposed of.
SANJIV KHANNA,J MAY 22, 2008 vld