Full Text
FAO No.75/1998 M/s. Tara Chand Jai Narain ..... Appellant
Through: Mr. M.L.Bhargava, Advocate
Through: Nemo.
JUDGMENT
1. Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes
2. To be referred to the Reporter or not? Yes
3. Whether judgment should be reported in Digest? Yes O R D E R % 22.05.2008 PRADEEP NANDRAJOG, J. (Oral)
1. The above captioned appeal under Section 23 of the Railway Claims Tribunal Act is directed against the order dated 15.10.97 passed by the learned Railway Claims Tribunal, Delhi.
2. The appellant M/s Tara Chand Jai Narain filed an application under Section 16 of the Railway Claims Tribunal Act against the respondent claiming a compensation of Rs.1,78,000/-.
3. The case set up by the appellant was that on 11.01.92 three consignments comprising of 245 bags of gram dal were entrusted by M/s Sanjeev Dal Mills to the respondent for transport from Nangloi to Sonepur. That the said three consignments were booked under Railway Receipt Nos.562200, 562201 and 562202 respectively. That it was the endorsed consignee of the consignments in question. That it 2008:DHC:1722 had purchased the consignments in question from M/s Sanjeev Dal Mills for a consideration of Rs.2,43,000/-. That the rate at which it had purchased the gram dal was Rs.9.91 per kg. That due to the gross negligence and misconduct of the employees of the respondent the consignments in question were short delivered and the contents thereof were found to be in damaged condition at the destination station. That it had sold the consignments in question for a sum of Rs.64,600/- and thus incurred a loss of Rs.1,78,400/-.
4. On an analysis of the documentary evidence and the facts and circumstances of the case vide impugned order dated 15.1.97 the Tribunal has held that the respondent was at fault for short-delivery and damage caused to the consignment and awarded a compensation of Rs.50,888/- as against a sum of Rs.1,78,000/- claimed by the appellant. In assessing the compensation payable to the appellant the Tribunal had determined the market rate of gram dal at the relevant time as Rs.7.50 per kg on the basis of rates of gram dal published in the Financial Express dated 14.03.92.
5. Challenge in the present appeal is limited to the extent of determination of the market rate of gram dal at the relevant time by the Tribunal.
6. To prove the market rate of gram dal at the relevant time and that it had purchased the gram dal at the rate of Rs.9.91 per kg from M/s Sanjeev Dal Mills, the appellant examined three witnesses namely Mr.Subash Chander Goyal, AW-2, Mr.Prabhu Dayal, AW-3 and Mr.Rangi Ram, AW-4.
7. Documentary evidence filed by the appellant in support of its case was bill no.4555 dated 11.01.92 Ex.AW2/1; receipt dated 17.01.92 Ex.AW2/2; bill no.4561 dated 15.01.92 Ex.AW2/4; (Aforenoted three documents were purportedly issued by M/s Sanjeev Dal Mills) relevant extract of a ledger book purportedly maintained by M/s Sanjeev Dal Mills Ex.AW2/5; relevant extracts of cash book and ledger book maintained by the appellant Ex.AW4/2 to Ex.AW4/7.
8. Mr.Rangi Ram AW-4, a partner in the appellant testified that on 11.01.92 the appellant had purchased the consignments in question from M/s Sanjeev Dal Mills for a sum of Rs.2,43,000/-. That the bill no.4555 dated 11.01.92 Ex.AW2/1 issued by M/s Sanjeev Dal Mills and signed by one Mr.Ashok Kumar who was a partner in M/s Sanjeev Dal Mills evidences that the consignments were purchased by the appellant for a sum of Rs.2,43,000/- and that it had purchased the gram dal @ rate of 9.91 per kg. That on 15.01.92 the appellant purchased another consignment of gram dal from M/s Sanjeev Dal Mills which is evidenced by the bill no.4561 dated 15.01.92 Ex.AW2/4. That on 17.01.92 the appellant issued a cheque in favour of M/s Sanjeev Dal Mills for a sum of Rs.2,67,979.37 towards payment for said four consignments. That the receipt dated 17.01.92 issued by M/s Sanjeev Dal Mills evidences the same. That the entries regarding purchase of the consignments in question by the appellant were duly made in the cash book and ledger book (Ex.AW4/2 to Ex.AW4/7) maintained by the appellant. During cross-examination he stated that the loss in sum of Rs.1,78,400/- incurred by the appellant was shown in the income-tax return filed by the appellant in the year 1992. That the audited account books showing the said loss have not been filed by the appellant in the present case.
9. Mr.Prabhu Dayal AW-3 was deputed by the appellant to deal with the respondent in connection with the appellants’ claim. He testified on the same lines as that of Rangi Ram, AW-4 regarding the purchase of the consignments in question from M/s Sanjeev Dal Mills. However in his cross-examination he stated that he has no personal knowledge about the purchase made by the appellant of the consignments in question.
10. Mr.Subash Chand Goyal AW-4 claimed to be employed as a manager in M/s Sanjeev Dal Mills. He testified that he had entrusted the consignments in question to the respondent for transport from Nangloi to Sonepur. That the consignments in question were first unloaded from a truck on the platform of the forwarding station and subsequently loaded in the wagon. That the bill no.4555 dated 11.01.92 Ex.AW2/4 bears the signatures of Mr.Ashok Kumar, a partner in M/s Sanjeev Dal Mills.
11. As already noted the Tribunal has ignored the oral and documentary evidence led by the appellant and has determined the rate of gram dal at the relevant time @ Rs.7.50 per kg on the basis of rates of gram dal published in the Financial Express dated 14.03.92. In coming to the said conclusion, under-noted two circumstances have weighed with the Tribunal:- I The fact that the appellant did not produce the bill no.4555 dated 11.01.92 Ex.AW2/1 at the time when the officials of the respondent prepared the assessment reports Ex.AW4/9, Ex.AW4/10 and Ex.AW4/11A to assess the damage caused to the consignments in question leads to an inference that the bill Ex.AW2/1 is not a genuine document and was procured by the appellant after the date of actual purchase of the consignments in question. II The fact that the audited account books of the appellant were not produced during the trial suggests that the cash book and ledger book Ex.AW4/2 to Ex.AW4/7 do not present the true picture of the loss incurred by the appellant.
12. The only thing that needs to be considered by this court is that whether while determining the market rate of gram dal at the relevant time the Tribunal was correct in ignoring the oral and documentary evidence led by the appellant.
13. The testimony of Mr.Prabhu Dayal AW-3 needs to be discarded at the first blush for the reason he stated in his crossexamination that he has no personal knowledge about the purchase made by the appellant of the consignments in question.
14. The testimony of Mr.Subash Chand Goyal AW-2 who claimed to be employed as a manager in M/s Sanjeev Dal Mills needs to be looked into carefully.
15. Mr.Subash Chand Goyal AW-2 could not produce any document in proof of his employment with M/s Sanjeev Dal Mills.
16. A letter dated 04.03.97 Ex.AW2/3 purportedly issued by one Ms.Ram Ramuti Devi claiming to be a partner in M/s Sanjeev Dal Mills was produced on record. It was stated in the letter that Mr.Subash Chand Goyal has been authorized by M/s Sanjeev Dal Mills to depose in connection with the purchase made by the appellant of the consignments in question. Mr.Subash Chand Goyal in his examinationin-chief neither utter a word about letter Ex.AW2/3 nor did he testify that Ms.Ram Ramuti Devi was a partner in M/s Sanjeev Dal Mills. In such circumstances, not much reliance could be placed upon the letter Ex.AW2/3.
17. It therefore has not been established beyond doubt that Mr.Subash Chand Goyal was employed as a manager in M/s Sanjeev Dal Mills.
18. Additionally the testimony of Mr.Subash Chand Goyal AW-2 is contrary to evidence on record.
19. In his examination-in-chief Subash Chand Goyal had testified that he was present at the forwarding station when the consignments in question were entrusted to the respondent and that the consignments in question were first unloaded on the platform of the forwarding station and subsequently loaded in the wagon. A perusal of the forwarding notes Ex.R-14, Ex.r-15 and Ex.R-16 issued in respect of the consignments in question reveals that they contain the following remark ‘Loaded directly from truck to wagon’. The said remark belies the testimony of AW-2 that the consignments were first unloaded on the platform and then loaded in the wagon and this in turn casts aspersion on his presence at the forwarding station at the time of entrustment of the consignments in question.
20. Subash Chand Goyal had stated in his cross-examination that a cheque in sum of Rs.2,67,589.45 was issued by the appellant in favour of M/s Sanjeev Dal Mills while the relevant extract of the ledger book Ex.AW2/5 purportedly maintained by M/s Sanjeev Dal Mills shows that a cheque in sum of RS.2,67,979.37 was issued by appellant in favour of M/s Sanjeev Dal Mills.
21. In such circumstances not much reliance can be placed upon the testimony of Subash Chand Goyal AW-2. The necessary consequence of the said conclusion is that the bill no.4555 dated 11.01.92 Ex.AW2/1, receipt dated 17.01.92 Ex.AW2/2 and bill no.4561 dated 15.01.92 Ex.AW2/4 stand non-proved as the appellant had sought to prove the said documents through the testimony of Subash Chand Goyal AW-2.
22. The remaining oral evidence is the testimony of Rangi Ram AW-4 who was an interested witness as he was a partner in the appellant. In such circumstances not much reliance can be placed by this court on the self-serving testimony of Rangi Ram AW-4.
23. Lastly I note that the conclusions/inferences drawn by the Tribunal from the circumstances noted in para 11 above are based upon sound logic.
24. The delivery of the consignments in question was taken by the appellant on 16.03.92 as evident from the assessment reports Ex.AW4/9, Ex.AW4/10 and Ex.AW4/11A. The assessment reports Ex.AW4/9, Ex.AW4/10 and Ex.AW4/11A were prepared by the officials of the respondent on 23.03.92. There is a time gap of seven days between the delivery and the preparation of the assessment report. It is not the case that the assessment report was prepared at the time when the delivery of the consignments in question was taken by the appellant and therefore the appellant had no opportunity to produce the bills at the time of the preparation of the assessment report. There is no reason as to why the appellant did not produce the necessary bills at the time of the preparation of the assessment reports. The Tribunal has correctly inferred that the conduct of the appellant in not producing the bills at the time of the preparation of the assessment reports strongly suggests that the appellant was not in possession of the bills at the time of preparation of the assessment reports and that the bills were subsequently procured by the appellant.
25. In view of above discussion the appeal is dismissed.
26. No costs.
27. TCR be returned forthwith. May 22, 2008 (PRADEEP NANDRAJOG) sl JUDGE