Anant Raj Agencies v. Delhi Development Authority

Delhi High Court · 23 May 2008 · 2008:DHC:1735
S. Ravindra Bhat
CS(OS) 2939A/1995
2008:DHC:1735
civil appeal_allowed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court partially set aside an arbitral award for failure to apply contractual escalation formula and disallowed additional claims for integral contract work, while reducing the interest rate from 18% to 12% per annum.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
Date of Decision: 23rd May, 2008 CS(OS) 2939A/1995
ANANT RAJ AGENCIES ..... Plaintiff
Through Mr.Harish Malhotra, Sr.Advocate with Ms. Namita Chaudhary, Advocate
VERSUS
DELHI DEVELOPMENT AUTHORTY ..... Defendant
Through Mr. D.S. Mahendru, Advocate for DDA.
CORAM:
MR. JUSTICE S. RAVINDRA BHAT
JUDGMENT

1. Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? YES

2. To be referred to the Reporter or not? YES

3. Whether the judgment should be reported YES in the Digest? % 23.05.2008 Mr. Justice S. Ravindra Bhat (Open Court)

1. In this suit, the award of an Arbitrator dated 29.11.1995, is sought to be made Rule of Court. The respondent/Delhi Development Authority(DDA) has objected by filing application under Sections 30/33 of the Indian Arbitration Act, 1940, being IA No.5094/1996. This order will dispose of objections by the DDA.

2. Several grounds for setting aside of the award were made. However, during the hearings, Mr.D.S.Mahendru, learned counsel for CS(OS) 2939A/1995 1 of 5 2008:DHC:1735 the defendant, confined the attack to the award to three heads. The Arbitrator had, in relation to claim No.2, for Rs.33,69,445/-, on account of loss suffered in execution of work beyond the stipulated date of completion of work (due to increase in prices of material and other heads), granted Rs.13,51,286/-. The ground raised is that the Arbitrator failed to appreciate other parts of contract such as clause 10 and clause 10CC. It is also alleged that such an amount could not have been awarded as there was no proof or evidence on behalf of the claimant. The DDA also contends that the Arbitrator failed to take into consideration the evidence led by it and that the formula adopted by him in awarding the said amount was unjustified.

3. During the course of hearing, learned counsel for the DDA relied upon an order of this Court in CS(OS) 2937-A/1995, in relation to the same parties. In that case also, the Court held that if the contract provides for a structured formula to determine escalation, claims in that regard have to be calculated only on that basis and not on any other formula. This was based on the decision of a Division Bench of this Court in Delhi Development Authority vs. U.Kashyap, 1999 (1) Arb. LR 88 (Del.)(DB). Learned counsel for the claimant/petitioner did not dispute the existence of an identical structured formula, in the present contract, and submitted that the decision in Kashyap's case (supra), would equally govern the facts of CS(OS) 2939A/1995 2 of 5 this case, on a fair reading of the order in CS(OS) No.2937-A/1995, dated 18.8.2006. Therefore, the objection of DDA, on this account, has to succeed.

4. The second contention made is with regard to award under claim No.12. That concerned a claim for Rs.2,29,117.78 for straightening bent up steel bars, issued coils and bent up bundles and element of cutting the bars to the requisite size. The Arbitrator held that the claimant was entitled to Rs.2,17,791.20 and awarded that amount. Learned counsel for the claimant -petitioner relied upon the judgment of this Court, reported as Anant Raj Agencies vs. D.D.A. And Anr., 2005(1)Arb.LR590(Delhi). In that case, the parties were the same. The Court considered a challenge to an identical claim and after considering the previous decisions (M/s.Wee Aar Constructive Builders vs. D.D.A., 2001(2) Arb. LR 71(Del.) and Hudson in Building & Engineering Contracts (11th Edition) held that where something is an integral part of a listed work or has to be inevitably performed, it would be deemed to include that work and the price quoted would be a part of it. On this reasoning, the Court had set aside the award for additional amounts for straightening bent up steel bars, cutting etc. Learned counsel for the claimant does not deny that the reasoning in that case would consequently apply here; more so since the parties to CS(OS) 2939A/1995 3 of 5 the dispute are the same. Accordingly, the DDA is also entitled to succeed in regard to its objections concerning claim No.12.

5. The last question argued concerns interest. The Arbitrator had awarded pendente lite interest at the rate of 18% per annum with quarterly rests on the amounts of claim granted, i.e. claims No.4,5,6,12,13 and 14 from date of entering upon reference (13.10.1992) till the date of making award. He directed that in case the DDA did not release the amount within sixty days, it would also pay interest at the rate of 18% per annum on all amounts awarded including under claims No.2 and 10 till their realization or till date of decree, whichever was earlier.

6. This Court has considered the submissions of the parties. In the other litigations including CS(OS) No.20A/1996, the Court had reduced the rate of interest but in a graded manner. Adopting the same approach, this Court also is of the opinion that having regard to the present trend, the interest rate should be appropriately reduced. Accordingly, instead of 18%, the rate of interest shall be 12% with quarterly rests from the date of reference till date of award. The Court further decrees future interest reducing it from the said 18% to 12% till its actual realization.

7. In view of the above reasoning, the DDA's objection has to partly succeed; the findings of award concerning claim No.2 and 12 CS(OS) 2939A/1995 4 of 5 are hereby set aside. The award of interest is modified as indicated in the preceding paragraph. The award is accordingly made Rule of Court subject to above modifications.

8. The suit and pending applications are decreed in the above terms.

S. RAVINDRA BHAT,J