Full Text
‘
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
W.P. (Crl.) No.1789/2006
Order reserved on : 13.05.2008
Date of Decision: 23.05.2008 # TEJ PAL SINGH ..... PETITIONER
! Through : Mr. C.S.Sharma, Advocate with Mr. D.D. Sharma, Mr. G.S. Singh, Advocate.
..RESPONDENTS ^ Through : Ms. Mukta Gupta, Standing
Counsel for the State.
JUDGMENT
(1) Whether reporters of local paper may be allowed to see the judgment? (2) To be referred to the reporter or not? Yes (3) Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest ? Yes
JUDGMENT
ARUNA SURESH, J.
1. Petitioner Tej Pal Singh was arrested on 18.03.2004 at about 12.30 night in case FIR No.123/04, under Section 292 IPC of the Indian Penal Code (IPC). 2008:DHC:1745 Petitioner has sought quashing of the FIR on the grounds that the Petitioner has been falsely implicated in this case which is borne out from the police record itself.
2. It is submitted by Mr. C.S. Sharma, learned counsel for the Petitioner that as per the prosecution story Head Constable jai Prakash along with Constable Dayanand was coming back after making enquiry of DD No.39-A when at about 11.30 P.M. he received a secret information at Machhli Wali Gali, New Layalpur, Krishna Nagar, Delhi on the basis of which he conducted a raid in the house of the Petitioner/accused, whereas infact DD No.39-A was registered only at 11.50 P.M. on 18.03.2004 on receipt of a wireless message from PCR on the call of the Petitioner himself. At the time when the alleged raid was conducted, Head Constable Jai Prakash, Ct. Dayanand were in the Police Station in connection with a kalandra prepared under Section 107/151 Cr.P.C. It is argued by the learned counsel for the petitioner that under these circumstances when DD No.39-A was registered at about 11.50 P.M. there could not have been any inquiry of the said DD at about 11.30 P.M., especially when Head Constable Jai Prakash, Constable Dayanand were present in the police Statioon at about 1.30 P.M. in the kalandra case being DD No.37- A dated 18.03.2004 titled ‘State Vs. Pradeep’. It is further argued that Petitioner himself had called the PCR at 100 number at about 11.50 P.M. and 11.53 P.M. from his residence A-94, Old Anarkali, Delhi regarding a quarrel between the Petitioner and brother of his brother-in-law on the issue of his sitting in the said house of the Petitioner. It is pointed out by the learned counsel for the Petitioner that the Petitioner was apprehended at 2/11, New Layal Pur, Delhi at about
11.50 P.M. as alleged whereas he was at A-94, Old Anarkali, Delhi and he was never apprehended by the police as claimed in the prosecution story. It is also alleged that no raid was conducted in the premises and subsequently the Petitioner has been booked in this case under Section 292 IPC.
3. Ms. Mukta Gupta, learned Standing Counsel for the State disputes the averments made in the Petition and has controverted the arguments of the learned counsel for the Petitioner. It is argued that HC Jai Prakash was not having his wrist watch at the relevant time and there could be some mistake in the assessment of time of respective investigation and raid conducted at premises No.2/11, New Layal Pur, Delhi and therefore some discrepancies seem to have occurred regarding the time of conduct of raid, investigation conducted by Head Constable Jai Prakash, regarding DD No.39-A and also the inquiry of DD No.37-A. She also pointed out that DD No.39-A was found bogus as no quarrel had taken place at A-94, Old Anarkali, Delhi. The discrepancies are only regarding the intimation of DD No.39-A at 11.30 P.M. and the raid conducted at 11.50 P.M. and the rukka was sent to the Police Station at about 12.50 P.M. for registration of the case.
4. I have considered the submissions of Mr. C.S. Sharma, learned counsel for the Petitioner, Ms. Mukta Gupta, Standing Counsel for the State and have also perused the relevant entries in Daily Diary-A dated 18.03.2004 and also the documents placed on the record.
5. True that, there are some discrepancies in recording of time in the DD entries but as stated by learned Standing counsel for the State these discrepancies have crept in the case because of the fact that the HC Jai Prakash was not wearing wrist watch at that time and the timing given by him were according to his own assessment and were not based on the actual timing which could only be noted by him from the watch. DD No.32-A dated 18.03.2004 was recorded at 9.50 P.M. regarding quarrel at 151, Gopal Park, Chander Nagar, Delhi. This DD was marked to HC Jai Prakash for inquiry. HC jai Prakash went to the spot and arrested a person named Pradeep, got him medically examined vide MLC No.531 from Dr. Headgewar Hospital and sent him to lock up at 11.25 P.M. To this effect DD No.37-A was recorded. DD No.39-A was recorded at about 11.50 P.M. This DD was recorded on receipt of PCR call regarding a quarrel at A-94, Old Anarkali, Delhi. This call was made by the Petitioner to the PCR regarding a quarrel which allegedly took place between the Petitioner and the brother of his brother-in-law at the said address. This DD was also marked to HC Jai Prakash for inquiry. This DD was found bogus as no quarrel had taken place. According to the Petitioner before Head Constable reached the spot, the parties had compromised and therefore no complaint was lodged with him. This indicates that HC Jai Prakash did visit the spot to inquiry about DD No.39-A.
6. As per the prosecution case when he was coming back after conducting an inquiry in DD No.39-A, he received a secret information regarding the sale of obscene material in the form of CD at premises No.2/11, New Layal Pur, Krishna Nagar, Delhi. On this information a raiding party was organized and raid was conducted in the said premises and the Petitioner was apprehended by the police at the spot and five CDs were recovered. As per the FIR these CDs were checked about their contents of obscenity at the spot itself. Rukka was sent at about 12.50 P.M. and thereafter FIR No.123/04 dated 19.03.2004 was registered in the Police Station Krishna Nagar at about 1.05 A.M. When questioned it was admitted that Petitioner had signed some documents but he had tried to state that he had singed blank documents.
7. Under these circumstances, simply because there are certain discrepancies regarding the time of the inquiry of DD No.39-A, raid conducted by HC Jai Prakash in this case, the arrest of the accused-Petitioner and registration of the FIR as well as inquiry of DD No.37-A it cannot be said at this stage that the Petitioner has been falsely implicated in this case and the FIR needs to be quashed.
8. This court cannot put to an end the investigation and consequent filing of the charge sheet by going into merits in a pre-trial manner and on consideration of the pleas of the Petitioner which unless proved to be true and reliable in regular trail, cannot form basis of a decision regarding commission of offence. Entertaining the writ petition against charge sheet or investigation and considering the matter on merits on the guise of prima facie evidence to stand an accused for trial would amount to pre-trial of a criminal case under Article 226 or 227 of the Constitution, even before the competent Magistrate or the Sessions Court takes cognizance of the offence. The charge sheet and the evidence placed in support of the allegations form the base to take or refuse to take cognizance by the competent Court.
9. Under the facts and circumstances of the case it cannot be said that prima facie no offence has been made out against the petitioner in the First Information Report. Reference is made to ‘State of Bihar & Anr. vs. P.P.Sharma, IAS & Anr.,, 1992 Supp (1) SCC 222.
10. The investigation is complete and the charge sheet has already been filed on the basis of sufficient evidence collected by the Investigating Officer during the investigation of the case. I do not find it a fit case to quash the FIR. Hence, petition being without any merit is hereby dismissed.
11. Attested copy of the order be sent to the trial court as well as to the State.
ARUNA SURESH (JUDGE) May 23rd vk