Full Text
! Through Mr. A.K. Singla, Sr. Advocate with Mr. J.K. Sharma, Advocate
Through Mr. Sandeep Malik, APP for State.
Mr. Vinod Diwakar, Advocate with Mr. M. Madan, Advocate for
R-2/complainant
JUDGMENT
1. Whether Reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes.
2. To be referred to the Reporter or not? Yes.
3. Whether the judgment should be reported in Yes. the digest?
JUDGMENT
MANMOHAN, J:
1. The present petition has been filed under Section 482 Code of Criminal Procedure (hereinafter referred to as Cr. P.C.) for setting 2008:DHC:1750 aside the order dated 11th March, 2008 passed by Metropolitan Magistrate, New Delhi in as much as it directed registration of FIR against the Petitioners.
2. Briefly stated the material facts of this case are that on 22nd February, 2005 the Complainant alleges that he was restrained by his mother, two brothers and the Petitioners from entering his shop-cumresidence No. 3, Main Market, Lodhi Colony, New Delhi hereinafter referred to as the said premises. The Complainant further states that he reported the matter to the local police, but it took no action. The Complainant also alleges that on 28th February, 2005 he was not only dispossessed from the said premises, but his goods were also removed by the aforesaid relatives and the Petitioners. The Complainant’s case is that despite reporting the matter to the police, the local police took no action as it was in hand in glove with the accused persons. It is also Complainant’s case that the aforesaid relatives and Petitioners had also prepared forged and fabricated documents to grab the said premises.
3. From the records it seems that on the basis of the above Complaint the police conducted an enquiry, but did not register an FIR as according to them the Complainant could neither satisfactorily explain the delay of two and a half years in lodging the complaint, nor could he produce the ownership documents of the goods & articles alleged to have been lying in the shop. The police also did not take any further action as they were of the view that the matter was already subjudice in a civil suit filed by the Complainant. The police records further indicate that the Complainant’s brother and mother could not be traced for recording their statements.
4. Since the police did not register an FIR, the Complainant approached the Magistrate by filing a complaint under Section 156 (3) of Cr. P.C. in which he prayed for a direction to register an FIR against the accused persons (including the Petitioners) in accordance with law. The relevant paras of the complaint are reproduced hereinbelow for ready reference:-
5. The Metropolitan Magistrate after perusing the status report filed by the police (wherein it has been concluded that the allegations made by the Complainant did not find support from any other statement / document gathered during the police inquiry) directed on 11th April, 2008 registration of FIR. The impugned order dated 11th April, 2008 is re-produced hereinbelow for ready reference:- “11/4/08 Pr: Ld. Counsel for the complt with complt. Heard. File Perused. Having heard the argument, advanced by the counsel for the complt and perused the status report filed by the police officials I am of the opinion that Cognizable offence is made out against the accused. It discloses the cognizable offence as per law laid down by Hon’ble Supreme Court in Ramesh Kumari Vs. State (NCT of Delhi) & Ors. reported as 2006 (1) JCC 468 SC that on receipt of information disclosing cognizable offence registration of FIR is must. Therefore, concerned SHO is directed to register the FIR against the accused, compliance report be filed on or before the next date of hearing i.e. 30/07/08. Sd/- MM/ND 11/4/08”
6. Mr. A.K. Singla, learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioners submits that there was total abuse of process of power by the Complainant in invoking the process and forum by way of an application under Section 156 (3) of Cr. P.C. According to him no such petition is maintainable in the absence of a complaint filed under Sections 190 of Cr. P.C. In support of this submission Mr. Singla relied upon Aleque Padamsee and Ors. Vs. Union of India and Ors. reported in 2007 (9) SCALE 275. In the said judgement it has been held that a person aggrieved by in-action of the police officials in registering an FIR, has to adopt the modalities contained in Section 190 read with Section 200 of Cr. P.C. Mr. Singla further submitted that Metropolitan Magistrate could not have disagreed with the report of the police without giving any reasons. He submitted that in the present case the Metropolitan Magistrate had ordered registration of an FIR in a rather mechanical manner. Mr. Singla also submitted that since the Magistrate had already taken cognizance in the matter, what was the need for him to seek a compliance report from the police. Mr. Singla relied upon the judgment of the Supreme Court in Devarapalli Lakshminarayana Reddy & Ors. Vs. V. Narayana Reddy & Anr. reported in (1976) 3 SCC 252, Daulat Radhu Bhatija Vs. State and Anr. reported in DRJ 1994 (29) 557, and S.K. Sinha, Chief Enforcement Officer Vs. M/s. Videocon International Ltd. & Ors. reported in 2008 (2) SCALE page 23, to emphasise the concept of cognizance and to show the difference between precognizance and post-cognizance stage.
7. The Counsel for Complainant / Respondent No. 2 after referring to the Impugned Order submitted that the Magistrate has the power to order investigation at pre-cognizance stage and that too without examining the Complainant on oath. In support of his submission Mr. Diwakar, learned Counsel for Complainant/Respondent No. 2 relied upon “Mohd. Yousuf Vs. Afaq Jahan (Smt.) and Anr. reported in (2006) 1 SCC 627, Nirmaljit Singh Hoon Vs. The State of West Bengal and Anr. reported in (1973) 3 SCC 753, Narsingh Das Tapadia Vs. Goverdhan Das Partani and Anr. reported in (2000) 7 SCC 183, and Madhu Bala Vs. Suresh Kumar and Ors. reported in (1997) 8 SCC 476.
8. Before I deal with the rival submissions I would like to refer to the relevant statutory provisions namely Sections 154, 156, 190, 200 & 202. The said Sections are reproduced hereinbelow for ready reference:-
9. On a combined reading of the provisions it is abundantly clear that when a written complaint filed before a Magistrate discloses a cognizable offence, the Magistrate may take cognizance upon the same under Section 190 of Cr. P.C. and proceed with the same in accordance with the provisions of Chapter XV. The other option available to a Magistrate, in such a case, is to send the complaint to the appropriate police station under Section 156 (3) of Cr. P.C. for investigation. Once such a direction is given under Section 156 (3) of Cr. P.C., the police is required to investigate into the complaint and on completion of the same, submit a police report in accordance with Section 173 (2) of Cr. P.C., on which a Magistrate may or may not take cognizance under Section 190 of Cr. P.C. In fact as soon as order under Section 156 (3) of Cr. P.C. is passed, the complaint transforms itself into a report given in writing within a meaning of Section 154 of Cr. P.C. which is known as First Information Report.
10. From the facts stated hereinabove, it is apparent that Complainant’s complaint discloses commission of alleged cognizable offences. It is settled law that whenever a complaint discloses commission of a cognizable offence, it is mandatory for the police to register an FIR. In the present case the police did not register an FIR and consequently the Magistrate was well within its power to order its registration under Section 156 (3) of Cr. P.C.
11. On reading of complaint as well as Impugned Order, I am of the view that the Magistrate has, in the present case, not taken cognizance of the offences with a view to commence a trial. In Nirmaljit Singh Hoon Vs. The State of West Bengal and Anr., Mohd. Yousuf Vs. Afaq Jahan (Smt.) and Anr. and Narsingh Das Tapadia Vs. Goverdhan Das Partani and Anr., referred to hereinabove, the Apex Court has consistently held that where a Magistrate has applied his mind only for ordering an investigation under Section 156 (3) of Cr. P.C., he cannot be said to have taken cognizance of the offence. In fact before taking cognizance of an offence, Magistrate can order investigation under Section 156 (3) of Cr. P.C. It has further been held that if a Magistrate directs investigation by the police, he is not to examine the complainant on oath because he has not taken cognizance of any offence therein.
12. In Aleque Padamsee and Ors. Vs. Union of India and Ors. the Supreme Court has only reiterated the law laid down in All India Institute of Medical Sciences Employees’ Union (Regd.) Vs. Union of India & Ors. reported in (1996) 11 SCC 582. In the said two cases the Apex Court has held that if the grievance of the Petitioner is that though offences punishable under IPC have been disclosed in a complaint but the police officials did not register an FIR, then a writ petition is not the remedy; but the aggrieved persons have to adopt the procedure mentioned in Section 190 read with Section 200 of Cr. P.C. On a reading of these two judgments, I am of the opinion that Complainant in the present case should have filed his complaint under Section 190 of Cr. P.C. But it is a settled law that nomenclature under which a petition is filed is not relevant. In Pepsi Foods Ltd. Vs. Special Judicial Magistrate reported in 1998 5 SCC 759 it has been held, “Nomenclature under which petition is filed is not quite relevant and that does not debar the court from exercising its jurisdiction which otherwise it possesses unless there is special procedure prescribed which procedure is mandatory”.
13. Consequently, in my view, filing of the petition by Complainant in the present case under a wrong section would not debar the Magistrate from exercising power that is otherwise available to him under Cr. P.C. Since in the present case the complaint filed by Complainant discloses commission of cognizable offence, registration of an FIR was mandatory and the Magistrate by directing its registration at pre-cognizance stage has rightly exercised the power vested in him. Since I have already held that a Magistrate has power to order registration of an FIR without examining Complainant on oath, the Magistrate has committed no illegality.
14. The present petition being devoid of merits is dismissed but with no order as to costs. However, it is clarified that the police shall carry out its investigation without being influenced by any observation in the present case and the Magistrate would also apply its mind independently at the time of taking a decision as to whether to take cognizance or not. [MANMOHAN] Judge. May 23, 2008 rn