Delhi Development Authority v. M/s Hargovind Jaggi

Delhi High Court · 02 Jul 2008 · 2008:DHC:1890-DB
CHIEF JUSTICE; S. MURALIDHAR
FAO(OS) No.98/1997
2008:DHC:1890-DB
civil appeal_dismissed

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court dismissed the appeal against an arbitral award holding that penalty recoveries without proof of loss are not permissible and factual findings of the Arbitrator cannot be interfered with.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
FAO(OS) No.98/1997
Delhi Development Authority …..Appellant
Through: Ms.Anusuya Salwan, Advocate
VERSUS
M/s Hargovind Jaggi …Respondent
Through: nemo
CORAM:
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON’BLE DR. JUSTICE S.MURALIDHAR
1.Whether reporters of the local news papers be allowed to see the
JUDGMENT
?
2.To be referred to the Reporter or not ?

3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest ? O R D E R 2.7.2008

1. This appeal is directed against the order of the learned single Judge dismissing the objections of the appellant to the award of the Arbitrator and making the award a rule of the Court.

2. The award of the Arbitrator was published on 21st February, 1990. Objections were filed by the appellant with regard to claims No.1,2,3,7,[8] and additional claim No.1. The FAO(OS) No.98/1997 2008:DHC:1890-DB present appeal is confined only to the objections in respect of claims No.2 and 3.

3. Claim No.2 was made by the respondent for a sum of Rs.10,197.50 deducted by the appellant for late supply of cement. The Arbitrator has held that the recovery made by the appellant for late supply of cement is in the form of penalty and that the appellant has failed to establish that any loss has been caused to it for which such penalty could be imposed. The Arbitrator has come to the conclusion on facts that the appellant has failed to establish any loss having been incurred by it. He held that no such recovery could be made from the respondent. This finding of the Arbitrator is essentially a finding of fact arrived at on appreciation of evidence and this Court cannot sit on appeal on such finding of fact.

4. Claim No.3 is for a sum of Rs.4,165/- deducted by the appellant from the various bills for alleged short supply of cement bags. It is the case of the appellant that the respondent supplied 42 bags of cement short. The recovery of the said shortage of cement bags was done in different R/A bills under special condition No.7(f) i.e. at the rate of Rs.2,100/- per metric tonne. The Arbitrator on appreciation of evidence came to the conclusion that the penal rate recovery in the absence of any proof of loss suffered by the appellant is bad in law and hit by Section 74 of the Indian Contract Act. Accordingly the Arbitrator held the recovery to the extent of Rs.2,205/- to be justified and the balance amount, namely, Rs.1,960/- to be unjustified and allowed the said sum of Rs.1,960/- in favour of the respondent.

5. In our opinion, it is not permissible for this Court to interfere with this finding of fact of the Arbitrator. In the result the appeal fails and the same is hereby dismissed.

CHIEF JUSTICE S.MURALIDHAR JULY 02, 2008 (JUDGE) “nm”