Manohar Singh v. New Friends Club

Delhi High Court · 15 Jul 2008 · 2008:DHC:2024-DB
The Chief Justice; Dr. Justice S. Muralidhar
LPA No.114/2007
2008:DHC:2024-DB
labor appeal_dismissed

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court upheld that an employer's requirement of a fitness certificate for a life guard was lawful and refusal to comply amounted to job abandonment, not illegal termination.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
LPA No.114/2007 MANOHAR SINGH ..... Appellant
Through: Mr.Sanjeev Joshi, Advocate
VERSUS
NEW FRIENDS CLUB ..... Respondent
Through Mr.Rajan Sabharwal with Ms.Seema Bhaduriya, Advocates
CORAM:
HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE S.MURALIDHAR
JUDGMENT

1. Whether reporters of the local papers be allowed to see the judgment ?

2. To be referred to the Reporter or not ?

3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest ?

JUDGMENT

% 15.07.2008

1. This appeal takes an exception to the order of the learned single Judge dated 4th October, 2006 whereby the writ petition filed by the appellant challenging validity of the award was dismissed. [LPA 114/2007] 2008:DHC:2024-DB

2. The appellant was working as a Life Guard/Coach on the swimming pool maintained by the respondent. The appellant met with an accident and was on ESI leave for 3 months and 20 days. He reported for work on 28th August, 1998 with the fitness certificate issued by the ESI. The appellant was permitted to resume his duty. Thereafter the management found that the appellant was not able to walk straight much less being able to perform the duties of Life Guard for which purpose he was appointed. Since the respondent could not risk the life of its members and their families, the appellant was asked to appear before the Head of Orthopedics Department in the ESI Hospital, who was requested to re-examine the appellant in view of the peculiar nature of the job of the appellant. The appellant, instead of appearing before the specialist for medical examination, approached the Conciliation Officer. The contention of the appellant was that on 8th September, 1998 he was prevented from entering the club premises when he came to attend his duty and on inquiry he came to know that his name had been removed from the attendance register. A reference was finally came to be made to the Labour Court with the following terms: “Whether the services of Shri Manohar Singh have been terminated illegally and/or unjustifiably by the management, and if so, to what relief is he entitled and what directions are necessary in this respect ?”

3. The Labour Court noted that the workman in his cross examination admitted that his services were never terminated. The management witness also deposed that the services of the workman were never terminated. He deposed that the appellant was directed to appear before the HOD Orthopaedics, ESI Hosapital for re-examination but he did not report for medical examination till the end of 2003. The workman in his cross examination also admitted that after 1998 he did not go to ESI Hospital, Basai Darapur, Delhi and he had gone there only in end of 2003. Under these circumstances the learned Labour Court came to the conclusion that the services of the respondent-workman was never terminated and he absented himself from the duty.

4. The award of the Labour Court was under challenge before the learned single Judge, who dismissed the writ petition by the impugned order. The learned single Judge in paragraph-7 of his order observed as under:

“7. The petitioner was employed by the club as life guard and swimming coach in the swimming pool of the respondent. Children and other persons, who did not know swimming, also used to come to learn swimming. The importance of the work of the petitioner was enormous. Since the petitioner was not in a position to walk properly and swim properly he could not have been able to save the lives of others. He was employed as life guard at the swimming pool. The risk was that some life may be lost in the pool due to his incapacity. For this reason, the management wanted that the petitioner should obtain certificate of fitness about the job which the petitioner was to perform. Recovering from injuries of an accident is one thing, and performing a job of a life guard is another thing. A life guard/coach is required to act swiftly and needs strong body and ability to swim and dive so that in the need of any emergency, he can save life of a drowning person. If he cannot walk properly and cannot swim properly, he cannot work as a life guard. The management could (not) be expected to put the lives of learners in danger by engaging the petitioner as a life guard. The demand made by the management that the petitioner should obtain a certificate of fitness from Head of Orthopedic Department, was not illegal, keeping in view the nature of his job. The petitioner’s refusal to go to Orthopedic Department
and refusal to furnish a certificate of fitness showed his intention of abandoning the job. The petitioner, in fact, should have shown eagerness to obtain such a certificate instead of raising objections against the certificate. The cases cited by the petitioner are of no help to him. The management if had asked the petitioner not to come unless he obtained certificate of his fitness, it was within its rights to do so and that does not amount to termination or retrenchment. It could not be expected of the management to put the lives of others in danger.”

5. We are in agreement with the findings recorded by the learned single Judge. There is no infirmity in the order of the learned Single Judge. The appeal has no merit and is accordingly dismissed.

CHIEF JUSTICE S.MURALIDHAR JULY 15, 2008 (JUDGE) ‘v’