Brij Bala Gupta v. Samarth Shiksha Samity & Ors.

Delhi High Court · 07 Jul 2008 · 2008:DHC:1949
Pradeep Nandrajog
WP(C) No.3033/1999
2008:DHC:1949
labor petition_allowed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court held that service rendered by the petitioner in an unrecognized school must be counted towards qualifying service for senior scale pay benefits upon transfer to a recognized school, directing retrospective placement and payment.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
WP(C) No.3033/1999 SMT. BRIJ BALA GUPTA ........ Petitioner through: Mr. Gyan Prakash, Advocate
VERSUS
SAMARTH SHIKSHA SAMITY & ORS. ........ Respondents through: Mr.Puneet Taneja, Advocate
RESERVED ON:
03.07.2008
Date of Decision: 07.07.2008
CORAM:
Hon'ble Mr.Justice Pradeep Nandrajog
JUDGMENT

1. Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?

2. To be referred to the Reporter or not?

3. Whether judgment should be reported in Digest?: PRADEEP NANDRAJOG, J.

1. Stating that it was intending to open a primary school (Saraswati Shishu Mandir) at Punjabi Bagh, vide a circular dated 26.3.1981, respondent No.1 Samarth Shiksha Samity, invited applications from eligible candidates informing that the chosen incumbent would be placed in the pay scale recognized by Delhi Administration. Since the post advertised was of Head-Mistress of the School, eligible criteria prescribed was as applicable to the post of Head-Mistress. WP(C) No.3033/1999 Page No.1 of 8 2008:DHC:1949

2. Being eligible, petitioner responded to the circular dated 26.3.1981 and was selected.

3. The petitioner was already working under respondent No.1 at its school at Mehrauli. Pursuant to her selection as the Head-Mistress of the School since she was to commence functioning under respondent No.1 at Punjabi Bagh, vide order dated 10.4.1981 issued under the signatures of the Secretary General of respondent No.1, she was transferred to the new school at Punjabi Bagh.

4. Under the signatures of the Secretary General of respondent No.1, vide order dated 5.7.1981, petitioner was intimated that with effect from 1.7.1981 she would be placed in the pay scale of Rs.425-15-560-EB-20-640. She was informed that her pay in the scale would be Rs.425/-.

5. Thus, it is apparent that with effect from 1.7.1981, petitioner was placed at the entry of the pay scale i.e. Rs.425/-.

6. There appears to have taken place a revision in the pay scale of Head-Mistresses and the entry pay scale of Rs.425/- came to be fixed at Rs.440/- with effect from 1.1.1984. On 16.12.1984 petitioner was informed of the said grade revision.

7. Unfortunately, neither party has informed the Court as to what was the scale of pay in the grade applicable where WP(C) No.3033/1999 Page No.2 of 8 Rs.440/- was the entry level pay.

8. The School at Punjabi Bagh was an unrecognized school.

9. Respondent No.1 had established a recognized school under the Delhi School Education Act, 1973. It was named Saraswati Bal Mandir, Jhandewalan.

10. There existed a vacant post of a trained graduate teacher (T.G.T) at Saraswati Bal Mandir, Jhandewalan, New Delhi. The petitioner applied for appointment in the said recognized school. She was selected. On 7.1.1986 she was informed by respondent No.1 as under:- “Madam, You are being transferred to Saraswati Bal Mandir, Jhandawalan, New Delhi w.e.f. 8-1-86 as T.G.T. Your salary and D.A. will remain as it is. Your services rendered in Panjabi Bagh Vidyalaya will be recognised and benefit as per rules will be given to you. Whatever, earned/ Medical leave balance on your account during the service rendered in Punjabi Bagh Vidyalaya will be credited and you will be entitled to take it as per your need. Accordingly on the above mentioned date please take over charge from Manager/Principal of Saraswati Bal Mandir Zhandawalan. Please take your relieving certificate with you. All accounts/paper regarding vidyalaya may be handed over to Manager.” (underlining emphasized)

11. It may be noted that the pay scale of TGT in schools recognized by the Competent Authority under the Delhi School WP(C) No.3033/1999 Page No.3 of 8 Education Act, 1973 was the same as that of Head-Mistresses of primary schools. Thus, on transfer as a TGT to the recognized school the petitioner continued to remain in the pay scale in which she was placed while posted as the Head Mistress of the School at Punjabi Bagh.

12. Upon acceptance of the report of the National Commission On Teachers (IVth Central Pay Commission) on 12.8.1987 the replacement scale of trained graduate teachers/Head-Masters (Head-Mistresses) of primary school was notified by Delhi Government as under:- “(b) Trained Graduate teachers/ Headmasters of Primary school Rs.1400-40-1600-50-1650- EB-50-1950-EB-50-2250- EB-50-2300-60-2600 Senior Scale (After 12 years) Rs.1640-60-2000-EB-60- 2360-EB-60-2600-75-2750- EB-75-2900”

9,042 characters total

13. In the year 1993 the petitioner wrote to respondent No.1 informing that she had been functioning as the Head Mistress of a primary school under respondent No.1 since 1.7.1981 and that with effect from 8.1.1986 she had been functioning as a TGT in a school run by respondent No.1 at Jhandewalan and that she had completed 12 years of service in the scale of a trained graduate teacher/Head-Mistress of a primary school and hence was entitled to be placed in the senior scale. WP(C) No.3033/1999 Page No.4 of 8

14. The claim was refuted by respondent No.1 informing the petitioner that her employment under the school at Punjabi Bagh could not be counted while determining the 12 years service to be rendered in the scale of a trained graduate teacher/Head-Mistress, for the reason, the said School was an unrecognized School and that since the petitioner was posted in the recognized School under respondent No.1 for the first time in the year 1986, the 12 year qualifying service would be completed in the year 1998.

15. Instant petition came to be filed by the petitioner when all forums of redressal failed. Prayer made in the petition is to direct the respondents to grant to the petitioner senior scale with effect from 1.7.1993 in terms of the circular dated 12.8.1987.

16. The rival submissions are short and crisp. According to the petitioner the pay scale of Head-Mistress in a primary school is the same as a TGT in a regular school and that when she was transferred from the School at Punjabi Bagh on 7.1.1986 where she was functioning as a Head-Mistress of the un-recognized school to the recognized school at Jhandewalan it was clearly stated to her that 'your salary and DA will remain as it is. Your services rendered in Punjabi Bagh Vidyalaya will be recognized and benefit as per rules will be given to you.' WP(C) No.3033/1999 Page No.5 of 8 Thus, according to the petitioner she would be entitled to the benefit of 5 years service which she had rendered as the Head Mistress in the unrecognized school. The result, according to the petitioner, is that her entitlement to be placed in the senior scale would mature in the year 1993.

17. The respondent alleges that the entitlement of the petitioner to be placed in the senior scale would mature when she would have completed 12 years service as a TGT in the recognized school.

18. A fact may be noted. It is not in the pleadings of the parties, but was admitted at the hearing of the writ petition in conformity with the letter dated 7.1.1986. Increments which were earned by the petitioner during her 5 years service while functioning as the Head-Mistress of the primary school at Punjabi Bagh were protected.

19. Letter dated 7.1.1986 transferring petitioner to the recognized school, contents whereof have been noted in para 10 above, support the pay protection of the petitioner as also the protection of her service rendered in unrecognized school at Punjabi Bagh. The same clearly states that the petitioner's service rendered in Punjabi Bagh will be recognized under the new school. The letter clearly states that the salary of the petitioner would remain as it is. WP(C) No.3033/1999 Page No.6 of 8

20. What does one mean when one tells his employee on transfer to a new unit that service rendered in a different unit will be recognized and even the pay would be protected? It simply means that all benefits accruing on account of past service would be protected and implemented for purpose of continued service in the new unit.

21. Looked at from any angle, and in particular in teeth of the letter dated 7.1.1986, it does not lie in the mouth of the respondent to allege that the respondent will not look into the service rendered by the petitioner in the unrecognized school run by the respondent where petitioner functioned as a Head Mistress for 5 years.

22. It need hardly be re-emphasized that the pay scale of Head Mistress in a primary school is the same as the pay scale applicable to a TGT.

23. The writ petition has to succeed.

24. The petition is allowed.

25. A mandamus is issued to respondent No.1 to place the petitioner in the senior scale of TGT/Head Mistress as per the circular dated 12.8.1987 with effect from 1.7.1993. Benefit of the replacement scale with effect from 1.1.1996 i.e. when the recommendations of the Vth Pay Commission were implemented would also be give. Arrears would be calculated WP(C) No.3033/1999 Page No.7 of 8 and paid to the petitioner by the respondent within 12 weeks of the date of this order. Petitioner is held entitled to interest @ 6% p.m. on the amount which would be payable each month to the petitioner with effect from 1.7.1993 from the date the differential amount becomes due and payable pursuant to the present order till date of payment.

26. Petitioner is held entitled to cost quantified in sum of Rs.5000/-. 07 July, 2008 (PRADEEP NANDRAJOG) vg JUDGE WP(C) No.3033/1999 Page No.8 of 8