Mool Chand Gupta v. Umaruddin Khokhar

Delhi High Court · 09 Jul 2008 · 2008:DHC:13625
Rekha Sharma
RSA 147/2008
2008:DHC:13625
civil appeal_dismissed

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court dismissed the appeal holding that in absence of a notification under the Delhi Rent Control Act, the civil court had jurisdiction to entertain the possession suit and the appellant could not take contradictory legal positions.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
RSA 147/2008 .
MOOL CHAND GUPTA Appellant
Through Mr. M F Zama, Advocate
VERSUS
UMARUDDIN KHOKHAR &ORS Respondent
Through none
CORAM:
HON'BLE MISS JUSTICE REKHA SHARMA
09.07.2008 This appeal is directed against the
ORDER
of Additional
District Judge Shri IS Mehta dated April 22, 2008. By virtue of the impugned order, the learned Judge has upheld the order of the Civil
Judge Ms. Shuchi Shahmiri dated January 14, 2008 whereby the suit filed by the respondents for possession of shop situated in property r no. 656, Gall No. 8, 25 ft. road, Rajeev Gandhi Nagar, Mustafabad
(Naya Mustafabad), Karawal Nagar, Delhi - 110094 was decreed.
The only ground that has been urged by learned counsel for the appellant is that the suit property is situated in an area which is governed by the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958 and, therefore, the civil court was barred from entertaining the suit.
It has been held both by the Civil Judge as well as by the first appellate court that the appellant failed to place on record any notification issued under the provisions of sub-section (2) of Section
1 of the Delhi Rent Control Act notifying that Naya Mustafabad area where the property is situate is governed by the Delhi Rent Control
2008:DHC:13625 Act, 1958. The learned Civil Judge in his judgment has also observed that the appellant himself had filed a petition . under
Section 27 of the Delhi Rent Control Act which he later withdrew on the ground that provisions of the Delhi Rent Control Act were not applicable to the area where the property in question was situated.
However, when the suit against him was filed before the Civil Court, he took somersault and raised a preliminary objection that the suit was barred under Section 50 of the Delhi Rent Control Act. The learned Civil Judge, thus further observed that the appellant could not be allowed to take contradictory stands as per his whims.
Having regard to the concurrent finding of both the Civil
Judge and the First Appellate Court holding that the appellant failed to place on record the notification showing that the area where the property is situate is governed by the Delhi Rent Control Act, I find no merit in the appeal. The same is dismissed.
JULY 09, 2008 PC.
REKHA SHARMA, J.
2008:DHC:13625