Full Text
JUDGMENT
25/27, Asaf Ali Road
New Delhi ….Appellant
Through: Mr. Tarkeshwar Nath, Adv.
1. Arun Saha S/o. Sh. Mishri Saha
2. Meena Devi W/o. Arun Saha
3. Asha Kumari D/o. Arun Saha All are residents of Jhuggi Sarai Kale Khan, Ganda Nala, New Delhi-13.
4. Sh. Hari Ram Singh S/o. Sh. Chamki Lal Singh R/o. Village Bhatta Chak, P.O. Shakund, P.S. and District-Bhagalpur (Bihar)
5. Yashpal S/o. Sh. Ram Kishan, 2008:DHC:1820 R/o. 8/13, Jangpura, Bhogal, New Delhi-14 ….Respondents. Through: Coram: HON'BLE MR.
JUSTICE V.B. GUPTA
1. Whether the Reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes
2. To be referred to Reporter or not? Yes
3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? Yes V.B.Gupta, J. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. has filed the present appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (for short as „Act‟) challenging the judgment, dated 11th January, 2008 passed by Sh. J.P.S. Malik, Judge MACT.
2. The facts of this case are that on 14th June, 2000, the deceased Rajesh Saha died due to injuries received by him in an accident near Ganda Nala, Sarai Kalen Khan, Delhi. This accident was caused due to rash and negligent driving of vehicle No. DIG 4727 which was being driven by respondent No.4. The vehicle in question is owned by respondent No.5 and insured with the appellant. The deceased was doing the work of Kabari and the offending vehicle was dumping the garbage and was being driven in a rash and negligent manner by its driver.
3. Vide impugned judgment, the Tribunal awarded a compensation of Rs. Rs.2,80,005/- along with simple interest @ 9% p.a. from the date of filing of the petition.
4. It has been contended by learned counsel for the appellant that the owner as well as driver did not produce the driving licence in spite of notice under Order 12 Rule 8 CPC given to them and as such adverse inference has to be drawn against them. It is further contended that the insured has committed the breach of the terms and conditions of the Insurance Policy. Therefore, the insurer is entitled to the recovery of awarded amount from the owner of the offending vehicle and the present case is of a no driving licence and as such the award passed by the Tribunal is liable to be set aside.
5. Ld. Counsel for the appellant has also relied upon the decision of Allahabad High court in Oriental Insurance co. Ltd. v. Indrasani Devi & ors., 2007 ACJ 1192, in support of its contentions.
6. Chapter XI of the Act, providing compulsory insurance of vehicles against third party risks is a social welfare legislation to extend relief by compensation to victims of accidents caused by use of motor vehicles. The provisions of compulsory insurance coverage of all vehicles are with this paramount object and the provisions of the Act have to be so interpreted as to effectuate the said object.
7. Section 149 of the Act provides as follows;
16. A driving licence is expected to be with the Driver and not with the owner of the vehicle. Thus, mere nonproduction of licence is not enough to discharge the burden of the Insurance Company. Merely giving notice to the owner of the vehicle to produce licence is not sufficient nor any admission, if any, of the owner that the driver was not holding a valid driving licence at the relevant time, and therefore cannot absolve the Insurance Company from liability.
17. When the Insurance Company takes the plea that it is not liable to pay compensation or to idemnify the insured as the driver was not holding a valid licence for driving the vehicle on the date of the accident and the vehicle was being driven in breach of the terms of the policy, the Insurance Company has to discharge the burden by placing legal and cogent evidence before the Tribunal (see Narcinva V. Alfredo 1985 ACJ 397 (supra): and the Division Bench cases of this Court in Shajadibai v. Babookhan and Ors. Vol. (1) 1988 ACC 24).
18. Further, the facts in the present case are different from the Oriental Insurance co. Ltd. v. Indrasani Devi and Others (supra) case because in that case neither the truck owner nor the truck driver appeared before the court nor did they produce even a photocopy of the licence. In these circumstances, it cannot be said that burden was upon the insurance company to prove that the truck driver did not have a driving licence. Therefore, the Court held that the insurance company may pay the amount of compensation to the claimants and thereafter the insurance company may recover that amount from the truck owner.
19. However, in the case in hand, the owner of the offending vehicle has testified that he has seen the driving licence of the driver but unfortunately he did not retain the copy of the driving licence of the driver who being a resident of Bihar could not be served with the summons.
20. Thus, the insurance company being the insurer cannot avoid its liability to indemnify the owner, for no fault of the owner when he had seen the driving licence of the driver as deposed by him on oath.
21. In absence of any iota of evidence from the side of appellant, I do not find any error in the impugned judgment whereby the Tribunal directed the Insurance Company to pay the compensation amount to the claimants without any recovery rights.
22. The instant appeal is, therefore not maintainable and accordingly, dismissed.
23. No orders as to costs.
V. B. GUPTA
(JUDGE) 30th May, 2008 rs