Veena Gautam v. Jivendra Gautam

Delhi High Court · 30 May 2008 · 2008:DHC:1819
V. B. Gupta
CM No. 6081/2008 in MAT App. No.60 of 2007
2008:DHC:1819
family appeal_dismissed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court upheld the mother's custody of the minor child while granting the father visitation rights during summer vacations, emphasizing the child's welfare as paramount.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
CM No. 6081/2008 in MAT App. No.60 of 2007
JUDGMENT
reserved on: 27th May, 2008
Judgment delivered on:30th May, 2008 Smt. Veena Gautam
W/o. Shri Jivendra Gautam, R/o. C-94, Minal Residency, Raj Homes, J.K. Road, Bhopal, M.P. ….Appellant
Through: Mr. M.P. Acharya with Mr. Pradeep Acharya, Adv. along with appellant and child, Akshat in person.
Versus

1. Mr. Jivendra Gautam S/o. Shri. R.R. Gautam, R/o. D-II, 2369, Vasant Kunj, New Delhi-110070.

2. Jitender Singh Yadav S/o. Unknown, @ Jatin, R/o. B-2, Sector 20, Noida, U.P. ….Respondents. Through: Ms. Veena Goswami, Adv. along with respondent in person. Coram: HON'BLE MR.

JUSTICE V.B. GUPTA

1. Whether the Reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes 2008:DHC:1819

2. To be referred to Reporter or not? Yes

3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? Yes V.B.Gupta, J. The present appeal under section 28 of Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 (for short as the “Act”) has been filed by the Appellant/Wife against the judgment and decree dated 07.07.07 passed by Sh. Gurdeep Singh, ADJ, Delhi.

2. It is averred that the marriage between the appellant and the respondent was solemnized on 17.02.95 at Bareilly as per Hindu rites and ceremonies. Out of the wedlock between the parties, a male child was born on 30.03.96. Later on, there started differences between the parties and respondent/husband filed a petition of Divorce.

3. Vide order dated 07.07.07, the Trial Court dissolved the marriage of the appellant with Respondent no.1 and granted the decree of divorce in favour of respondent. Since the matter of custody of child was pending before the Guardianship Court it was also ordered that the order of the Guardianship Court would be binding upon both the parties.

4. Aggrieved thereby, the Appellant/Wife has filed the present appeal before this Court. During the pendency of this appeal, the Respondent has filed an application under section 26 of the Act read with section 151 CPC, praying that he be allowed to have temporary custody of the child Master Akshat Gautam @ Donny during summer vacations from middle of May, 2008 to first week of July, 2008 or any other period at the convenience to the child as per his vacations, so that the child could spent considerable time with his father and paternal family. The father is residing in posh locality of Vasant kunj, New Delhi and the child will enjoy better company and better status besides all other facilities available in Metro city like New Delhi.

5. It has been stated by the Respondent that during the pendency of proceedings of Divorce and section 26 of the Act in the Trial Court, the parties reached the compromise to take divorce by mutual consent and issue of custody of child was settled as per details were given in the order dated 3.4.01. In the said order, it has been mentioned that; “As regards the custody of child, it is agreed that child will continue to study in a school in Bhopal and the Respondent shall handover the child during summer vacations and petitioner shall handover the custody of child back after summer vacation.”

6. Although the respondent’s petition for custody of child was disallowed on the ground of jurisdiction by Guardian Judge, Delhi but in appeal filed by Respondent in this Court, this Court allowed the Respondent to meet the child on every Sunday of the month at Income Tax Guest House in Bhopal for 2 days. The Appellant and her father along with her relations generally surround the child during meeting and do not allow the child to have free talk to the Respondent/father or the grandfather of the child, who generally visit the child for meeting besides their relations on number of occasions. Although Respondent gifted mobile phone with SIM Card to the child but the Appellant is not allowing him to talk to respondent. Thus, in the circumstances as the child who is of tender age of twelve needs company of his father and by meeting almost every month, the Respondent and his son has developed a special relationship. So, it will be in the welfare and betterment of the child, if the child is allowed to stay with the Respondent i.e. father of the child and his relations including grandparents, uncles, aunts and their children etc. during summer vacations.

7. In reply filed on behalf of the Appellant, it is stated that the child has been residing with his mother since his early age and the respondent no.1 has taken no care of the child all these years and all the present exercise is aimed at to force the appellant to agree for divorce and to withdraw the appeal as the appellant is living the life only for her son Donny. The child has grown up old enough to wisely ascertain his wishes, affection and welfare. At any rate when he will come to know of the wild charges levelled by respondent no.1 and his father against the Appellant, the mental health of the child may be adversely affected. Thus, the order prayed for will only invite trouble and botheration to the child as well as to the family and such a step would be extreme hazardous to physical and mental health of the child.

8. It is further submitted by the Appellant that during the meetings, the Respondent No. 1 and his father make ugly scenes, indulge in quarrelling, abusing filthy words and show objectionable attitude and behavior, which virtually make the child tense, feared and depressed. Such kind of attitude has hurt the feelings of the child immensely and is not at all in the welfare of him. Thus, the child has been continuously living with his mother; he has no recognitions with Respondent no.1 and his family and has no affection or familiarity at all. The child cannot be thrown in utter unknown, strange and unhealthy atmosphere. The Respondent no.1, his father and other family members do treat the child brutally in meetings at Bhopal and the child do not wish to visit them at all and he virtually fears from them all. The child may have grave down fall in health and mind if he is carried by Respondent no.1. Thus, the application filed by the Respondents should be dismissed.

9. In rejoinder filed by the Appellant, he has controverted the averments made by the Respondent.

10. I have heard the Ld. Counsels for the parties and have perused the record.

8,397 characters total

11. The duty cast on the court while considering matters relating to custody, health or education of the minor child is to secure the paramount welfare of the minor. The rights and wishes of the parties are subservient to it. Procedural, legal objections and technicalities should not come in the way of doing substantial justice in ensuring welfare of the minor, who is the victim of the marital discord.

12. Having regard to the complexities of the situation in which this Court has been called upon to balance the emotional confrontation of the parents of the children and the welfare of the minors, I have given anxious thought as to what would be in the best interest of the minors. I have myself spoken to child, Akshat, without either of the parents being present, in order to ascertain his preference in the matter.

13. Although the child had expressed before this Court that he did not want to meet his father, but keeping in mind the fact that the welfare of the child is of paramount importance, the Court seriously consider whether the child should be deprived of his father’s company or not?

14. Without going into the allegation and misapprehensions expressed, on the paramount consideration of best safeguarding the interest of the children, in my opinion, order for visitation rights of the Respondent deserves to be passed.

15. I, therefore, feel that the interest of child will be best served if he remains with the appellant but with sufficient access to the Respondent no.1, to visit him at frequent interval.

16. Accordingly, applicant/respondent No.1 (the father of the child and respondent No.1’s father), shall be permitted to meet the child at Bhopal where the child is currently staying and studying. The meeting shall take place in the Income Tax Guest House. These two persons shall be permitted to meet the child on every Sunday from 10 a.m. to 6 p.m. during the summer vacations. The appellant/wife and her father shall also be at liberty to be there at the time when the meeting takes place. 1st June, 2008, is fixed for the meeting with the child at the aforesaid place at 10 a.m. Similar meeting shall also take place on subsequent Sundays of June and July, 2008, till the child has summer vacations in his school, for the same duration.

17. This is however subject to the desire of the child.

18. Application under Section 26 of the Act, stands disposed of in view of the above terms.

19. Order Dasti.

V. B. GUPTA

(JUDGE) 30th May, 2008 rs