Full Text
W.P.(C) No. 2207/2007
JUDGMENT
Through: Ms. Maneesha Dhir with Ms. Preeti Dalal,Advocates.
Through : Mr. Ajay Kumar Tandon with Mr. V.K. Tandon
Advocates for respondent No. 3.
Mr. V. Seshagiri, Advocate for respondent No. 4.
Mr. Prem, Advocate for respondent No. 5.
Mr. A. Mariarputham and Mr. Anurag Mathur, Advocates for respondent No. 8.
Ms. Indrani Mukherjee with Ms. Chandrani Mukherjee, Advocates for respondent 10.
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V.K. SHALI
1. Whether the Reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes
2. To be referred to the Reporter or not? Yes
3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? Yes W.P.(C) No. 2207/2007 Pg. 1 of 12 2008:DHC:1981-DB JUDGMENT 10.07.2008 MUKUL MUDGAL, J.
1. This writ petition challenges the order of AAIFR dated 21 st February,2007, dismissing the appeal preferred by the petitioner on the ground of limitation. The order of the BIFR confirmed its earlier order dated 2 nd January, 2002 to wind up the company under Section 20(1) of the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act (hereinafter referred to as the SICA) and further directed that the opinion be forwarded to the concerned High Court for necessary action in accordance with law. The Company was also restrained under Section 22(b) of SICA, from disposing of or alienating any of its fixed assets and current assets without specific prior approval of the BIFR and the charge holders until the appointment of an Official Liquidator by the concerned High Court.
2. In the order challenged in appeal, dated 4 th March, 2004, the BIFR noted that subsequent to the order dated 2 nd January, 2002, giving the last opportunity to the promoters, the company had not submitted any rehabilitation proposal till that W.P.(C) No. 2207/2007 Pg. 2 of 12 date and had also failed to comply with the direction of the Madras High Court regarding deposit of Rs.[1] crore, resulting in the vacation of the interim order in the Madras High Court.
3. The company's stand before the BIFR was that no scheme of rehabilitation was submitted as the Manging Director of the company had been in on going negotiations with the banks and financial institutions to arrive at a negotiated settlement and failure of negotiations was the cause of not submitting the rehabilitation scheme by the company. The ICICI submitted that no negotiations had been held by the Managing Director of the company for arriving at a settlement of dues and even the associate companies of the petitioner company namely Kongar Integrated Fibres Ltd. And Kongrar Textiles Ltd. had also been ordered to be wound up by the BIFR. Consequently, upon the following reasoning in the concluding paragraphs, the BIFR by order dated 4 th March, 2004, held as follows:- “9. Having heard the submissions and considering the material on record, the Bench particularly in W.P.(C) No. 2207/2007 Pg. 3 of 12 view of the fact that the Company had failed to comply with MHC's order dated 13.3.2003 for deposit of Rs.[1] crore with BOI came to the conclusion that despite having allowed enough time and opportunity, it had not been possible to formulate any acceptance revival scheme for the company enabling it to make its net worth exceed the accumulated losses within a reasonable time while meeting of its due financial obligations and that the company as a result thereof was not likely to become viable in future and that it was just, equitable and in public interest that the company should be wound up u/s 20(1) of the Act. The Bench, therefore, confirmed its earlier prima facie opinion formed vide order dated 2.1.2002 to wind up the company in terms of Section 20(1) of the Act. It was also directed that this opinion be forwarded to the concerned High Court along with copies of all earlier orders/proceedings in the case for further necessary action according to law.
10. The Bench further directed in terms of clause (b) of Section 22A of the Act that the company should not dispose of or alienate in any other way any of its fixed assets and current assets without specific prior approval of the BIFR and the shareholders till such time as an Official Liquidator was appointed by the concerned High Court.”
4. 4 th March, 2004 was the date of the impugned order, which order was admittedly passed in the presence of the Consultant of the petitioner company. The certified copy of the said order was applied for the first time on 19 th May, 2004. W.P.(C) No. 2207/2007 Pg. 4 of 12 The appeal was thereafter filed before AAIFR on 4 th June, 2004. Reliance was placed by Ms. Maneesha Dhir, the learned counsel for the petitioner on Regulation 13 of the BIFR Regulations, 1987, which reads as follows:-
5. Section 25 of the SICA reads as follows:-
6. This clearly shows that beyond the period of 60 days, the appellate authority does not have any jurisdiction to entertain an appeal. In the present case, the appellant was conscious of the order dated 4 th March, 2004, as its representative W.P.(C) No. 2207/2007 Pg. 6 of 12 was present on that date and for the first time the application for certified copy was filed on 19 th May, 2004, well after the expiry of 60 days.
AAIFR has given the following reasoning in the order dated 21 st February, 2007, while dismissing the appeal of the petitioner:- “7. We find from records that the impugned order was passed on 4.3.2004 in presence of the representative on behalf of the appellant. The application for certified copy of the impugned order was submitted on 19.5.2004, although the impugned order dated 4.3.2004 was issued to all concerned including the appellant by the Board on 24.3.2004 and the appellant ought to have received the same in the normal course shortly after 24.3.2004 which can be presumed from the provision u/s 114 of the Indian Evidence Act and Illustration (f) thereof.” On the basis of the above reasoning, the appeal was dismissed as being barred by limitation.
8. We have heard the learned counsel for the petitioner who relied upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Puwada Venkatesara Rao vs. Chidamna Venkata Ramana, (1976) 2 SCC 409. The relevant position of law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the said judgment reads as follows:- W.P.(C) No. 2207/2007 Pg. 7 of 12
9. In our view the above decision which related to the service of a notice to a party would not come to the aid of the petitioner as in the present case the petitioner inspite of being aware of the BIFR's order passed in its presence had applied for certified copy well beyond the period of 60 days which was the outer limit within the AAIFR could have entertained the appeal. Further there is no enabling provision which would vest the Appellate Tribunal to condone the delay W.P.(C) No. 2207/2007 Pg. 8 of 12 beyond 60 days even subject to a party showing sufficient cause for the same.
10. The learned counsel for the petitioner also relied upon a judgment of a learned Single Judge of this Court in Jagat Ram Khullar and another vs. Battu Mal, AIR 1976 DELHI 111. The relevant portion relied upon, reads as follows:-
11. In our view the petitioner's case set up in the writ petition cannot be W.P.(C) No. 2207/2007 Pg. 10 of 12 sustained as the petitioner has only stated that the order dated 4 th March, 2004 was not received by it in normal course by the petitioner. In our view the petitioner had applied for certified copy of the order beyond the period of 60 days, and cannot be now heard to say that its appeal should be treated in time. Even if we treat the appeal to be filed in time, we have already noted the finding of the BIFR that the appellant is not serious about the revival of the company and that the company has enjoyed the interim order of the Madras High Court which stipulated the deposit of Rs.[1] crore, and that non-compliance of the said condition of deposit led to the vacation of the interim order. The findings of facts by the BIFR that the petitioner never submitted a rehabilitation scheme, has rightly been recorded by it and even if the appeal was to be treated as having been filed in time, there is no ground to interfere with the aforesaid order of the BIFR on merits. The petitioner had thus enjoyed conditional interim order of the Madras High Court without complying with the condition of deposit of Rs. 1 crore. This is another factor which must preclude the exercise of the writ jurisdiction in favour of the W.P.(C) No. 2207/2007 Pg. 11 of 12 petitioner. Thus even if we assume that the appellate order was not entirely right in law in dismissing the appeal on the ground of limitation, the facts of the case as noted above clearly dis-entitles the petitioner to the equitable and discretionary relief under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. The writ petition is accordingly dismissed with costs quantified at Rs.20,000/- payable not later than 4 weeks to the Delhi High Court Legal Services Committee.
(MUKUL MUDGAL) JUDGE (V.K. SHALI) July 10, 2008 JUDGE kkb