MTNL Senior Executive Association v. Chairman and Managing Director, MTNL

Delhi High Court · 26 May 2008 · 2008:DHC:1751
Anil Kumar
W.P.(C) No.6465/2007
2008:DHC:1751
administrative appeal_dismissed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court dismissed the petitioners' interim relief seeking to restrain posting and promotion of DOT officers in MTNL, holding that the absorption process is sub-judice and no prima facie case for interim directions was made out.

Full Text
Translation output
CM Nos. 12140 & 17173 of 2007 in WP (C) 6465/2007
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
W.P.(C) No.6465/2007
Date of Decision: May 26, 2008
MTNL Senior Executive Association ….… Petitioners
Through its Secretary & Anr
Through: Mr.Mahabir Singh, Sr.Advocate with Mr.Nikhil Jain, Advocate.
VERSUS
Chairman and Managing Director, MTNL ........ Respondents
& Anr
Through : Mr.V.K.Rao, Advocate for the respondent No.1.
Mr.P.P.Malhotra, ASG with Mr.Suresh Kait, Advocate for the respondent No.2.
CORAM :-
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KUMAR
JUDGMENT

1. Whether reporters of Local papers may YES be allowed to see the judgment?

2. To be referred to the reporter or not? NO

3. Whether the judgment should be reported NO in the Digest? ANIL KUMAR, J. CM Nos.12140 & 17173/2007

1. The petitioner no.1 is an association of absorbed DOT Group A officers of MTNL who have already exercised their option for absorption in MTNL. In the writ petition they are seeking implementation of the terms and conditions of letter dated 4th October, 2005 and other 2008:DHC:1751 letters/circulars issued on the same subject and for direction to the respondents not to post on promotion, transfer or deputation DOT officers in MTNL and to prepare a seniority list for Group A officers in MTNL and to fill the post on promotion and to repatriate the unabsorbed officers from MTNL and to create a trust under Rule 37A of the CCS(Pension) Rules, 1972 for pension as provided under clause 18(i) of the general terms and conditions and for a direction to respondents to call for options for pro-rata pension and to grant the same to the petitioners.

2. The petitioners have filed CM No.12140/2007 seeking an interim restraint against the posting on promotion/transfer and deputation of DOT officers in MTNL and directions to the respondents to promote the eligible officers of Group A against the vacancies available in MTNL after preparing the seniority list and to provide pension for retiring absorbed officers from Government of India and to grant pro-rata pension as an interim measure.

3. On behalf of Secretary, Department of Telecommunications, respondent no.2 the counsel had made a statement on 11th September, 2007 that no posting on promotion/transfer of DOT officers shall be made in MTNL. On the statement of the counsel for respondent No.2 the Court had ordered accordingly and it further clarified that in case of any transfer it would be open for the respondent to approach the Court. The arrangement pursuant to the statement of respondent No.2 is continuing.

4. An application being CM No.17173/2007 has also been filed by the respondent No.2 for vacation of order dated 11th September, 2007 passed on the statement made by the counsel for the respondent no.2.

5. The petitioner in his application for interim directions has contended that the action of the respondents in not implementing the terms and conditions for absorption of Group `A' officers in MTNL is arbitrary and discriminatory. It was alleged that the posts in MTNL are being filled up by DOT officers, ignoring the claim and seniority of absorbed Group `A' officers which is causing irreparable loss and injustice to Group `A' absorbed officers. It is also contended that the officers who have not exercised the option for absorption are promoted on regular basis against the work and post in MTNL and are being posted to work in PSU whereas the names of the absorbed officers have been removed from the promotion list of DOT altogether which is contrary to the vital terms and conditions of absorption. The petitioners/applicants have also sought interim directions on account of not settling the pro-rata pension and because the option has not been invited by the respondents as per clause 18(2). The interim direction is also sought regarding non creation of pension fund by the Government in MTNL as warranted under Rule 37A.

6. The petition is contested by respondents. Respondent No.2 has contended that petitioner No.1 is alleged to be an association, however, no resolution has been filed in support of authorization of the competent person nor any copy of the Memorandum of Association and bye-laws or registration certificate has been filed on behalf of the petitioner no.1. It is also contended that though the petition is filed in representative capacity but the disputes will be individual service disputes and no facts have been disclosed as to how a particular individual officer has been prejudiced. Regarding absorption it is contended that number of Court cases are pending and consequently list prevailing before initiation of absorption process is being maintained. Regarding absorption process of ITS Group `A' officers it is stated that OM dated 24th March, 2005 has not attained finality due to various Court cases and presidential order issued for absorption in MTNL/BSNL in respect of individual officers are also subject to final outcome of Court cases.

7. According to respondent No.2 DPCs for regular promotions against civil posts are only conducted by UPSC to consider the eligible officers for promotion to next higher grade who are available in the department as on crucial date of vacancy year and none of the vacancies arising out of retirement, resignation, VRS etc of the absorbed Group `A' employees has been considered for holding of DPC by the UPSC and these vacancies are being used for promotion of eligible absorbed officers only. The respondents have also asserted that it is ensured that absorbed ITS officers are not put to any loss in the matter of promotion and to fulfill that a common seniority list of ITS officers is also being maintained which fact is also being clarified by clarification dated 30th May, 2005 stipulating that seniority within the respective cadres shall be the same as was prevailing in DOT as on 1st October, 2000 subject to any alterations in the seniority made by Department of Telecommunications after 1st October, 2000 till the presidential order for absorption is issued.

8. The respondent No.2 has also contended that the concerned CMDs have already been intimated to convene the DPCs in respect of eligible officers and to promote them. Reliance has been placed for this on office memorandum dated 30th September, 2000. Regarding the prorata pension it is stated that Department of Pension and Pensioner‟s Welfare has amended sub Rule 8 of Rule 37A of CCS Pension Rule, 1972 with effect from 14th October, 2005 and has made provision for giving option to the absorbed Group “A” officers to receive pro-rata retirement benefits for the service rendered under the Central Government and the Department of Pension and Pensioner‟s Welfare has been requested to amend the rule further to make it effective from 30th September, 2000. Regarding creation of pension fund reliance has been placed on DO letter No.40-14/3-2003-Pen (T) dated 23rd August, 2005 address to CMD, MTNL advising him for creation of pension fund and also to communicate the quantum of Government liability towards one time lump sum settlement in accordance with sub Rule 15 of Rule 37A. The averment has also been made that every effort is being made to implement the terms and conditions for absorption of Group A officers in MTNL/BSNL and those employees who have already been absorbed in MTNL are not put to any loss.

9. An ex parte order dated 11th September, 2007 was passed on the application of the petitioners on the statement made by the counsel for the respondent no.2, directing the respondents not to post on promotion/transfer DOT Officers in MTNL. The respondents have filed an application being CM No.17173/2007 for vacation of this interim order whereby respondents were directed not to post on promotion/transfer DOT Officers in MTNL on various grounds including the ground that the statement was given by the counsel for the respondent no.2 on account of misunderstanding.

10 The respondents have contended that the office memorandum dated 24th March, 2005 of Department of Telecommunication calling for option from all the Group `A' Officers and various clarifications given by OM dated 4th October, 2005 were challenged before the Central Administrative Tribunal, Principal Bench, in New Delhi in OA No.693/2005. The petition was disposed of by order dated 31st October, 2005 holding that Secretary, Department of Telecommunication shall extend the date of submission of options of Group `A' Officers who have not yet been absorbed in MTNL to 30th November, 2005 and thereafter, respondents shall be at liberty to take appropriate decisions on such options within a reasonable period. Against the order dated 31st October, 2005 by the Central Administrative Tribunal, the writ petition being W.P.C. No.22515/2005 was filed and after hearing the parties the following order has been passed: “In terms of the prayer made by the counsel appearing for the petitioners, the petitioners are allowed further 10 days time to enable them to exercise their options. Any option, if exercised, by the petitioners in terms of the order passed by the respondents and any other order passed by the respondents during the pendency of this writ petition pertaining to the subject matter which is being agitated herein would be subject to the result of the writ petition making it clear that if in case the petition is allowed and any adverse order is passed by the respondents against the petitioners, the same would abide by the final orders to be passed in the writ petition.”

11. Pursuant to order dated 28th November, 2005 of the Division Bench, the 10 days‟ time granted to exercise the option has expired, yet the repatriation of Group `A' Officers who have not exercised the option pursuant to interim order, it appears cannot be finalized as the writ petition is still pending and other petitions are pending before Central Administrative Tribunal. After hearing the writ petition, if the Division Bench comes to the conclusion that the Group `A' Officers who had been asked to exercise options and who had not exercised options, were not offered comprehensive terms and conditions for absorption in MTNL, and because the terms and conditions of absorption lacked complete information on various aspects of absorption like promotional avenues, pension, etc., they can still be allowed to be absorbed. Consequently it is inevitable to infer that the absorption process of officers of DOT in MTNL/BSNL has not attained finality. Such officers are still working with MTNL/BSNL and continuing as Officers of Department of Telecommunication.

12. This cannot be disputed, in the facts and circumstances, that the absorption process started in terms of OM dated 24th March, 2005 has not attained finality as the matter is still sub-judiced before the Division Bench and in some other Tribunals and other High Courts which is apparent from the copies of orders passed by Central Administrative Tribunal, Allahabad Bench and Mumbai Bench and the copy of the order dated 11th July, 2006 of High Court of Andhra Pradesh extending the interim suspension of OM dated 24th march, 2005. Another relevant fact which is not disputed by the petitioner is that only 36 officers of ITS Group have been permanently absorbed in MTNL on the basis of their option whereas approximately 218 ITS Group `A' Officers have not exercised their option for absorption but are still working in MTNL.

20,514 characters total

13. By the order dated 18th October 2005 those officials who had not exercised their option were directed to be repatriated to Department of Telecommunication. An interim order to maintain the status quo ante prior to 18th October 2005 was granted by Central Administrative Tribunal benches situated at Allahabad and Mumbai. Consequent thereto the Grade `A‟ officers who had been ordered to be repatriated have been allowed to join back and they are still working with MTNL/BSNL. There are about 218 group `A‟ officers who are involved in operations, development, planning and other related work out of which only 36 officers have been absorbed after they exercised their option. Since the absorption has not been completed the seniority which was prevalent before some of the officers were absorbed is still continuing. Presidential orders issued for absorption in MTNL/BSNL in respect of individual officers are also subject to final outcome of court cases

14. The petitioners have prayed that no officer be posted on transfer, promotion or deputation to the MTNL. The generic plea on behalf of the association cannot be accepted because no details have been given by the petitioners to substantiate the plea that they shall suffer irreparable loss in case unabsorbed officers are transferred or appointed on deputation. If the rules of the MTNL permit appointment on deputation, the petitioner no.1 association cannot claim that no officers of DOT should be appointed on deputation. The petitioners also cannot insist that no person should be promoted in the department of telecommunication on the vacancies which are available in the department as on crucial date of vacancy year and none of the vacancies arising out of retirement, resignation, VRS etc. as none of these vacancies are being considered for filling which are only for absorbed officers in MTNL. The seniority of the members of petitioner No.1 shall not be affected by promotion of the officials of other departments in the facts and circumstances. The time permitted by the orders of the Government and orders passed by the Courts for exercising their options for absorption has already expired. The time granted by the Division Bench to the officials who had not exercised their option for absorption has already expired. Whether such officials whose petition is still pending before the Division Bench shall be entitled to be absorbed in MTNL is yet to be decided. The possibility that such officers who have not exercised their option up till now and whose writ petition is still pending may be allowed and they may be absorbed in MTNL, cannot be denied their promotion in their parent department on the grounds as raised by the petitioners.

15. The petitioners have also sought interim directions for preparation of seniority list of MTNL considering those officials who have exercised their option and who have already been absorbed. This cannot be disputed that the OM dated 24th March, 2005 has not attained finality due to various court cases and presidential orders issued for absorption in MTNL/BSNL in respect of individual officers are subject to final outcome of Court's cases. Preparation of seniority list considering only those officials who have exercised their option and not considering other officials whose matters are still pending will create multiplicity of proceedings and in the facts and circumstances it will not be an appropriate to direct the respondents to finalize the seniority list by an interim direction.

16. The petitioners have sought repatriation of unabsorbed officials. The Court cases on behalf of these officials are still pending. Though the time granted in the proceedings to exercise their option has expired, however, the proceedings have not been finally disposed of and they are still pending. In the circumstances by an interim order no directions should be given to the respondent no.1 to repatriate those officials to their parent department who have not exercised their options.

17. The plea of the petitioners that the posts in MTNL are being filled up by the DOT officers ignoring the claim and seniority of absorbed officers prima facie appears to be without any basis, as no particulars have been given of the officers who have not been promoted according to recruitment rules for promotion. Nothing has been disclosed about the officers who have been appointed on deputation ignoring the claim of the absorbed officers who are allegedly entitled for promotion for those posts on which the unabsorbed officers on deputation have been appointed. If a post is to be filled by promotion, it cannot be filled by appointing an officer on deputation unless the rules provides for filling the posts on deputation. If the rules provide for filling the posts by deputation, the petitioner's member cannot have any grievance. The allegations made by petitioners are generic without any particulars and in the circumstances the petitioners are unable to show any prime case in their favor. The officers who are on deputation are not entitled for promotion in MTNL unless they are absorbed, If a post in the MTNL can be filled up on deputation, the members of the petitioner no.1 cannot have a grievance about it nor can they allege that they will suffer irreparable loss or that they will suffer greater inconvenience on account of promotion of officers in their department who have not exercised their option and who are still on deputation in MTNL.

18. The petitioners have also alleged that the officers who have not been absorbed, are promoted on regular basis against the work and post in MTNL. No particulars and details of any of such officials have been given. Merely on the bald plea of the petitioners they are not entitled for any interim relief in the facts and circumstances nor in the circumstances it can be inferred that the balance of convenience is in favor of the petitioners so as to be entitled for an interim direction/order from this Court.

19. From the pleas of the respondents it is apparent that the DPCs for regular promotions against civil post only are being conducted by UPSC to consider the eligible officers for promotion to next higher grade which are available to the department and none of the vacancies arising out of retirement, resignation, VRS etc. of absorbed group `A‟ employees have been considered which are only for absorbed officers. The respondent no.2 has also asserted that the members of petitioner no.1 are not put to any loss in the matter of promotion and to achieve that a common seniority list is also being maintained. The petitioners are unable to show as to how they will be prejudiced in the facts and circumstances from the promotion of those officers who have not been absorbed. The respondents have further asserted that to further safeguard the interests of the members of petitioner no.1, CMDs of MTNL/BSNL have been asked to convene the DPC in respect of eligible officers and to promote them on the recommendation of the DPC. No details of the officers who have been promoted on regular basis in MTNL although they have not exercised their option for absorption, have been given by the petitioners. The members of petitioner's association cannot have a grievance about removal of their names from the promotion list of DOT after their absorption nor they can claim on this ground that the officers of DOT who have not yet been promoted should not be promoted or should not be appointed on deputation to MTNL/BSNL. The allegations of the petitioners are vague and in the circumstances, the interim directions/orders and as prayed by them cannot be passed in their favor

20. The Department of Pension and Pensioner‟s Welfare has amended sub Rule 8 of Rule 37A of CCS Pension Rule, 1972 with effect from 14th October, 2005 and has made provision for giving option to the absorbed Group “A” officers to receive pro-rata retirement benefits for the service rendered under the Central Government and the Department of Pension and Pensioner‟s Welfare has been requested to amend the rule further to make it effective from 30th September, 2000. In view of this averment of the respondents, no interim order can be granted at this stage nor it will be appropriate to pass any general order.

21. For pension fund it is apparent that DO letter No.40-14/3-2003- Pen (T) dated 23rd August, 2005 has been address to CMD, MTNL advising him for creation of pension fund and also to communicate the quantum of Government liability towards one time lump sum settlement in accordance with sub Rule 15 of Rule 37A. In the circumstances it will not be appropriate to grant any general directions to the respondents regarding creation of pension fund and for pro-rata pension.

22. In the circumstances the apprehensions and allegations of the petitioners are without any legal basis and the petitioners are unable to show that inconvenience caused to them shall be greater in case interim relief as prayed by them is not granted. The petitioners therefore, are not entitled for an order that no postings on promotion/transfer of Department of technology officer be made in MTNL nor they are entitled for other interim directions.

23. For the forgoing reasons, the application for interim directions by the petitioners being CM 12140 of 2007 is dismissed and the application of the respondent no.2 being CM No.17173 of 2007 is allowed and the order dated 11th September, 2007 passed on the basis of the statement made by the counsel for the respondent no.2 is vacated. Considering the facts and circumstances, the parties are however, left to bear their own costs. May 26, 2008.

ANIL KUMAR J. „Dev‟