Full Text
Date of Decision: 26.05.2008
Capt.Rajinder Singh Rosha ….… Petitioner
Through: Mr. Manjit Singh ahluwalia, Advocate along with petitioner in person.
Through : Mr.Ravi Kant Chadha, Sr.Advocate with Mr.Dheeraj Malhotra and
Mr.Mritunjaya Kumar Singh, Advocates for the respondent.
JUDGMENT
1. Whether reporters of Local papers may YES be allowed to see the judgment?
2. To be referred to the reporter or not? NO
3. Whether the judgment should be reported NO in the Digest? ANIL KUMAR, J. *
1. The petitioner has prayed for initiation of contempt proceedings against the respondent, Jehangir Wadia (Jeh Wadia) for willfully disobeying the order dated 5th December, 2007 passed by the Court in CM No.16404/2007 in W.P(C) No.8703/2007. 2008:DHC:1752
2. The petitioner filed the writ petition No.8703/2007 seeking interalia direction to the respondents in the writ petition to issue „No Objection Certificate‟ to the petitioner and to release the salary and other legitimate dues of the petitioner which were allegedly pending for last 11½ months amounting to about Rs.32,56,500/-.
3. The petitioner also filed an application for interim directions being CM No.16404/2007 seeking direction to the Director General, Civil Aviation; Union of India through Secretary, Ministry of Civil Aviation and Goair Airlines to issue `No objection certificate‟ to the petitioner so that he could join elsewhere in the meantime during the pendency of the writ petition.
4. On 5th December, 2007 this Court directed respondent no.3 to release the suspension allowance to the petitioner, if not already released, as per the rules applicable within a period of two weeks from that day on the plea of the respondent that the petitioner had been placed under suspension by the respondent No.3 since 13th July, 2007.
5. The petitioner contended that he several times met the respondent for compliance of order dated 5th December, 2007 but the respondent did not pay any heed to the request of the petitioner and thus he has committed the contempt of this Court and has deliberately and intentionally disobeyed the order.
6. The application is contested by the respondent. The respondent categorically contended that the petitioner never met him in relation to the compliance of order dated 5th December, 2007 and petitioner also did not made any request either in person or by any written communication. It was also contended that the respondent does not operate from any office at Jor Bagh where petitioner is alleged to have met the respondent.
7. It was further pleaded on behalf of respondent that the petitioner in violation of civil aviation requirements had willfully and deliberately stopped reporting for duties and remained absent from work, as a result of which the Goair Airlines suspended him and the notice period of six months had elapsed on 2nd August, 2007. The payment of the alleged suspension allowance was denied on the ground that an amount of Rs.53,162/- is recoverable as salary and the suspension allowance payable to the petitioner for 21 days from 13th July, 2007 comes to Rs.1,45,645/- only. The respondent also contended that a training cost of Rs.8,80,807/- is also recoverable from the petitioner and the total amount recoverable from the petitioner after adjusting the amount of suspension allowance is Rs.7,31,505/- and therefore, no amount on account of suspension allowance is payable to the petitioner.
8. An additional affidavit has been filed on behalf of respondent contending that the respondent has been unnecessarily dragged in the present petition with the aim to harass and pressurize him for illegal gains and no contempt has been committed by the respondent. It was asserted that the petitioner joined the respondent company on 19th July, 2006 in terms of Pilot Employment Agreement and no salary was payable for the month of July,2006 as the licence of the petitioner was not recurrent and because it was mandatory in view of Clause 8.[2] of the Pilot Employment Agreement. Though the gross salary of the petitioner was Rs.4,30,000/-, however, the suspension allowance was payable on the basic salary of the petitioner. The respondent has also contended that the petitioner is also liable for the expenses incurred in revalidation of his licence for which he underwent 10 simulator sessions.
9. From the facts stated hereinabove it is apparent that the respondent is no denying the entitlement of the petitioner for suspension allowance during the pendency of the disciplinary proceedings against him. What is contended by the respondent is that the amount payable on account of suspension allowance is liable to be adjusted from the amounts which are payable by the petitioner to the respondent under various accounts. The respondent was not directed to pay the suspension allowance without adjusting any of the amounts claimed by the respondent from the petitioner. If the respondent believed that the amount claimed from the petitioner are adjustable from the amounts claimed by the petitioner, it will be difficult to infer that the respondent deliberately and intentionally did not pay the suspension allowance so as to violate the order of this court.
10. The Supreme Court in Mrityunjoy Das v. Sayed Hasibur Rahaman (2001) 3 SCC 739 had held that mere disobedience of an order may not be sufficient to amount to a `Civil Contempt‟ within the meaning of section 2(b) of the Act of 1971. The essential requirement is the intentional and deliberate violation of the order of the court. It was also held that if two interpretation are possible and the action of the alleged contemnor pertains to one such interpretation, it will be doubtful to hold that the order has been violated willfully and intentionally. In paragraph 15 of Mrityunjoy Das (supra) the apex court had held as under:
11. This is no more disputable that exercise of power within the meaning of the Act of 1971 is comparatively a rarity and should be used sparingly and in the larger interest of society and for proper administration of justice.
12. The petitioner has alleged that he met the respondent in number of times at the office at Jor Bagh. The allegation is denied by the respondent. It is asserted that the respondent does not operate from the office at Jor Bagh and in the circumstances it can be inferred that the plea of the petitioner that he met the respondent is not correct. The plea of the petitioner is also vague because the petitioner did not disclose the dates on which he met the respondent. In any case in the entirety of the facts and circumstances it is difficult to infer that there has been deliberated and intentional violation of the order dated 5th December, 2007 so as to entail the consequences of committing contempt of this court.
13. The Supreme Court of India in the case Perspective Publications (Pvt.) Ltd. v. State of Maharashtra (AIR 1971 SC 221) has observed at page 230, inter alia thus: “The summary jurisdiction by way of contempt must be exercised with great care and caution and only when its exercise is necessary for the proper administration of law and justice.” (Per Grover, J.) Contempt of Court is essentially a matter which concerns the administration of justice and the dignity and authority of judicial Tribunals. It is not a right of a party to be invoked for the redress of his grievances. It is not also a mode by which the rights of a party, adjudicated upon by a Tribunal can be enforced against another party. Moreover, if the matter, as in the present case, requires a detailed inquiry, it must be left to the Court which passed the order and which presumably is fully acquainted with the subject-matter of its own order. When the matter relates to mere infringement of an order, as between parties, it is clearly inexpedient to invoke and exercise contempt jurisdiction as a mode of executing the order, merely because other remedies may take time or are more circumlocutory in character. Contempt jurisdiction should be reserved for what essentially brings the administration of justice into contempt or unduly weakens it (vide (1964) 68 Cal WN 148, AIR 1951 Pat 231, AIR 1966 Mad 21 and AIR 1971 ALL 231).
14. Having carefully considered the allegations made in the contempt petition. I am of the opinion that the action of the respondent does not fall within the ambit of Contempt of Courts Act. No undertaking was given to or accepted by the Court. The suspension allowance was not given under the belief that the amount recoverable from the petitioner is more than the amount payable. Whether the suspension allowance was payable on the basic salary or on the total emoluments also negated the element of willingness in not complying with the order. In any case suspension allowance as computed by the respondent has been paid to the petitioner without prejudice to the pleas and contentions of the parties. In the circumstances it cannot be held that the respondent has committed contempt of this court.
15. In the circumstances there are no grounds to take action against the respondent for a committing Contempt of this court. The petition is therefore, dismissed. May 26th, 2008.
ANIL KUMAR J. ‘K’