PURI AND CO. v. INDIAN INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY

Delhi High Court · 23 Jul 2008 · 2008:DHC:2110
S. Ravindra Bhat
CS(OS) 2652A/1987
2008:DHC:2110
civil appeal_dismissed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court upheld an arbitration award dismissing the plaintiff's claims, affirming limited judicial interference with reasoned arbitral findings based on evidence.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
CS(OS) 2652A/1987
Reserved on: July 10,2008 Pronounced on July 23, 2008
PURI AND CO. ......Plaintiff.
Through Mr. V.K. Mishra, Advocate.
Vs.
INDIAN INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY ......Defendant.
Through Mr. Suresh Sinha, advocate with Mr. L.P. Sinha, Advocate.
CORAM:
Hon'ble Mr. Justice S. Ravindra Bhat
JUDGMENT

1. Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes

2. To be referred to the Reporter or not? Yes

3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? Yes Hon'ble Mr. Justice S. Ravindra Bhat:

1. In this suit, the claimaint/objector (hereafter referred to as the plaintiff) challenges the award dated 20.7.1987 of a sole arbitrator appointed by the parties, to adjudicate their inter se disputes.

2. The plaintiff was awarded the work of construction of a building for the Association of Indian Universities, at 16 Kotla Road, CS(OS) 2652A/1987 page No.1 of 12 2008:DHC:2110 New Delhi which included the building portion, Water supply, Sanitary installation and Drainage. The works were awarded by the defendant/Indian Institute of Technology (hereafter called “IIT”). Clause 25 of the agreement enjoined the parties to refer inter se disputes to arbitration. The plaintiff raised certain demands which were referred to the arbitration of Prof. N.M. Swani, a Director of the IIT. He entered upon reference on 11.11.1986. After considering materials on record and the rival pleadings, the arbitrator published his award on 20.7.1987. As against 20 claims of the plaintiff, the arbitrator awarded six claims and partially allowed one claim. He directed payment of 12% per annum simple interest to the claimant. The IIT, respondent in the arbitration proceedings had counter claimed on six heads which were rejected.

3. In these proceedings, during the course of hearing arguments were addressed on the findings of the arbitrator in respect of claim No.1, claim No.2 and claim Nos. 15 & 16.

4. The plaintiff had claimed refund of Rs.85,000/- on account of 2% rebate withheld by the IIT. The background to this head of claim is that the plaintiff while tendering for the works, on 9.7.1982 offered this rebate if the contract were awarded within 30 days. It is CS(OS) 2652A/1987 page No.2 of 12 common ground that by letters dated 22.7.1982 and 7.8.1982 this offer of rebate was extended if the agreement were to be finalized by 31.8.1982. The plaintiff claims to have received confirmation of acceptance of its tender after 10.9.1982. It, therefore, argued before the arbitrator that deduction of 2% on account of rebate was inadmissible since the contract was awarded beyond the stipulated time granted to the IIT in that regard. In defence, the IIT had contended about having accepted the offer and awardrd the contract to the plaintiff, through its letter dated 30.8.1982. The said document was produced as Ex. C-1 with the counter statement of facts in arbitration proceedings. The arbitrator rejected the plaintiff's submission and held that acceptance of the tender was conveyed before relevant date i.e. 31.8.1982 and thus the IIT was justified in regard to the 2% rebate

5. It was contended by Mr. V.K. Mishra, learned counsel that the findings in the award with regard to the 2% rebate are factually untenable and legally unsound. He urged that the IIT had never dispatched any such letter, dated 30.8.1982 and that it saw the light of the day for the first time in arbitral proceedings. It was contended that in terms of the contract all previous correspondence CS(OS) 2652A/1987 page No.3 of 12 were deemed part of the agreement. The previous letters, it was contended by counsel, on the subject were a part of the agreement and exchanged by the parties. Yet the letter of 30.8.1982 found no mention and was never a part of the contract or the correspondence. In these circumstances and in the absence of any corroborative evidence that the contract was awarded on 30.8.1982 the IIT could not have legitimately claimed the rebate.

6. Counsel for the IIT, on the other hand, contended that the findings of the arbitrator are pure questions of facts based on inferences drawn from the materials available on record. It was argued that the plaintiff did not deny receiving the other letters which extended the time up to 30.8.1982; it did not also deny receiving the letter dated 10.9.1982. Counsel relied on that document and submitted that it contained a clear reference to the previous letter awarding the contract, on 30.8.1982 with details of such letter. Counsel further urged that the plaintiff never protested or commented about absence of such letter or correspondence in time or immediately after 10.9.1982 and sought to claim refund of the rebate for the first time in arbitral proceedings. This, it was urged, was clearly inadmissible. CS(OS) 2652A/1987 page No.4 of 12

7. The court has considered the award on claim No.1. The Arbitrator considered the letter dated 30.8.1982 which was Ex. 1 of the counter claim of IIT. He also noticed that IIT's letter of acceptance dated 10.9.1982 was a part of the contract at page 125 and that it clearly adverted to the previous letter of 30.8.1982 through which acceptance of the tender was conveyed. He, therefore, concluded that the plaintiff was informed about the acceptance of the offer before the stipulated date 31.8.1982. The findings of the arbitrator on this claim in the opinion of the court cannot be termed as conjectural or based on no evidence. Also the discussion in the award shows that the arbitrator deliberated on the rival contentions and drew his independent inference. It may be possible for a court, while exercising its original jurisdiction to arrive at a contrary view, in such cases. Yet that is not the standard to be applied while judging whether the award has to be set aside for legal misconduct. The view taken by the arbitrator is certainly a plausible one. In these circumstances, the objections to the findings on claim No.1 are held to be without foundation and are therefore rejected.

8. The second challenge to the award centers round findings on CS(OS) 2652A/1987 page No.5 of 12 claim No.2. The plaintiff had claimed Rs.42,500/- as refund of 1% rebate deducted from monthly running payments. The Arbitrator allowed a portion of this claim except holding that the respondent/IIT was entitled to retain the deduction to the extent of Rs.9731.75. It is contended that the deduction of Rs.9731.75 permitted is in error of law as the IIT could not have adjusted this amount against the security deposit. It is urged that this deduction was an afterthought since a guarantee bond remained in force till September, 1985 to indemnify the IIT. Reliance is placed on documents such as Ex. C-68 and C-75.

9. While tendering for the work, the claimant had offered a 1% rebate if monthly running bills were paid within one week of their submission for the work done. This was accepted by the IIT in its letter dated 10.9.1982. A careful reading of the award would show that besides noticing a plaintiff's contention, the arbitrator also independently examined other relevant documents such as Ex. 4 running bills and Ex. C-15 and C-75. Factually the findings can hardly be characterized as errors of law or betraying an approach or findings of fact unsupported by evidence amounting to legal misconduct. Therefore, the objections on claim No.2 are also held to be CS(OS) 2652A/1987 page No.6 of 12 without basis.

10. The claimants have claimed Rs.62,000/- for non-issue of cement to their work force on Respondent’s off-days and also for late issue of the cement at 9.00 a.m. instead of 8.00 a.m. on working days. The plaintiff referred to Ex. C-27, C-28 and C-105 of P-1 in support of its claim. They claimed that by late issue of cement i.e. at

9.00 a.m. instead of 8.00 a.m., 12.5% of their labour output was wasted. Non-issue of ement on Institute off-days (Ex. C-27 of P-1) in addition to the weekly off-days was contrary to provision 2c(i) page 42 of contract Agreement (R-1). The plaintiff alleged that total wages paid to the workers and the masons dealing with the cement work was Rs.4,53,893.50, of which 12.5% was wasted, which the plaintiff demanded for late issue and the balance for off-days. The plaintiff gave reports for masons and labour employed on work involving use of cement. The IIT argued that the plaintiff had been making lump sum claims giving details neither in the letter asking for arbitration nor in the statement of claims. The plaintiff, it is claimed had not given details of their workforce which remained idle on off-days on account of non-issue of of cement. The IIT averred it had been issuing cement to the plaintiff continuously whenever it CS(OS) 2652A/1987 page No.7 of 12 sought for it, as was evident from the Registrar of cement, which showed issue of cement on Saturdays and even on some Sundays and other holidays. Cement could not be issued when the work was not in progress and the plaintiff did not want it. The Register of Cement was relied to show long gaps in the progress of work and that the plaintiff did not work on such days. The IIT therefore, inferred that plaintiff was not interested in doing the work regularly and had not mustered sufficient workforce.

11. The arbitrator had rejected this claim after considering the entries in the register of cement dated 7.3.1983, 9.3.1983, 10.3.1983, 20.3.1983, 26.3.1983 and 27.3.1983. He also considered the testimony of Shri. J.P. Jain, Junior Engineer IIT. The questions put to the witness and the answers given by him were produced verbatim in the award. This court has considered the arbitrator’s findings in this regard. They can hardly be characterized as errors in law or findings of facts unsupported by evidence. The arbitrator noted that no written complaints had been contemporaneously made, when the contract itself was being worked out in 1982-83 and 1983-84. It was also noticed that the plaintiff did not keep any particulars about its workers (who CS(OS) 2652A/1987 page No.8 of 12 remained idle due to lapses of the IIT in not issuing cement) or mention at the relevant time, or disclose other relevant particulars in that regard. In these circumstances the findings of the arbitrator, attacked as contrary to law are unfounded; certainly also not on the basis of any lack of consideration of evidence. After all, the informality attached to arbitration proceedings does not imply that every claim of a litigant, bereft of supporting proof is to be regarded as legitimate. There may certainly be some relaxation in the mode and manner of proving facts; yet the underlying obligation to adduce evidence continues to rest on those who make claims, based on factual assertions. The plaintiff failed to prove its facts here; its objection, to the findings on the claim, have to, therefore, fail.

14,229 characters total

12. Claim No. 16 is for the sum of Rs. 52,000 towards additional charges on scaffolding for the work of aggregate plastering on the surface of the building. The arbitrator had denied this claim. The plaintiff had been awarded two contracts for separate parts of the building. It is contended that the work of plastering could not be taken up since IIT delayed its decision on construction of “chajjas” and projections. The claim on this head was Rs. 4000/- per month CS(OS) 2652A/1987 page No.9 of 12 for 13 months. The IIT had denied this lump-sum claim as not tenable. The arbitrator observed that the contract in question involved construction up-to the roof slab of the third floor; the fourth and fifth floors were covered by another contract. The arbitrator reasoned that if the contracts for the other floors had been awarded to another agency, these questions could possibly have been legitimately raised. However, since the plaintiff was awarded the contracts for both parts of the building, (the arbitrator reasoned) as use cost of the materials was un-spelt, in the later contract, it could be reasonable to conclude that the plaintiffs used the materials and equipment available with it for one contract, in the execution of another. This reasoning, in the opinion of this court, is unexceptionable. Besides, the plaintiff did not show how it could claim Rs. 4,000/- per month, for 13 months.

13. A court’s power to interfere with an arbitration award, under Section 30 and 33 of the old Act is well established. From Union of India –vs- A.L. Ralia Ram AIR 1963 SC 1685 down to Food Corporation of India –vs- Chandu Construction 2007 (4) SCC 697, it has been ruled that to constitute misconduct implies something unreasonable which would fall outside the jurisdiction of the CS(OS) 2652A/1987 page No.10 of 12 arbitrator. The standard to be applied for judging the legality of an award is irrationality, caprice, arbitrariness or the adjudicatorarbitrator acting beyond the terms of the agreement. (Ref. Bhagwati Oxygen Ltd. –vs- Hindustan Copper Ltd. 2005(6) SCC 462; Rajasthan State Mines and Minerals Ltd. v. Eastern Engineering Enterprises and Another, (1999) 9 SCC 283). It has been further held (U.P. State Electricity Board v. Searsole Chemcials Ltd. (2001) 3 SCC 397), that where the arbitrator applies his mind to the pleadings, considers the evidence adduced before him and passes an award, the Court cannot interfere by reappraising the matter as if it were an appeal.

14. Another test indicated by the Supreme Court, in - Chandu Construction(supra) and Bharat Coking Coal Ltd. v. M/s. Annapurna Construction, (2003) 8 SCC 154,) is that where the arbitrator travels beyond the contract he acts in excess of jurisdiction in which case, the award passed by him becomes vulnerable and can be questioned in an appropriate Court. In this case, the arbitrator, agreed to be appointed by the parties, was a technical man, whose experience and judgment was relied on by both parties, and has not been impeached in these proceedings. He has rendered an award, which contains reasoning on each contention raised, concerning every CS(OS) 2652A/1987 page No.11 of 12 claim; the award is a 100 page document. Neither his approach, or appreciation of pleadings or evidence betrays any flaw which would vitiate the findings, in the award.

15. In view of the above reasons, the court is of the opinion that plaintiff’s objections to the award have to fail. They are accordingly dismissed. Subject to these findings, the award has to be made a rule of court; the suit is decreed in its terms. No costs. July 23, 2008 (S. RAVINDRA BHAT) JUDGE CS(OS) 2652A/1987 page No.12 of 12