Anil Kumar Gupta & Others v. Chief Fire Officer & Ors.

Delhi High Court · 23 Jul 2008 · 2008:DHC:2117-DB
The Chief Justice; Dr. Justice S. Muralidhar
CM Nos.9452/2008, 10022/2008 in WP(C) 5638-45/2008
2008:DHC:2117-DB
civil appeal_dismissed

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court upheld the Local Commissioner's directions for supervising the construction of an underground water tank, dismissing the petitioner's objections and ordering compliance with court-mandated conditions.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
CM Nos.9452/2008, 10022/2008 in WP(C) 5638-45/2008
ANIL KUMAR GUPTA & OTHERS ..... Petitioners
Through Mr.D.K. Rustagi with Mr.Achin Aren, Advocates.
VERSUS
CHIEF FIRE OFFICER & ORS. ..... Respondents
Through Ms.Zubeda Begum, Advocate for R-1 to 3
Mr.Sandeep Aggarwal with Mr.A.
Singh, for DJB/R-5 Mr.B.B. Gupta, Adv. for R-6
CORAM:
HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE S.MURALIDHAR
JUDGMENT

1. Whether reporters of the local papers be allowed to see the judgment ?

2. To be referred to the Reporter or not ?

3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest ? % O R D E R 23.07.2008

1. We have heard the counsel appearing for the petitioner as well as counsel appearing for respondents No.1,[5] and 6. This writ petition was disposed of vide order dated 29th March, 2007. However, subsequently CM No.5518/2007 was filed by the respondent No.6 seeking correction of typographical error in the said order and also for modification of condition No.3 stipulated therein. The Structural Engineer nominated by this Court for supervising the construction of the [WP(C) 5638/2005] 2008:DHC:2117-DB underground water tank also filed an application being CM No.5519/2007 seeking a direction to the Registry to furnish to him certified copies of the plans and reports submitted by Shri R.S. Jindal, Architect to enable him to commence the construction of the tank. By order dated 27th April, 2007, the order of 29th March, 2007 was modified whereby clause 3 of the said order was substituted by following clause: “The construction will be completed within one month from the date the same commences. R- 6 shall furnish to the Registry of this Court a Bank Guarantee for a sum of Rs.7.[5] lakhs which shall be encashable at the instance of the petitioner in case any damage is caused to any portion of the property in the occupation of the petitioner or any other occupant other than R-6. The amount so available upon encashment shall be used for repair of the damage, if any caused.”

2. Thereafter certain further orders were passed for ensuring compliance regarding furnishing of the bank guarantee by the respondent No.6. In the meantime, Shri N.K. Jain, who was appointed as Supervisor passed away. The respondent No.6, therefore, filed an application being CM No.12438/2008 and suggested the names of four other Structural Engineers for nomination to undertake the supervision work assigned earlier to Shri N.K. Jain. The Division Bench by order dated 7th April, 2008 has appointed Shri G.P. Thareja, District and Sessions Judge (Retired) as a Local Commissioner to supervise through a Structural Engineer the proposed construction. The power of nominating a suitable Structural Engineer is also delegated to him. It is also directed that the construction of the underground water tank by the respondent No.6 shall be subject to the terms and conditions already stipulated by the orders passed by this Court in these proceedings. The fee of Shri Thareja if fixed at Rs.50,000/- to be paid equally by the two parties. The fee of the Structural Engineer to be nominated by Shri Thareja, after hearing both the sides, is to be fixed by Shri Thareja and to be paid by the respondent No.6. The parties are given liberty to make their proposals and suggestions in regard to the construction of the tank as also the other modalities before Shri Thareja, if so advised.

3. Shri Thareja has submitted report dated 5th July, 2008, whereby he is seeking the following directions from the Court: “(a) Sri S.N. Sinha Professor and Acting Head Department of Civil Engineering may be appointed as Engineer in-charge to supervise the construction of underground water tank as per the designs approved by him along with Sri Masood as suggested by Professor Sinha or any other engineer of his choice. (b) The petitioner may be directed to deliver vacant possession of shops for three months within fifteen days of intimation to them. Professor Sinha suggests that the construction would be complete by two months but on safe side more time of one month would be appropriate, considering the congested area of Chandni Chowk where work may be done after working hours.

(c) Necessary directions be also given to the local police to assist and not to obstruct the construction of the water tank if necessary at odd hours.

(d) The petitioners may be directed to deposit the fee of the local commissioner as already directed since their cheque given to the local commissioner has been returned with remarks no sufficient funds. (e) Considering the time already devoted including the number of visits at site already done and further to be made and further time is to be devoted considering the fear of the petitioners appropriate further fee may be fixed.”

4. It is required to be stated that respondent No.6 has now filed an application being CM No.9452/2008 requesting the Court to pass appropriate directions as desired by the Local Commissioner in his report dated 5th July, 2008. The petitioner has, however, filed CM No.10022/2008 raising certain apprehensions about the implementation of report of Shri Jindal and is seeking a direction to the Local Commissioner to consider CM Nos.10970/2006 and 1868/2007 before deciding on the implementation of the said report.

5. We do not find any substance in the apprehensions raised by the petitioner. The reliefs claimed by the petitioner in his CM cannot be granted. The Local Commissioner has submitted a detailed report. We are of the view that the directions sought by the Local Commissioner are liable to be granted. It is ordered accordingly.

6. Counsel appearing for the petitioner states that the petitioner has paid the fee of the Local Commissioner.

7. The applications CMs No.9452/2008, 10022/2008 stand disposed of.

CHIEF JUSTICE S.MURALIDHAR JULY 23, 2008 (JUDGE) “nm”