M/S YASH BUILD WELL (P) LTD v. M/S VIRAJ ALLOYS LTD

Delhi High Court · 24 Jul 2008 · 2008:DHC:2127
Rajiv Sahai Endlaw
CS(OS)2060/2007
2008:DHC:2127
civil appeal_allowed

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court decreed recovery of Rs 26,66,559/- with 6% interest against the defendant company alone, dismissing claims against the individual director for lack of cause of action.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
CS(OS)2060/2007
Date of Decision: 24.07.2008
M/S YASH BUILD WELL (P) LTD ….… Plaintiff
Through: Ms Rajshree, Advocate.
VERSUS
M/S VIRAJ ALLOYS LTD & ANR ........ Defendants
Ex-parte.
CORAM :-
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW
JUDGMENT

1. Whether reporters of Local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?

2. To be referred to the reporter or not?

3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest?

RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW, J

1. The plaintiff has instituted the present suit for the recovery of Rs 26,66,559/- with pendente lite and future interest. Though the suit is instituted against M/s Viraj Alloys Ltd and Shri Niraj Kochar but in the prayer paragraph in the plaint decree is claimed against “defendant company” only. The claim in suit is for the balance amount due for the construction work carried out by the plaintiff on the Farm House at Vasant Kunj at the instance of the 2008:DHC:2127

2. Both the defendants were proceeded ex parte vide order dated 11th March, 2008 and remain absent. The plaintiff has led its ex parte evidence vide affidavit of its director Shri K.P. Singh who has also instituted the suit and signed and verified the plaint on behalf of the plaintiff. He has proved Resolution of Board of Directors of plaintiff in his favour as Ex PW1/1. He has further deposed that the plaintiff had agreed to work for the farmhouse of the defendant; that the work has been executed by the plaintiff as per requirement and under the strict supervision through a consultant appointed by the defendant and the other agents of the defendant; that the plaintiff has been submitting running account bills (which have been proved as Ex PW1/2 to Ex PW1/7) through architect/consultant appointed by the defendant and the bills have been paid by the defendants to the plaintiff from time to time; that the bills submitted by the plaintiff to the defendant also show the work executed by the plaintiff; that the plaintiff had submitted the 7th running account bill dated 25th April, 2007 for the gross value of work done for Rs 1,07,01,924/- (Ex PW1/8) out of which net value of work done worked out to Rs 18,53,742/- after deduction; that the plaintiff has been reminding the defendant for release of the balance payment but the defendant has failed to do so and the consultant earlier appointed by the defendant has also left the defendant; that the plaintiff submitted the final bill on 3rd August, 2007 for Rs 26,66,559/- (Ex.PW1/9) which included the quantities executed and rates claimed upto the 7th running account bill; that the defendant has, thereafter, carried out addition/alterations to the property for now; that a principal sum of Rs26,66,559/- is due from the defendant to the plaintiff; that the plaintiff is also entitled to interest at 18% per annum. The said evidence of the plaintiff remains unrebutted.

3. The entire plaint does not describe the defendant No.2 and does not disclose a cause of action against the defendant No.2. The territorial jurisdiction is also invoked with reference to defendant company. The documents filed by the plaintiff also show that the bills were being raised by the plaintiff on the defendant No.1 (M/s Viraj Alloys Ltd) and not on the defendant No.2 (Shri Niraj Kochar). In the affidavit by way of evidence also no evidence of claim or right of claim against defendant No.2 is led. The plaintiff has not been able to make out any case against the defendant No.2. The defendant No.1 is a limited company and is entitled to be sued in its own name and even if the defendant No.2 is the director or officer of the defendant No.1, in the absence of any averments of the plaintiff in this respect, the defendant No.2 would not become liable for the debts, if any, of the defendant No.1. As aforesaid, the prayer is also against defendant company only.

4. From the ex parte evidence, the claim of the plaintiff in so far as against defendant No.1 is within limitation. The plaintiff is, accordingly, found entitled to a decree for the principal sum of Rs 26,66,559/-, however, against the defendant No.1 only. As far as the claim of the plaintiff for interest is concerned, the plaintiff has not contested the suit and in the circumstances plaintiff is entitled to interest at 6% per annum only on the principal sum of Rs 26,66,559/-, from the date of institution of the suit till realization with costs limited to the court fees paid by the plaintiff. The decree sheet be drawn up accordingly.

RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW, J. July 24, 2008. M