M/S. ATWAL & ASSOCIATES v. M/S. VECTRA INVESTMENTS PVT LTD

Delhi High Court · 25 Jul 2008 · 2008:DHC:2144-DB
THE CHIEF JUSTICE; DR. JUSTICE S. MURALIDHAR
FAO(OS) No. 327/2007
2008:DHC:2144-DB
civil appeal_dismissed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court dismissed the defendants' appeal, holding that disputes beyond the scope of an arbitration clause cannot be referred to arbitration and upheld the ex parte decree for recovery of dues.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
FAO(OS)No.327/2007 M/S. ATWAL & ASSOCIATES ..... Appellant
Through Ms.Radhika Chandrasekhar, Adv.
VERSUS
M/S. VECTRA INVESTMENTS PVT LTD ..... Respondent
Through Mr.Amit Bansal, Adv.
CORAM:
HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE S.MURALIDHAR
JUDGMENT

1. Whether reporters of the local papers be allowed to see the judgment ?

2. To be referred to the Reporter or not ?

3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest ? % JUDGMENT 25.07.2008

1. This appeal is filed by the defendants against the order dated 10th May, 2007 passed by the learned single Judge in CS(OS) No.626/2005 and IA No.5744/2006 and IA No.207/2007.

2. The order passed in IA No.207/2007 is not subject matter of the appeal.

3. IA No.5744/2006 has been filed by the defendants under Section 8 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. The learned single Judge has noted that the arbitration clause under [LPA 327/2008] 2008:DHC:2144-DB the hire-purchase agreement dated 4th July, 2000 was restricted to disputes arising out of this agreement between the parties and would, therefore, not govern the disputes which are outside the purview of the same. It has been further noted that the plaintiff has made a claim in the present suit for an amount of Rs.34,69,593/- towards an amount given as loan; an amount of Rs.76,13,726/- on account of sale of dumpers; and a running lease account of Rs.16,05,272/-. It has been noted that these three claims do not arise out of the agreement dated 4th July,

2000. The Apex Court in Sukanya Holdings (P) Ltd. v. Jayesh

H. Pandya and another {(2003) 5 SCC 531} has pointed out that there is no provision in the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 when the subject-matter of the suit includes subject-matter of the arbitration agreement as well as other disputes, requiring the matter to be referred to arbitration. There is also no provision for splitting the causes or parties and referring the subject-matter of the suit to the arbitrators. That apart, it is further seen that the agreement dated 4th July, 2000 stood exhausted inasmuch as by letter dated 25th May, 2001, the defendants offered to purchase the vehicles of the plaintiff which were the subject-matter of the agreement. This offer was accepted by the plaintiff and consequently, the amount which was due and payable by the defendants came to be secured by way of demand promissory notes and the deed of guarantee. Thus it is clear that the suit claim is beyond the arbitration clause contained in the agreement dated 4th July, 2000.

4. The suit being CS(OS) No.626/2005 has been instituted by the plaintiff under Order XXXVII of the Code of Civil Procedure seeking a decree for recovery of Rs.1,26,88,591/- against the defendants with pendente lite and future interest. As the defendants successfully avoided service of the summons, the plaintiff moved an application seeking service by the substituted modes of publication of the citation in the daily newspaper and affixation of the summons at their last known address and on the notice board of this Court, which was directed by this Court by order dated 29th October, 2005. The defendants were duly served and they put in their appearance on 19th April, 2006. The application filed by the defendants under Order XXXVII Rule 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure for condonation of delay in filing the memorandum of appearance was allowed by the order dated 9th January, 2007. The plaintiff thereupon served the summons for judgment on the defendants on 3rd April, 2007. However, the defendants failed to take any steps in accordance with law within the statutory period of limitation. In these circumstances the matter was proceeded ex parte and decree came to be passed for a sum of Rs.1,26,88,591/- with interest @ 10% per annum with effect from the date of filing of the suit i.e. 4th April, 2005.

5. The suit claim was on account of three separate transactions. The first was a hire-purchase agreement dated 4th July, 2000 whereunder the defendants took on hire-purchase basis two dumpers for a period of 12 months. The defendant No.2 had given his personal guarantee in respect of the two vehicles and the defendants had agreed to pay a sum of Rs.45,000/- per month for each dumper as hire charges and the defendants had the rights to purchase the vehicle during the period of one year. By a letter dated 25th May, 2001, the defendants offered to purchase the two vehicles of the plaintiff at a price of Rs.24,62,500/- each. In the event of default, the defendants were liable to pay interest @ 24% per annum. That offer of the defendants was accepted by the plaintiff by letter dated 30th May, 2001. The two vehicles were duly handed over by the plaintiff to the defendants on hire-purchase agreement. The defendants failed to adhere to repayment schedule and defaulted in the payment. The second transaction is of the year

2001. The defendants approached the plaintiff for short term loans. The plaintiff provided three loans to the defendants. The defendants executed three demand promissory notes and defendant No.2 also executed his personal guarantee to secure the loans. The defendants had agreed to pay interest @ 18% per annum on the loan amount. The defendants also issued post dated cheques to secure the loan. There is no dispute that the defendants defaulted in making payment. The third transaction is of lease of certain vehicles by the plaintiff company to the defendants and for these leases the defendants were liable to pay rental on the basis of rate per trip multiplied by the number of trips. It is brought on record that the defendants confirmed the balance dues in the three accounts as on 31st March, 2002 and signed their accounts. Again, the balance was confirmed by the defendants as on 31st March, 2003 and also as on 31st March,

2005. The evidence of the plaintiff has gone unrebutted and uncontroverted and the plaintiff has been able to prove that it is entitled to such claim.

6. Counsel appearing for the appellants/defendants is unable to show any cogent reason for not filing the reply and seeking leave to defend.

7. In our opinion, there is absolutely no substance in the appeal. The appeal is dismissed.

CHIEF JUSTICE S.MURALIDHAR JULY 25, 2008 (JUDGE) “nm”