Shri Satish Kumar v. UOI & Ors.

Delhi High Court · 28 Jul 2008 · 2008:DHC:2156
Reva Khetrapal
CS(OS) 1829A/1999
2008:DHC:2156
civil appeal_dismissed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court upheld an arbitration award in favor of the contractor, dismissing the Union of India's objections for non-arbitrability and misconduct under the Arbitration Act, 1940.

Full Text
Translation output
REPORTED
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
CS(OS) 1829A/1999
DATE OF RESERVE: May 06, 2008
Date of Decision: July 28, 2008 SHRI SATISH KUMAR ..... Plaintiff
Through: Mr. Vivekanand, Advocate.
VERSUS
UOI & ORS. ..... Defendants
Through: Mr.R.C.Nangia, Advocate
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE REVA KHETRAPAL
JUDGMENT

1. Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?

2. To be referred to the Reporter or not?

3. Whether judgment should be reported in Digest? JUDGMENT: REVA KHETRAPAL, J.

1. The petitioner was awarded a contract for “Repairs to Passenger Platform Service with Bitumastic Flooring on Platform No.2 at Saharanpur” vide work order No.128-W/280/DEN-I/UMB dated 27.02.1992 by the respondent/Union of 2008:DHC:2156 Manager, Northern Railway, New Delhi appointed Shri Jagdeep Rai, Dy. Chief Engineer/Const./Works, Northern Railway and Shri A.K.Lal, Dy. F.A. & CAO/Const., Northern Railway, Delhi as Co-Arbitrators to adjudicate upon the disputes. The said Co-Arbitrators, as per terms of reference, jointly requested Shri Raj Kumar Sarkar, Dy. Chief Engineer/Deposit Work, Northern Railway, Patel Nagar, New Delhi to act as Umpire vide letter No.94/Arb./JR-11 dated 29.6.95 which he agreed to act on 3.7.1995. The Co-Arbitrators entered into the reference on 23.11.1995, but did not hold any hearing during the period of validity, that is, four months from the date of entering into the reference. Accordingly, the petitioner invoked the arbitration clause and requested Shri Raj Kumar Sarkar to enter into the reference and to act as Umpire vide his letter dated 28.03.1998. Shri Raj Kumar Sarkar entered into the reference on 5.4.1999 and after having heard the parties and gone through the material on record, gave his award on 23.7.1999, thereby allowing the claims of the petitioner to the extent of Rs.60,395/- (Rupees Sixty Thousand Three Hundred Ninety Five only) with simple interest @ 12% p.a. on Rs.51,690/- (that is, Rs.60,395/- minus Rs.8705/- = Rs.51690/-) from 1.10.92 till the date of payment. The learned Umpire further held that if the awarded amount was not paid within a period of 75 days from the date of publishing of the award, the respondent would be liable to pay interest @ 18% to the contractor till the payment of the award amount. The learned Umpire,

2. The respondent/Union of India has filed the present objections to the award under Sections 30 and 33 of the Arbitration Act, 1940 on the ground that the learned Umpire mis-conducted the proceedings, inasmuch as he could not have awarded the said amount in accordance with the specific clauses of the agreement and also as per the evidence available with him. The award of the learned Arbitrator is, therefore, stated to be against the facts on record and bad in law. The award is also stated to be based on conjectures and surmises. Finally, it is submitted that by interpreting the clauses of the agreement in a manner different from the original agreement, the learned Umpire has exceeded the terms of reference. Thus, according to the Union of India, claims No.1,2,[4] & 5 were wrongly allowed by the arbitrator, while the counter-claim of the Railways was wrongly dis-allowed and accordingly the award of the learned arbitrator was liable to be set aside under the provisions of Sections 30 and 33 of the Arbitration Act, 1940.

3. The petitioner/contractor has filed a detailed reply to the objections denying the objections in seriatum and praying for the dismissal of the objections with costs and for making the award the rule of the court with further interest @ 18% p.a. from the date of decree till the date of the payment.

4. It is proposed to deal with the objections of the respondent/UOI claim-wise and the same are accordingly dealt with as follows:- Claim No.1:

5. The first Objection is with regard to the claim No.1, whereby the learned arbitrator against the amount claimed of Rs.80,000/-, awarded a sum of Rs.10,000/- in respect of the work done. It is stated by the Objector that in accordance with Clause-45 of the General Conditions of Contract, which was part of the agreement between the parties, the measurement of work recorded between the parties was final and binding. Any claim in regard to measurement or any claim for work which was not according to the measurement, being an 'excepted matter', could not be awarded by the arbitrator. By awarding claim No.1, the learned arbitrator has given an award contrary to the agreement between the parties. It is also contended that the reasoning given by the learned arbitrator is vague and baseless.

6. In reply it is denied that the dispute with regard to claim No.1 was an 'excepted matter'. It is submitted that the respondent took no plea of 'excepted matter' either before the Court at the time of making of the order of reference by the Court or before the learned Arbitrator. As per the recorded measurement, the claimant was entitled to Rs.42,681.72 for work done after deducting the running payment, the details whereof were filed before the arbitrator. Without issuance of later on, behind the back of the claimant, struck off by the respondent on the allegation of alleged defects. There were letters and material on record to show that the claimant had rectified the defects. It was also an admitted case of the respondent that the work as done by the claimant had been put to use and was being utilized by the respondent without dismantling the same or without further rectification, either departmentally or otherwise. Thus, the learned arbitrator, keeping in view all the facts and circumstances, awarded a sum of Rs.10,000/- to the claimant, though a much larger amount was claimed.

7. A perusal of the counter statement of facts on behalf of the respondent/UOI filed before the learned arbitrator shows that it was nowhere pleaded by the respondent that claim No.1 was in the category of 'excepted matters'. The plea of the learned counsel for the respondent that Claim No.1 fell in the category of 'excepted matters' cannot, therefore, be entertained at this stage. Such a plea is also not sustainable in view of the judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme court in J.G.Engineers (P) Ltd. Vs. Calcutta Improvement Trust AIR 2002 S.C 766 and Narain Prasad Lohia Vs. Nikunj Kumar Lohia 2002(1) Arbitration Law Reporter (RLR) 493 (Supreme Court), wherein applying the principal of waiver, it was held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court that the respondent not having taken the objection with regard to the non-arbitrability of the claim before the arbitrator or any objection that the said claims were 'excepted matters' and having contested the claims on merits, is estopped from raising such an objection after having suffered the award.

8. The learned arbitrator's finding that during discussion the respondent agreed that defects of some portions were removed by the claimant and, therefore, the claim was being partly allowed to the extent of Rs.10,000/- as against the claim of Rs.80,000/-, cannot, therefore, be faulted, more so, as the learned arbitrator has reasoned that though the respondent had entered the measurement of the whole work done by the claimant in the measurement book, later some of the measurements had been scored out on account of defects noticed. There is also nothing on record to suggest that this scoring out in the measurement book was done after issuance of notice to the claimant, in his presence. The amount has been awarded on the basis of the measurement book and it is not the case of the respondent that no measurement was recorded. The record also shows that by letter dated 28.9.1992, the claimant had written to the respondent that the defects had been rectified and that there was no rebuttal of this fact from the side of the respondent. Claim No.2:

8. Claim No.2 is towards idling of labour, staff, tools, plants and equipment and additional expenses due to faults and failures of the respondent. Against the a sum of Rs.41,690/- only (Rupees Forty One Thousand Six Hundred Ninety only) has been awarded by the arbitrator to the claimant with the following break up:- Claim No. Description of claims Amount claimed (Rs.) Amount awarded (Rs.)

2. (i) (ii) (iii) (iv) (v) Idling of labour, staff, tools, plants and equipments and additional expenses due to faults and failures of respondent. Double wages of 10 workmen @ Rs.40 per day for 6 months. Salary of supervisor Hire charges for T &P Salary of watch & ward conveyance, rent, lodging, boarding etc. for six months. Reasons of the amount awarded After hearing the arguments of both claimant and the respondent and going through the records presented, the claim is partly awarded as shown against each item above due to nonremoval of hindrances and nonavailability of site during the day time which resulted in hindrances and labour output at site as also agreed by respondent. 4,15,000/- 72000/- 24000/- 90000/- 24000/- 33000/- 41,690/- 14400/- 4645/- 18000/- 4645/- Nil 41690/-

9. The reasons recorded by the arbitrator for award of this claim are that due to non-removal of hindrances and non-availability of site during the day time which resulted in hindrances and labour output at site, “as also agreed by the appears to be that the site and the electricity were not provided to the contractor within the stipulated period. In this context, apart from the fact that the learned arbitrator has recorded that, the non-removal of hindrances and non-availability of site during the day time was admitted by the respondent, the learned counsel for the claimant has drawn my attention to an intimation sent by the Assistant Engineer, Northern Railway, Saharanpur to the S.H.O/GRP/Police, Saharanpur dated 27.04.1992 which is to the following effect:- “Northern Railway Office of the Assistant Engineer/N.Rly Saharanpur. No.18-A/16/535 Dated 27/4/92 Sub: Repairs to pass, platform surface with bitumastic flooring of P F No.2 at SRE. The above work is being carried out by Shri Satish Kumar, Contractor Saharanpur. Due to power cut in day time, the work is being done during night time. Please allow contractor's labour (about 10 men) to work on the platform No.2 & 3 during night time so that the work may be completed well in time i.e. within target date. sd/- Assistant Engineer Northern Rly., Saharanpur.”

10. The learned counsel for the claimant submits that in view of the fact that the respondent was squarely to blame for the non-availability of the site during the day time resulting in hindrances and increased labour output at the site, the learned arbitrator was justified in granting claim No.2 in respect of idling charges. He also points out that though the aforesaid charges were claimed for a period of six months, the learned arbitrator has awarded the same for a period of one and half month only.

13,253 characters total

11. The learned counsel for the respondent/UOI does not dispute the letter dated 27.04.1992 or the fact that it was agreed to by the respondent before the arbitrator that there was non-availability of site during the day time. This being so, it is not understandable as to how the award of one and half month idling charges on account of non-availability of the site to the claimant can be objected to by the respondent. The contention of the respondent that the award of claim No.2 for idle labour, staff, tools, etc. in the sum of Rs.41,690/- by the learned arbitrator is not only contrary to the pleadings, but also against the record of the proceedings is, therefore, clearly mis-placed. Claim No.4:

12. In the context of claim No.4, the findings of the learned arbitration are as follows: Amount awarded

4. Refund of earnest money/security deposit (Earnest money deposited Rs.2500/-. Security deposit Rs.6383/-. Deduct electric bill for Rs.2678/-. Net amount payable Rs.8705/-). Rs.2500/- Amount awarded Reasons of amount awarded. As per the final bill prepared and entered in measurement book No.D-571/UMB/90 Page-99 by the respondent, security deposit of Rs.6383/has been deducted from the Ist running on account bill and out of E/money of Rs.5000/-, the respondent has adjusted Rs.2400/- as security deposit and an amount of Rs.2678/- is to be deducted for electricity as per electric bill from claimant. Thus, the respondent will pay Rs.8705/- to the claimant (i.e. Rs.6383/- + Rs.5000/- = Rs.11383/- minus Rs.2678/- = Rs.8705/-). This has already been accepted by the respondent during the arguments. Rs.8705/-

13. At the outset, the learned counsel for the claimant explained that though the claim under this head was made for earnest money deposited in the sum of Rs.2,500/-, the learned arbitrator has also dealt with the security deposit under this head. It was elaborated by him that it was not that the security deposit was not claimed before the arbitrator, but that the arbitrator instead of dealing with it in claim No.1, has dealt with it in claim No.4.

14. A somewhat feeble attempt was made by the learned counsel for the respondent to urge that the learned arbitrator was not justified in awarding the aforesaid claim. The learned counsel for the petitioner, on the other hand, has drawn my attention to page 171 of the records, which contains handwritten notes with regard to the payment due to the contractor. The said handwritten records are “NORTHERN RAILWAY Dy. Chief Engineer/Const. N.rly, Tilak Bridge Sh.R.K.Sarkar Payment due to the contractor for “Repair to Passenger Platform service with bitumastic flooring of Platform No.2 at Saharanpur.

(i) Security 10% Rs.6383.00 (against

(ii) Earnest money Rs.5000.00