Full Text
CS(OS) 1634/2006
Date of Decision: 31.07.2008
RUPRAI EXPORTS PVT LTD ……Plaintiff
Through: Mr Dhananjai Rana, advocate
Ex parte.
JUDGMENT
1. Whether reporters of Local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? YES
2. To be referred to the reporter or not? NO
3. Whether the judgment should be reported NO in the Digest?
RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW, J (ORAL)
1. The plaintiff has instituted the present suit for recovery of Rs 58,10,913/- along with pendent lite and future interest at the rate of 15% per annum. The monies are claimed to be due for the garments exported by the plaintiff to the defendant No.1 firm of which defendant Nos 2 and 3 are partners. The defendants were proceeded ex parte vide order dated 14th March, 2007. The plaintiff has, thereafter, led its ex parte evidence by filing the affidavit by way of examination in chief of Shri Lakhvinder Singh Rooprai, Director of the plaintiff and of Shri Subodh Garg, accountant of the 2008:DHC:2205
2. PW[1] Shri Lakhvinder Singh Rooprai has proved the certificate of incorporation of the plaintiff company as PW1/2 and the Resolution of the Board of Directors of the plaintiff company authorizing Shri Lakhvinder Singh Rooprai to institute the suit and sign and verify the plaint and depose before the court as Exhibit PW1/1. The said witness has further deposed that goods were supplied by the plaintiff to the defendant No.1 firm vide invoices dated 20th April, 2002 to 20th February, 2003 of the total value of GBP-80,337.57 equal to Rs.58,10,913/-. The certified copy of the ledger of the plaintiff stated to be maintained in the normal course of business of the plaintiff has been proved as Exhibit PW1/4. The witness has also proved as Ex PW1/6 acknowledgement of liability by the defendants vide letter dated 7th October, 2005 of the defendant No.3 as partner of defendant No.1 and addressed to the plaintiff at Delhi acknowledging liability in the sum of GBP-80,337/-. The invoices vide which supplies were made by the plaintiff to the defendants have been proved as Exhibit PW1/7 and the airway and shipping bill has been proved as Exhibit PW1/8 and forms SDF and certificate of origin issued by the Customs Authorities for the export have been proved as Exhibit PW1/9. PW[2] Shri Subodh Garg has deposed that he is computer literate and had been operating the computer maintaining the accounts of the plaintiff and has fed the entries of bills/invoices on a day-to-day basis. The computer generated accounts statement has been proved as Exhibit PW2/1 which also shows the amount of Rs 58,10,913/- to be due from the defendant No.1 to the plaintiff.
3. Needless to add that the aforesaid evidence of the witnesses of the plaintiff remains unrebutted.
4. Though the defendants are based in / residents of London, jurisdiction of this court has been invoked alleging that the supplies were made by the plaintiff to the defendant from Delhi and the orders were placed at Delhi and all negotiations took place at Delhi. These averments also remain unrebutted. On these averments, this court has territorial jurisdiction over subject matter of suit. Though the invoices vide which supplies have been made are of a date more than three years prior to the institution of the suit but the defendants have within three years prior to the institution of the suit vide letter Exhibit PW1/6 (supra) unequivocally admitted liability in the suit amount by the plaintiff. The claim in suit is thus within time. The plaintiff has proved its case for recovery of Rs 58,10,913/from the defendants jointly and severally. However, since, the defendants have not contested the suit, the plaintiff is held entitled to interest at 6% per annum only from the date of the institution of the suit till realization. The plaintiff in the circumstances is held entitled to costs limited to the court fees paid by the plaintiff. The suit of the plaintiff is accordingly decreed in the aforesaid terms.
RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW, J.