Full Text
W.P.(C) No. 13414-25/2005 Delhi University & College Karamchari Union.. Petitioners
Through: Mr.Vidhu Upadhyaya, Adv.
Through: Mr.Rajinder Dhawan, Adv.
Date of Decision: 28.07.2008
JUDGMENT
1. Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
2. To be referred to the Reporter or not?
3. Whether judgment should be reported in Digest?: PRADEEP NANDRAJOG, J.
1. Marching under the banner of Delhi University and College Karamchari Union, 12 persons have filed the aforesaid petition praying that order dated 14.5.2005 terminating their services be quashed. The petitioners pray that they be reinstated in service under respondent No.2, Lady Irwin College. University of Delhi has been impleaded as respondent No.1 for the reason the college is affiliated to the University of Delhi.
2. These 12 persons were initially appointed as 2008:DHC:2161 temporary employees and later on as probationers on various dates against various posts. The details of the post held and the period of appointment is as under:-
┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐ │ Sl. Name Posts Date of Date of │ │ No. Appointment Appointment │ │ TEMPORARY PROBATION │ ├─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤ │ 1. Smt. Safai 15.03.04 & 07.07.04 │ │ Kamlesh Karamchari 13.06.04 │ │ 2. Smt.Sushil Mali ---- 07.07.04 │ │ a Devi │ │ 3. Smt. Kunti Hostel 15.03.04 & 07.07.04 │ │ bearer/helper 13.06.04 │ │ 4. Santosh Office 21.02.03 25.05.04 │ │ Kumar attendant │ │ Tiwari │ │ 5. Bijendra Lab. ---- 03.09.04 │ │ Singh attendant │ │ 6. Gyan Safai 21.02.03 11.12.03 │ │ Chand Karamchari │ │ 7. Lokesh Safai 21.02.03 03.09.04 │ │ Kumar Karamchari │ │ 8. Radhey Safai 21.02.03 05.04.04 │ │ Shyam Karamchari │ │ 9. Paramjeet Lab.attendant 21.02.03 26.08.04 │ │ Singh │ │ 10. Jay Lib.attendant 04.03.04 & 18.08.04 │ │ Bahadur 07.06.04 │ │ 11. Kunwar Chowkidar 21.02.03 03.09.04 │ │ Singh │ │ 12. Manish Library 04.03.04 & 18.08.04 │ │ Kumar Attendent 07.06.04 │ │ 3. Needless to state each post against which petitioner │ │ worked is a non-teaching post. │ │ 4. Relevant portion of the order dated 14.5.2005 │ └─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘
13. Mr.Santosh Kumar Tiwari (Office Attendant)
14. Mr.Naveen Singh (Office Attendant) Sd/- Dr.Anupa Siddhu”
12. Responding to the additional affidavit, Dr.Anupa Siddhu, Principal-cum-Director of the college has explained Annexure P-7 by stating that a group called Group-S[4], concerned with recruitment and employment, had some vacancies. That she knew the said group and with a view to provide alternative jobs to not only the petitioners but the other similarly situated employees she had sent out the handwritten note Annexure P-7.
13. Surprisingly enough, in her additional affidavit Dr.Anupa Siddhu has not explained Annexure P-8 filed by the petitioners along with the rejoinder affidavit.
14. Petitioners have responded to the additional affidavit filed by Dr.Anupa Siddhu responding to the petitioners' averments in the rejoinder affidavit. To put it briefly, in the said additional affidavit filed in response to the additional affidavit filed by the Principal of the College further documents have been annexed showing that salary and wages are being paid to the persons employed vide order dated 8.6.2005 annexed as Annexure P-8 to the rejoinder affidavit filed by the petitioners.
15. The factual narration of the relevant facts herein above noted prima facie establishes an attitude of highhandedness and hire & fire being adopted in the respondent No.2 college. It is interesting to note that when services of the petitioners were dispensed with the erstwhile principal had retired and a new principal Dr.Anupa Siddhu had taken over.
16. It smells of nepotism. It gives rise to a grave suspicion that the new principal wanted to create her own fiefdom.
17. Why I say so?
18. Annexure P-8 filed by the petitioners along with the rejoinder affidavit has not been explained by the principal of the college when she filed the additional affidavit on 24.3.2007 responding to the pleas urged in the rejoinder affidavit. As noted herein above, the principal of the college explained Annexure P-7, the hand-written note issued by her on 7.6.2005. She had an opportunity to explain Annexure P-8, the order dated 8.6.2005. She has explained why 14 persons were employed at daily wage basis to various posts in the college.
19. I am conscious of the fact that out of 14 persons appointed on daily wage basis 5 were employed as safai karamcharis, 4 were employed as chowkidars, 3 as gardeners and 2 as office attendants and that not all petitioners were employed to said posts. But, Smt.Kamlesh, Gian Chand, Lokesh Kumar, Radhey Shyam, all petitioners were working as safai karamcharis when their services were dispensed with. Similarly, Sushila Devi, another petitioner was deployed as a gardener. Further, petitioner Kanwar Singh was deployed as a chowkidar and petitioner Santosh Kumar Tiwari was deployed as an office attendant. At least, said petitioners could have been continued in services if not other petitioners who were employed as laboratory attendant, library attendant and hostel helper.
20. In the decision reported as JT 2007 (12) SC 179 UP State Electricity Board vs. Puran Chandra Pandey, a Division Bench of the Hon'ble Supreme Court cautioned the Courts that its decision in Umadevi's case (supra) has not be applied mechanically as if it were a Euclid's formula. The Hon'ble Supreme Court cautioned the Courts that individual facts of each case has to be seen.
21. In said decision, Hon'ble Supreme Court drew attention to its earlier decision reported as AIR 1978 SC 597 Maneka Gandhi vs. UOI which held that reasonableness and non-arbitrariness is a part of Article 14 of the Constitution of India and that there could not be arbitrariness in State action. The Hon'ble Supreme Court noted that Maneka Gandhi's case (supra) did not deal with the issue of regularization of services of employees, but held that the principle of reasonableness in executive action is of general application.
22. What more unreasonableness can be found in the action of the principal of the college who disengaged the petitioners on the plea that their employment by the erstwhile principal was in violation of the directive issued by UGC on 31.8.1999 and that there were no posts against which petitioners were employed. Surprisingly enough, within about an year, on 8.6.2005, during pendency of the instant writ petition, 14 persons were re-engaged as daily wagers. I repeat, in spite of availing an opportunity the principal has not explained the circumstances under which she issued the office order dated 8.6.2005
23. It is obviously a case of resorting to hire and fire. It is a case where the UGC directive is being used as a shield to non-suit the petitioners but at the same time give employment to other persons.
24. In the decision reported as 1992 (4) SCC 118 State of Haryana vs. Piara Singh, the Hon'ble Supreme Court noted with regret that ad-hoc, casual and daily wage employment had given rise to back-door entries in employment for monetary consideration. This was the reason, in said decision, the Hon'ble Supreme Court laid emphasis on employment being resorted to by notifying applications from the name registered with the employment exchange and by public notice.
25. Instant case shows that the malady noted by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Piara Singh's case (supra) continues to plaque public employment. Annexure P-8 is a living example thereof.
26. I see no reason why safai karamchari's, chowkidars, malis and office attendant taken on daily wage basis on 8.6.2005 should continue at the cost of the petitioners who had been employed in the college but by the erstwhile principal.
27. Unfortunately, neither counsel could throw much light on the fate of the 14 persons employed vide Annexure P-
8.
28. The petitioners would thus be entitled to the minimum relief that henceforth, whenever the college requires additional hands on daily wage, ad-hoc or temporary basis first offer would be made to the petitioners and only in the event petitioners refuse the same would the college resort to employment of any other person.
29. In the facts and circumstances of the case I hold that the petitioners would be entitled to cost which I assess in sum of Rs.10,000/-. Cost shall be paid by the second respondent.
(PRADEEP NANDRAJOG) JUDGE July 28, 2008 dk”