COSMIC BUSINESS SCHOOL v. ALL INDIA COUNCIL OF TECHNICAL EDUCATION & ORS.

Delhi High Court · 30 Jul 2008 · 2008:DHC:2186
Vipin Sanghi
W.P.(C) No. 5111/2008
2008:DHC:2186
administrative appeal_dismissed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court held that a State university cannot operate study centres outside its State without UGC/DEC approval and that AICTE has jurisdiction over unauthorized technical education centres, dismissing interim relief to the petitioner.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
W.P.(C) No. 5111/2008
Date of Decision: 30.07.2008 COSMIC BUSINESS SCHOOL ..... Petitioner
Through Mr. Prashant Mendiratta, Adv.
VERSUS
ALL INDIA COUNCIL OF TECHNICAL EDUCATION & ORS. ..... Respondent
Through Mr. Nikhil Nayyar, Adv. for R-2 Mr. Amitesh Kumar for UGC
Mr. Jatan Singh for AICTE Mr. Aly Mirza for Distant Education
Council/R-5 Mr. Shikha Palsule for R-3
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIPIN SANGHI
JUDGMENT

1. Whether the Reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?

2. To be referred to Reporter or not? No

3. Whether the judgment should be No reported in the Digest? VIPIN SANGHI, J. (Oral) W.P.(C) No. 5111/2008 Counsel for respondent Nos.2,3, 4 & 5 have put in appearance and they seek time to file their counter affidavit. Let the same be filed within four weeks. Rejoinder be filed before the next date. List on 11.12.2008. CM No. 9773/2008

1. On the last date counsel for respondent No.1 All India Council of Technical Education (AICTE) had stated that till today the 2008:DHC:2186 respondent No.1 shall not give effect to the impugned order dated 9.3.2007. Today learned counsel for respondent No.1 has refused to extend the undertaking given to the court on the last date and has argued the matter on the aspect of grant of interim protection to the petitioner against the threatened action in terms of the impugned show cause notice of the respondent AICTE dated 9.3.2007 and the communication dated 30.6.2008. I have accordingly heard arguments at some length addressed by the counsel for the parties on the aspect of grant of interim protection as prayed for by the petitioner.

2. Indira Gandhi National Open University Act (IGNOU Act) has established IGNOU to encourage Distance Education System in the country as well as to coordinate the standards of such education. Distance Education Council (DEC) has been constituted as a body under Section 25 of IGNOU Act to promote concept of Open University as well as the Distance Education System, and for its coordination and determination of Standards of teaching.

3. The petitioner company claims to be running a study centre as defined under Regulation 2.[4] of the UGC (Establishment of And Maintenance of Standards in Private Universities) Regulations, 2003, established and maintained by respondent No.2 University viz Sikkim Manipal University of Health, Medical & Technological Sciences, which is a University constituted by the State of Sikkim by Act IX of 1995. The petitioner has however, not placed these Regulations of 2003 on record. Instead, what has been annexed to the writ petition are the UGC (the minimum standards of instructions for grant of the first degree through non formal/distance education in the faculties of Arts, Humanities, Fine Arts, Music, Social Sciences, Commerce and Sciences) Regulation, 1985 issued on 25.11.1985. Clause 3.[2] of these Regulations of 1985 enables the Universities to set up study centres (outside the headquarters) in areas where there is a reasonable concentration of students. It also lays down the facilities that a study center should provide.

4. The case of the petitioner is that IGNOU vide communication dated 29.8.2007 granted provisional recognition to programmes offered through distance education mode by the respondent No.2 University. The petitioner has accordingly set up a study centre of Respondent No.2 University in Delhi. The application for renewal of the recognition for the academic year 2008-2009 made by respondent No.2 to DEC is still pending. It is contended that AICTE has no role to play in the matter of courses and programmes run by respondent No.2 under the Distance Education Mode. This is the admitted position as is evident from the letter dated 12.4.2007 issued by AICTE to the Director, National Institute of Open Schooling. Reliance is also placed on the communication dated 28.8.2001 of UGC addressed to respondent No.2 which states that Universities are permitted to award degrees through Distance Education at their own centers in different parts of the country. Reliance is placed on the decision of the Supreme Court in Bhartidasan University & Anr. vs.

AICTE (2001) 8 SCC 676 which states that AICTE Act does not require a university to obtain prior approval of AICTE for starting a department or unit as an adjunct to the university itself to conduct technical education courses of its choice. The regulations framed by AICTE which required the Universities to obtain such approval were held to be void. It is, therefore, argued that the AICTE has no jurisdiction to take action against the petitioner as threatened in the impugned show cause notice dated 9.3.2007 and the letter dated 30.6.2008.

5. Learned counsel for the UGC, Mr. Amitesh Kumar, submits that after the Regulations of 1985, the UGC has framed the UGC (Establishment of and Maintenance of Standards in Private Universities) Regulations, 2003 which are applicable to private Universities such as respondent No.2.

6. These regulations of 2003 have been considered by the Supreme Court in Prof. Yashpal & Anr. vs. State of Chattisgarh & Ors. AIR 2005 SC 2026. Regulation 3.[3] of these Regulations puts restriction on establishment of a University outside the State by any state. The same reads: “3.[3] A private university established under a State Act shall operate ordinarily within the boundary of the State concerned. However, after the development of main campus, in exceptional circumstances, the university may be permitted to open off-campus centres, offshores campuses and study centres after five years of its coming into existence, subject to the following conditions……..”

7. He submits that the UGC has not granted any permission to respondent No.2 to open its study centres outside the State of Sikkim. Respondent No.2, Sikkim Manipal University of Health, Medical & Technological Sciences, Gangtok, Sikkim could not have extended its arms/activities beyond the State of Sikkim by setting up its study centres outside the State of Sikkim. In this regard reference may also be made to the observations of the Supreme Court in the aforesaid decision in paragraph 41. The same reads as follows: “41. Dr. Dhawan has also drawn the attention of the Court to certain other provisions of the Act which have effect outside the State of Chhattisgarh and thereby give the State enactment an extra territorial operation. Section 2(f) of the amended Act defines 'off-campus center' which means a center of the University established by it outside the main campus (within or outside the State) operated and maintained as its constituent unit having the university's complement of facilities, faculty and staff. Section 2(g) defines "offshore campus" and it means a campus of the university established by it outside the country, operated and maintained as its constituent unit, having the university's complement of facilities, faculty and staff. Section 3(7) says that the object of the University shall be to establish main campus in Chhattisgarh and to have the study centers at different places in India and other countries. In view of Article 245(1) of the Constitution, Parliament alone is competent to make laws for the whole or any part of the territory of India and the legislature of a State may make laws for the whole or any part of the State. The impugned Act which specifically makes a provision enabling a University to have an off-campus center outside the State is clearly beyond the legislative competence of the Chhattisgarh legislature.”

8. Therefore, respondent No.2 University, which is a University constituted under a State Law passed by the legislature of the State of Sikkim, prima facie, cannot have extra territorial authority, i.e. it cannot run, manage or supervise study centers outside the State of Sikkim. Following the decision in Prof. Yashpal (supra) the Supreme Court, in Rai University vs. State of Chattisgarh & Ors., 2005(5)SLR 838 has clarified that “institutions of the erstwhile private Universities, if otherwise eligible, may apply and seek affiliation with any other University which has jurisdiction over the area where the institution is functioning and is empowered under the relevant Rules and Regulations and other provisions of law applicable to the said University to grant affiliation.”

9. Mr. Jatan Singh, learned counsel for AICTE has also drawn my attention to a Memorandum of Understanding dated 10.5.2007 entered into between the UGC, AICTE and Distant Education Council (DEC). Under this MOU the aforesaid bodies have constituted a Joint Committee known as “UGC-AICTE-DEC Joint Committee for Technical and General Education in Distance Mode”. The purpose of entering into the MOU is stated to be to ensure the quality of technical and general education offered through distance and mixed mode. UGC and AICTE have agreed to utilize the expertise and involvement of DEC in functions such as review of the programmes & courses, curricula, norms and standards of approval of new courses and institutions, periodic review of the institutions/programmes, coordination of inspection and approval activities. The approval to the programmes run by a University through distance education are required, under this MOU, to be jointly issued by all the constituents of the said Committee.

10. My attention has also been drawn to the DEC guidelines for regulating the Establishment and Operation of Open and Distance Learning (ODL) Institutions in India issued by DEC. The Preamble to these guidelines clearly sets out the mischief that is sought to be remedied by these guidelines. The relevant portion of the Preamble states: “Of late, it has been seen that there is indiscriminate proliferation of Open and Distance Learning (ODL) Institutions In India. Even single-mode conventional universities are becoming dual mode to offer programmes in the distance mode. This has happened due to the fact that the formal system of face-to-face instruction has failed to cope up with the educational requirements of the ever-increasing number of aspiring students after plus two stage. At present more than 20% students of higher education in the Country are enrolled in the ODL system. What is disturbing to note is that distance mode has become purely commercial venture with little or no attention being paid to the quality of education offered to the learners. Many Universities awarding sub-standard certificate/diploma/degree programmes are not adhering to even the guidelines issued by the concerned regulatory bodies. In order to safeguard the interest of the students in India and to ensure the quality of education, the DEC has framed Guidelines, 2006 for regulating the establishment and operation of Open and Distance Learning (ODL) Institutions in India.”

11. These guidelines clearly provide that the parent institutions shall not establish their study centers/regional centers outside their jurisdiction as specified in the parent institutions Act/ MOA. In case of “deemed to be university” offering distance education programmes, the same will be confined to the state in which the main campus of the parent institution is located, except for programmes that are culturally and linguistically relevant even outside their state. The guidelines further provide that explicit approval of DEC should be obtained for offering such programmes (Guideline 3.3).

13,887 characters total

12. Guideline 9.[2] of these guidelines further states that the Study Centres shall be opened only in affiliated and constituent colleges, and in such other academic institutions which the parent institution may deem fit. The Study Centre should be located only within the jurisdiction of the parent institution after signing MOU. In case of deemed to be university the study centres should be only in the state where its Headquarter is located.

13. As aforesaid, IGNOU granted only provisional recognition for the academic session 2007-2008 vide communication dated 29.8.2007 addressed to respondent No.2 University for offering programmes through distance modes. This communication further stated that “for recognition of your institution for offering programmes through distance mode from the next academic year, i.e., from June-July, 2008, you are requested to submit fresh application in the prescribed format developed by DEC.”

14. The petitioner is running the study centre of respondent No.2 University at Delhi. In the face of the aforesaid decisions of the Surpeme Court in Prof Yashpal & Anr. (supra) and Rai University (supra), as also keeping in view the guidelines framed by DEC and the Regulations framed by the UGC in 2003 which have also been taken note of in the judgment of the Supreme Court in Prof Yashpal & Anr. (supra), it appears that running of the study centre by the petitioner at Delhi is prima facie impermissible. The petitioner ought to have disclosed in the writ petition the DEC guidelines and the UGC guidelines of 2003, which have unfortunately been withheld.

15. The submission of the petitioner that the AICTE is not entitled to take coercive action against the petitioner since the AICTE has no jurisdiction over respondent No.2 University in view of the decision of the Supreme Court in Bhartidasan (supra) does not appear to be tenable. This is so because, prima facie, the petitioner cannot run a study center, as a study centre of respondent No.2 University outside the State of Sikkim. Since the umbilical chord connecting the petitioner to respondent No.2 cannot be sustained, the petitioner cannot seek umbrage under respondent No.2 to sustain its activities or to seek protection against action that respondent AICTE may initiate. Admittedly, the petitioner is running the center to impart education in courses of management which comes within the realm of AICTE. Therefore, it appears that AICTE would have jurisdiction to proceed against the petitioner.

AICTE has not proposed to take action against respondent No.2 University. The decision in Bhartidasan (supra) is, therefore, not applicable.

16. Various other submissions have been made by the parties. However, at this stage I do not consider it necessary to deal with all of them. Since, prima facie, the petitioner is not entitled to run the study center, the application is dismissed.

VIPIN SANGHI,J JULY 30, 2008 aj