Full Text
Smt.Darshna Rani …..Appellant
Through: Mr.M.S. Vohra, Advocate
Through: Mr.C. Mohan Rao, Advocate
HON’BLE DR. JUSTICE S.MURALIDHAR
1.Whether reporters of the local news papers be allowed to see the
JUDGMENT
2.To be referred to the Reporter or not ?n
3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest ?n ORDER % 5.8.2008
1. The appellant challenges the order of the learned single Judge dated 13th March, 2008 passed in WP(C) No.6897/2007.
2. The appellant is the original writ petitioner. She had submitted a tender for allotment of shop bearing No.G-7, Block No.B-IV, Ground Floor, LSC at Lawrence Road in February, 2004. Along with the tender form, she had deposited Rs.98,750/towards earnest money. The bid of the appellant was accepted 2008:DHC:2244-DB and a demand letter dated 15th April, 2004 was issued to the appellant to deposit balance amount of Rs.2,96,250/- on/or before 14th May, 2004. The demand letter specifically stipulates that if the payment was not made by 14th May, 2004, the appellant would be liable to pay 15% compound interest with compounding being done of the accounting year. The demand letter further states that no regularisation of allotment is permissible on payment beyond 180 days. It is an admitted position that the appellant had not made full payment within 180 days in terms of the demand cum allotment letter. The appellant also did not pay interest in terms of the said demand cum allotment letter. In these circumstances, the respondent has refused to make allotment of the aforesaid shop and has cancelled the allotment made to the appellant.
3. The main contention of the appellant is that in similar cases the DDA had condoned delay of more than 180 days. However, this is disputed by the DDA. It has been stated that there was only one case in which the DDA had condoned delay of 380 days and the Vice Chairman had taken the said decision on 28th November, 2000. In no other case the DDA has condoned delay in payment of the principal amount beyond 180 days but delay in payment of interest beyond the said period can be condoned.
4. This Court has consistently taken a view that the bids for purchasing a shop are purely of the commercial nature and, therefore, such cases cannot be compared to allotment of residential plots / flats. In Prem Rani (Smt.) & Ors. v. Delhi Development Authority {2005 II AD (Delhi) 376}, this Court held that non-statutory policies, guidelines and conditions evolved for the functioning of state agencies bind such agencies; they can ignore such conditions only at the peril of violation of Article 14. In that case reliance was placed on the decisions of the Supreme Court in Raman Dayaraman Shetty v. Union of India; West Bengal State Electricity Board v. Patel Engineering and Netai Bag v. State of West Bengal. It is thus clear that in the absence of any authority to waive conditions of an auction to the terms governing an auction, where such conditions have not been complied with or have been violated, there is no valid sanction of tenders. The contention that in some other cases DDA had accepted the amount beyond 180 days must be rejected as Article 14 creates an obligation to grant equal treatment but the same does not amount to a mandate to indulge in transgression of policies.
5. In the result, the appeal fails and is dismissed.
CHIEF JUSTICE S.MURALIDHAR, J August 05, 2008 “nm”