Full Text
JUDGMENT
M/s. Malhotra Card Manufacturers
& Another … Appellants
Through: Mr. D.K. Rustagi, Advocate
Through: Mr. Arvind Chadha, Advocate
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUNIL GAUR
1. Whether the Reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
2. To be referred to Reporter or not?
3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? SUNIL GAUR, J.
1. This appeal has been preferred against judgment and decree dated 3rd February 2004 of the Additional District Judge, Delhi, whereby counter claim of Rs.4,98,347/- of the Appellant/ defendant has been dismissed not on merit but by holding that it is time barred and the suit of the Respondent/plaintiff for recovery of Rs.1,73,878/- with pendentelite and future interest @ 9% per annum has been decreed with costs.
2. The broad facts of this case are that the Appellant firm is 2008:DHC:2271-DB engaged in the business of forwarding of freight by Air and Sea and the Respondent firm had handed over five shipments for onward delivery by Air Freighting on 10th December, 1998 with the pre-condition that the above said five shipments should definitely reach the destination at Uganda by 15th December, 1998. Respondent had advised the Appellant to send the above said shipment through Gulf Air by paying extra freight of almost Rs.60,000/-, so that the said shipment would reach the destination by 16th December 1998 positively.
3. Appellant had agreed to send the above said five shipments through Gulf Air Carrier to Uganda on the assurance given by the Respondent that the said consignment would reach the destination by 16th December 1998. However, the aforesaid consignment of the Appellant was off-loaded on the way by Gulf Air and it could not reach the destination in time and the buyer of the Appellant were not able to distribute the Christmas Cards, Diaries, Calendar and Promotional items in time and so the payment of the Appellant was stopped, which led to loss of business worth lacs of rupees and the Appellant had to visit Uganda to settle the issue of delayed receiving of goods and on that account, counter claim was made for not receiving the entire payment of the goods, expenses incurred for travelling to Uganda and back and damages on account of loss of future business etc. Whereas, the suit of the Respondent pertained to the recovery of the outstanding principal amount of Rs.1,73,878/- with interest towards the air freight charges for the above said five shipments.
4. On the claim and counter claim, the issues framed by the Trial Court read as under:- “1. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to the amount claimed by them in their claim alongwith interest and costs? OPP
2. Whether the defendant is entitled to the amount claimed in their counter claim alongwith interest and costs? OPD
3. Whether the suit is bad for non-joinder and mis-joinder of the parties? OPD
4. Relief.”
5. Shri P.K. Malhotra, partner of the Appellant/defendant firm had deposed as DW-1 and Capt. Sudhir Kapoor, Managing Partner of the Respondent/plaintiff firm had deposed as PW-2 and the Respondent herein had got examined Assistant Manager of Jet Air Ltd., (which was general sales agent for Gulf Air) as PW-1 to prove letter Ex. P-2 to indicate that the above referred shipment was to arrive at the destination on 16th December 1998 but it got off loaded due to heavy rush of Christmas and non-availability of space and it had arrived at the destination in parts, i.e., on 20th December 1998 and 23rd December 1998 and thereafter. Apart from the above referred evidence, consisting of three witnesses, no other evidence was led before the Trial Court by either side.
6. After a contest, vide impugned judgment and decree, Trial Court has decreed the suit of the Respondent/plaintiff and has dismissed the counter claim of the Appellant/defendant as indicated in opening paragraph of this judgment.
7. Both the sides have been heard in this appeal and the record of this case has been perused by us.
8. During the course of the arguments, the challenge to the impugned judgment was confined by the learned counsel for Appellant to the rejection of the counter claim of the Appellant/Defendant and in our view, it was rightly done, as we find that the claim of the Respondent/plaintiff to the Air Freight charges is legitimate one and it could not have been withheld. There is no dispute that the outstanding principal amount, after adjusting the part payment received, is Rs.1,73,878/- and in the light of the evidence led, there is no justification for withholding it and we find that the Trial Court rightly decreed the aforesaid amount with reasonable rate of interest @ 9% per annum. Therefore, the challenge in this appeal to decree of Rs.1,73,878/with costs and pendentelite and future interest @ 9% per annum fails. However, we have given our anxious consideration to the dismissal of the counter claim of the Appellant which has been out rightly done by the Trial Court by holding that it is time barred.
9. Trial Court has relied upon section 27, 29 & 30 of the Carriage by Air Act, 1972 and has reproduced the above said sections in the impugned judgment. As per Section 30 of the aforesaid Act, the period of limitation for claiming damages on account of late delivery or non-delivery of the Air Freighted goods is two years, which has to be reckoned from the date of arrival of the goods at the destination or from the date on which the Aircraft ought to have delivered the goods at the destination. Trial Court has held that the counter claim of the Appellant was made on 1st November, 2001 and infact it should have been made by January, 2001 and thus it has been dismissed as time barred. Trial Court has also relied upon case of M/s. Shailesh Textile Industries vs. British Airways and Anr., 2003 (IV) Apex Decisions (Delhi) 276, wherein it has been held that in cases under the Carriage by Air Act, 1972, right to damages is extinguished, if action is not brought within the period of two years from the date of its accrual and the Limitation Act, 1963 would not apply to such cases.
10. Aforesaid finding of the Trial Court has been assailed before us by the Appellant by drawing our attention to the pleadings of the parties, to highlight that neither it was Appellant’s case nor it was Respondent’s case that the Respondent was an agent of the Carriage ‘Gulf Air’. After having perused the pleadings of the parties, we find that there is no whisper in the pleadings of the parties about Respondent being an agent of the Carrier ‘Gulf Air’. Not only this, the evidence on this vital aspect is also lacking. Infact, as per the deposition of the Assistant Manager, PW-1, of Jet Air Limited, the G.S.A. (General Sales Agent) of the Carrier ‘Gulf Air’ is Jet Air Limited. It is pertinent to notice that when the Managing Partner (PW-2) of the Respondent/plaintiff was cross examined before the Trial Court, it was clarified by him that the commission charged for air freighting by the Respondent/plaintiff is in their capacity as freight forwarding agents and the Carrier ‘Gulf Air’ was not made a party as there was no privity of contract between the Respondent/plaintiff and said Airlines.
11. In the face of the above referred evidence, it was not open to the Trial Court to have simply looked into photocopy of Airway Bill (which is not duly proved on record) to notice that in the column of issuing carrier agent name and city, the name of the Respondent is mentioned. It is not disputed not it can be that it has to be first established that the Respondent is an agent of the Air Carrier ‘Gulf Air’ and then only the question of applicability of the Carriage by Air Act, 1972, would arise. Thereafter only, it can be seen as to whether the ratio of judgment reported as 2003 (IV) Apex Decisions (Delhi) 276, applies to this case or not.
12. We are of the considered opinion that the Trial Court has gravely erred in proceeding on the presumption that the Respondent is the agent of the Carrier ‘Gulf Air’, because we have found that neither there are specific pleadings nor any legal evidence on record to establish the factum of Respondent being an agent of the Carrier ‘Gulf Air’. To arrive at a just decision in this matter, we deem it appropriate to frame an additional issue, which is under: “Whether the Respondent - Ashtbhuj Ocean Movers acted as an agent of Gulf Air, while issuing the Airway Bills, receiving the consignment and putting the same on board for onward carriage to the destination? If so, whether the claim for payment of damages against the agent is not maintainable under Section 27, 29 & 30 of the Carriage by Air Act, 1972?”
13. In all fairness to both the sides, we also deem it proper that an opportunity ought to be afforded to the parties to the suit to lead evidence on the above referred additional issue and direct the Trial Court to record a finding on the aforesaid additional issue regarding applicability of the Carriage by Air Act, 1972 to this case. It is made clear that if the finding on the aforesaid additional issue is returned in favour of Appellant, then the Trial Court is directed to decide the counter claim of the Appellant on merits on the basis of the evidence already recorded. However, it is left open to the Trial Court to decide if any fresh evidence is required to be brought on record by the parties to the suit, if any such application is made by either side.
14. In view of the aforesaid narration, impugned judgment and decree dismissing the counter claim of the Appellant/defendant is set aside, leaving the parties to bear their own costs and the counter claim of the Appellant/defendant is directed to be registered as a separate suit by the Trial Court which is expected to decide it afresh after framing the additional issue, as indicated above. However, impugned judgment decreeing the suit of the Respondent/plaintiff for a sum of Rs.1,73,878/- with pendentelite and future interest @ 9% per annum with costs is affirmed.
15. In pursuance to the order dated 9th December 2004 passed by this Court in this appeal, decretal amount of Rs.1,73,878/- has been deposited by the Appellant with the Registrar General of this Court and the same stands invested in Fixed Deposit Receipt. With the dismissal of this appeal qua the impugned decree of Rs.1,73,878/- with interest and costs, it follows that the Respondent/plaintiff would be at liberty to withdraw the aforesaid amount with interest accrued thereon and to take out the execution for the remainder, if any.
16. Counter claim of the Appellant is remanded back to the trial court, to be expeditiously tried afresh as directed above. Both the sides are directed to appear before the District Judge, Delhi on 5th September, 2008 for assigning of the counter claim to the Court of competent jurisdiction. Trial Court record be sent back forthwith.
17. This appeal is partly allowed to the extent indicated above.
SUNIL GAUR, J T.S. THAKUR, J August 7, 2008 PKB