Full Text
IA.No. 9680/2006(u/O 7 Rule 11 CPC) & CS(OS)
250/2006
Date of Decision: 08.08.2008
PRIYANKA VIVEK BATRA ….…Plaintiff
Through: Mr. Pradeep K Bakshi with Mr Madhur Yadav, Advocates
Through: Mr. Akhil Sibal with Ms Meghna Mishra, Mr Abhishek Roy and Mr Salim Inamdar, Advocates.
Defendant No.3 ex parte.
JUDGMENT
1. Whether reporters of Local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? YES
2. To be referred to the reporter or not? YES
3. Whether the judgment should be reported YES in the Digest?
RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW, J
1. The defendants No. 1 and 2 have filed this application under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC for rejection of the plaint as premature and not disclosing any cause of action and on the ground of claim therein being barred by the Benami Transactions (Prohibition) Act. Vide order dated 2nd May, 2007, the plaintiff was also called upon to 2008:DHC:2298
2. One Shri Ashok Malik was the father of the plaintiff and the defendant No.2 and the husband of the defendant No.1. Shri Ashok Malik died on 4th January, 2003. It is the case of the plaintiff that Shri Ashok Malik has left a Will dated 29th October, 2002 of which probate has been applied for by its executor before this court and is pending as Testamentary Case No. 3/2006. It is the case of the defendants No. 1 and 2 that the said Shri Ashok Malik left a Will dated 28th February, 1998 and they have applied for probate of the same in the courts at Chandigarh. The plaintiff has instituted the present suit (a) for declaration that the agricultural land situated at Rajasthan and Haryana and the flat at Belvedere Tower, DLF City Phase II, Gurgaon are the properties of Shri Ashok Malik and the plaintiff alone is entitled to the said properties in accordance with the Will dated 29th October, 2002; (b) for further declaration that in terms of the said Will, the defendants do not have any share in the aforesaid properties;
(c) for declaration that certain other properties in Gurgaon and
Rohtak, which the defendant No.1 has got transferred to her name on the basis of the Will set up by the defendant No.1, is bad and; (d) for further declaration that certain other properties again at Haryana in the joint names of Shri Ashok Malik and the defendant No.1 or in the sole name of the defendant No.1 are, in fact, the properties of Shri Ashok Malik only and in terms of the will dated 29th October, 2002 of Shri Ashok Malik the plaintiff alone is entitled to the said properties; (e) for permanent injunction restraining the defendants from dealing with the said properties.
3. The counsel for defendants No. 1 and 2 has argued that all the immovable properties with respect to which declaration is claimed are situated outside the territorial jurisdiction of this court; u/S 16(d) of the CPC the suit for determination of any right or interest in immovable property can be filed only in the court within whose jurisdiction the property is situated. It is further urged that in the present case all the parties also are outside the jurisdiction of this court. Reliance was also placed on Harshad Chiman Lal Modi v DLF Universal Ltd [(2005) 7 SCC 791] to canvass that the bar of territorial jurisdiction is statutory bar within the meaning of Order 7 Rule 11(d) CPC
4. The counsel for defendants No. 1 and 2 relied upon Ram Shankar v Balakdas AIR 1992 MP 224 to contend that the jurisdiction of civil court to adjudicate on validity of Will is barred owning to the exclusive jurisdiction of the Probate court. Reliance is further placed on Smt Rukmani Devi & Ors v Narendra Lal Gupta 1985 1 SCC 144; Rukn-ul-Mulk S Abdul Wajid & Ors v Mrs Gajambal Ramalingam and Ors AIR (37) 1950 Mysore 57 and Alagammai & Ors v V. Rakkammal AIR 1992 Madras 136 to urge that the judgment of the probate court would be a judgment in rem and would have binding effect as it is the probate court alone which can go into the question of the validity of the Will. It was urged that the plaintiff, till the probate of the Will on the basis of which title to properties is claimed had no legal character within the meaning of Section 34 of the Specific Relief Act and of which declaration could be
5. The defendants/applicants also urged that the reliefs that properties in the name of defendant No.1 or in the joint names of defendant No.1 and her deceased husband (father of plaintiff and defendant No.2) were the properties of deceased only is in the teeth of Section 4 of the Benami Act and it did not make any exception for a wife, as the defendant No.1 admittedly is.
6. The counsel for the plaintiff, on the other hand, relied upon Union Bank of India v Logic Systems Pvt Ltd (AIR 1992 Del 153) and Rohit Kochar v Vipul Infractrure Developers Ltd 122 (2005) DLT 480 to contend that this court has territorial jurisdiction. He further urged that the bar of Benami was not applicable between husband and wife. The counsel for the plaintiff stated that the question of whether the defendant No.1 or the deceased was the owner of the property could not be adjudicated in the probate proceedings and the plaintiff had instituted the suit to curtail delays even after succeeding in probate proceedings. During the hearing, on inquiry, counsel for the plaintiff admitted that the defendants No. 1 and 2 were in possession of the properties with respect to which declaration was claimed. Upon further inquiry as to why the plaintiff had not claimed the consequential relief of possession of the properties, the counsel for the plaintiff stated that the plaintiff has in the plaint craved leave under Order 2 Rule 2 CPC in this respect and would be claiming the said relief in the event of the probate being allowed and further in the event of it being declared that the deceased only was the owner of the properties which stand in the name of the
7. Re: The suit being premature or the plaint disclosing no cause of action.
AIR 1968 P & H 108, Murli Dhar Dua v Shashi Mohan 68 (1997) DLT 284 and Preethi Pal Singh v Jagjit Singh 1996 (37) DRJ 643 has held that in so far as Delhi (and it equally applies to Haryana where subject properties are situated) it is not essential to obtain probate of Will and Will can be setup and proved in collateral proceedings also.
Prasad AIR 1916 PC 78 it was said: “There is so much more danger in India than here of harassing and vexatious litigation that the courts in source of litigation”
Brothers AIR 2004 SC 2093 lays down that if the litigation, irrespective of the result will benefit neither of the parties to litigation should not be flogged like a dead horse. This court in Maha Singh v Shri Anand 116 (2005) DLT 378 held that court is not an idle docile and mindless spectator powerless to bring frivolous litigation to an early end; the court is also not a slave of proceeding.
I. If the present suit is allowed to proceed the defendant No.1 will be compelled to prove her title and all of which may be irrelevant succeeds.
Order 7 Rule 11 of CPC, but I consider it essential to do substantial justice between the parties specially when the plaintiff is not likely to suffer any loss and all rights of plaintiff, if successful in her Will, are protected.
8. Re: Territorial Jurisdiction
9. Re: The claim in suit be barred by Benami Transactions Prohibition Act. The argument of the counsel for the defendants No. 1 and 2 that the claim of the plaintiff that the properties in the name of the defendant No.1 or in the joint names of the defendant No.1 and her deceased husband are held benami and her deceased husband was the real owner thereof is barred by Benami Transactions Prohibition Act, 1988 does not appear to be tenable in view of Nand Kishore v Sushil Mehra AIR 1995 SC 2145 holding that neither the filing of a suit nor taking of a defence in respect of either the present or past benami transaction involving the purchase of property by a person in the name of his wife is prohibited under sub-sections (1) and (2) of Section 4 of the Benami Act. This court thereafter in (80) 1999 DLT 670 on facts held that the wife was benami and the husband was the real owner of the property. The plaint is, therefore, not liable to be rejected on this ground.
10. Re: The relief of permanent injunction claimed in the plaint The plaintiff has, besides the relief of the declaration, with respect to which, as aforesaid, the plaint is liable to be rejected, has also claimed the relief of permanent injunction restraining the defendants from dealing with the properties with respect to which declaration is claimed. The relief of permanent injunction has been claimed as a consequential relief to the relief of declaration. Once it is held that the plaint for relief of declaration is liable to be rejected/dismissed, the plaint insofar as for the relief of permanent relief of permanent injunction is also barred by the provisions of Section 41(h) of the Specific Relief Act. The plaintiff has equally efficacious relief of protecting the estate of the deceased by applying to the probate court under Part VII, chapter XXIII of the Indian Succession Act, 1925. It has been held in Cotton Corpn of India v United Industrial Bank AIR 1983 SC 1272 that the relief of permanent injunction is barred by the provisions of Section 41 of the Specific Relief act.
11. In view of the findings aforesaid, the plaint is rejected/dismissed for the reason of not disclosing any cause of action and/or for the reason of the relief of declaration being premature and/or the plaintiff being not entitled to the same on the date of the institution of the suit and further on the ground of the relief of declaration claimed in the plaint being barred by law i.e., Section 16 of the CPC and the relief of permanent injunction claimed in the plaint being barred by the provisions of Section 41 of the Specific Relief Act. However, in the facts of the case, the parties are left to bear their own costs.
RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW (JUDGE) August 08, 2008 M