Kingston Computers I P.Ltd. v. State Bank of Travancore

Delhi High Court · 12 Aug 2008 · 2008:DHC:2327
Pradeep Nandrajog; Sunil Gaur
RFA 174/2007
2008:DHC:2327
civil appeal_allowed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court held that a suit filed by a company director without formal authorization documents is valid under Order 29 Rule 1 CPC if the director's status is unchallenged, allowing the appeal and decreeing the suit.

Full Text
Translation output
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
RFA 174/2007
KINGSTON COMPUTERS I P.LTD. ..... Appellant
Through: Mr. D.K.Sharma, Advocate
VERSUS
STATE BANK OF TRAVANCORE ..... Respondent
Through: Mr. Abhishek Kumar, Adv. for R-1.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PRADEEP NANDRAJOG
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUNIL GAUR O R D E R 12.08.2008
JUDGMENT

1. Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?

2. To be referred to the Reporter or not?

3. Whether judgment should be reported in Digest?: PRADEEP NANDRAJOG, J.(Oral)

1. Vide order dated 21.5.2007 the appeal was admitted. Filing of the paper book was dispensed with. Trial Court Record was summoned.

2. Thereafter, from time to time, matter was adjourned for final hearing.

3. The matter has been heard for final disposal today.

4. Before noting the facts relevant for the disposal of the instant appeal it may be noted that the respondent was served with a notice of admission of the appeal somewhere prior to RFA No.174/2007 2008:DHC:2327 3.10.2007. On said date counsel appeared for the respondent.

5. No cross objections have been filed. Period of limitation for filing cross objections has lapsed. No cross appeal has been filed.

6. Appellant company had opened an account with the first respondent, State Bank of Travancore. Being a company registered under the Companies Act, the appellant had to inform State Bank of Travancore as to who would operate the account on it's behalf. It is not in dispute that vide Ex.PW-1/C the necessary information was conveyed to the bank. The information was in the form of the Board Resolution at the meeting of the Board of Directors of the appellant which was held on 19.4.2001. Ex.PW- 1/C was conveyed to the bank under the signatures of Raj Shukla, a Director of the appellant company.

7. Ex.PW-1/C reads as under:- “EXTRACT OF MINUTES OF BOARD OF DIRECTORS MEETING HELD ON 19TH APRIL 2001 AT THE REGISTERED OFFICE OF THE COMPANY “RESOLVED that the banking account No. 1217 of “Kingston Computers India Pvt. Ltd.” with State Bank of Travancore, R.K.Puram, New Delhi, be operated by the following authorized persons, to sign or accept all cheques, bills of exchange, promissory notes and other orders, within the limits stated herein below: That Mr. Raj Shukla, Director is authorized to sign all cheques, without any limits. That Mr. Debashis Saraswati Director and either Mr. Sanjeev Gulati or Mr. Rohit Khanna are authorized to sign jointly all cheques. That these signing instructions supercede all earlier instruction given by the company to the Bank. “FURTHER RESOLVED THAT the aforesaid bank be instructed to honour all cheques, promissory notes and other orders drawn by and all bills accepted on behalf of the Company whether such account be in credit or overdrawn and to accept and the credit to the account of the Company all money is deposited with or owing by the bank or any account at any time or time kept or to be kept in the name of the Company and the amount, cheques, promissory notes, bills and other negotiable instruments, orders or receipt provided they are endorsed/signed by the above signatories on behalf of the company and such signature(s) shall be sufficient authority to bind the company in all transactions between the bank and the Company, including those specifically referred to herein. Sd/- Raj Shukla Director”

8. A perusal of Ex.PW-1/C shows that the first respondent was clearly instructed that the account in the name of the appellant would be operated by Raj Shukla. It was made known that he could operate the account without any limit. As an alternative, it was informed to the bank that respondent No.2, Mr. Debashis Saraswati, along with either Mr. Sanjeev Gulati or Mr. Rohit Khanna could also operate the account.

9. Meaning thereby, the account could be operated by either Raj Shukla acting alone or Debashis Saraswati jointly with Sanjeev Gulati or Debashis Saraswati acting jointly with Rohit Khanna.

10. To put it pithily, acting singly Debashis Saraswati could not operate the account.

11. It is not in dispute that the account bearing No. CA- 1217 in the name of the appellant company was opened by the first respondent pursuant to receipt of the resolution Ex.PW-1/C, apart from other documents executed by the appellant as per the requirement of the bank.

12. It is not in dispute that 22 cheque leafs out of the cheque book issued by the respondent bank were utilized for making withdrawals in various sums and that these 22 cheques were signed only by Debashis Saraswati. Details of the said 22 cheques are as under:-

12,880 characters total
┌───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ Sl. Cheque No. Dated             Drawn in favour of   Amount                      │
│ No.                                                                               │
├───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
│ 1.    18533       20/4/2001      Sharma Builders      Rs.20,000/-                 │
│ 2.    18535       21/4/2001      Compatible           Rs.2,000/-                  │
│                                  Computers                                        │
│ 3.    18556       16/5/2001      Yourself             Rs.1,78,565/-               │
│ 4.    18557       18/5/2001      S.D.Mandal           Rs.2,000/-                  │
│ 5.    18564       04/06/01       Vivekananda          Rs.8,500/-                  │
│                                  Sarkar                                           │
│ 6.    18568       13/6/2001      Self                 Rs.11,000/-                 │
│ 7.    18571       19/6/2001      Admax                Rs.375/-                    │
│ 8.    18574       20/6/2001      Self                 Rs.3,000/-                  │
│ 9.    18578       20/6/2001      S.K.Nabh             Rs.9,000/-                  │
│ 10. 18578         20/6/2001      S.K.Nabh             Rs.6,000/-                  │
│ 11. 18575         21/6/2001      Vevekananda          Rs.5,000/-                  │
│                                  Sarkar                                           │
│ 12. 18579         29/6/2001      Debashish            Rs.4,000/-                  │
│                                  Saraswati                                        │
│ RFA No.174/2007                                            page 4 of 12           │
│                                                                   2008:DHC:2327   │
│ 13. 18581         02/07/01     Self                 Rs.5,000/-                    │
│ 14. 18583         02/07/01     Vivekananda          Rs.3,500/-                    │
│                                Sarkar                                             │
│ 15. 18585         06/07/01     Debashish            Rs.8,500/-                    │
│                                Saraswati                                          │
│ 16. 18586         06/07/01     Self                 Rs.10,000/-                   │
│ 17. 18587         06/07/01     Indo     German Rs.4,100/-                         │
│                                Chamber      of                                    │
│                                Commerce                                           │
│ 18. 18589         07/07/01     Self                 Rs.6,875/-                    │
│ 19. 18588         07/07/01     Self                 Rs.5,000/-                    │
│ 20. 18593         18/7/2001    Yourself             Rs.3,85,255/-                 │
│ 21. 18591         18/7/2001    Yourself             Rs.3,41,578/-                 │
│ 22. 18592         18/7/2001    Self                 Rs.10,000/-                   │
│ 13.         On realizing that the bank had permitted Debashis                     │
└───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘

23. This then is the short issue which needs to be considered by us exercising appellate jurisdiction.

24. Order 29 Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure reads as under:- “1. Subscription and verification of pleading.- In suits by or against a corporation, any pleading may be signed and verified on behalf of the corporation by the secretary or by any director or other principal officer of the corporation who is able to depose to the facts of the case.”

25. Discussing Order 29 Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure, in the decision in United Bank of India's case (supra), in para 10, Hon'ble Supreme Court held as under:- “Reading Order 6 Rule 14 together with Order 29 Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure it would appear that even in the absence of any formal letter of authority or power of attorney having been executed a person referred to in Rule 1 of Order 29 can, by virtue of the office which he holds, sign and verify the pleadings on behalf of the corporation. In addition thereto and dehors Order 29 Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure, as a company is a juristic entity, it can duly authorize any person to sign the plaint or the written statement on its behalf and this would be regarded as sufficient compliance with the provisions of Order 6 Rule 14 of the Code of Civil Procedure.”

26. Suffice would it be to state that in law, the Secretary, Director or a Principal Officer of a company would be treated as duly authorized to institute suit on behalf of a company. This flows out from a bare reading of Order 29 Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure and as further explained in the decision in United Bank of India's case.

27. Thus, if Ashok K.Shukla is proved to be a Director of the appellant company, the suit instituted under his signatures would have to be treated as a properly instituted suit.

28. Taking note of the fact that the appellant did not summon any witness from the office of the Registrar of Companies to prove that Ashok K.Shukla was a Director of the Company as also taking note of the fact that the minute books of the appellant company were not produced to prove that Ashok K.Shukla was a Director of the appellant, we consider the issue in light of the available evidence. But before that we may note that the appellant gave a justification for not producing the minute books of the appellant company by stating that Sh. Debashis Saraswati had run away with the record of the appellant company.

29. To establish the authority of Ashok K.Shukla to institue the suit on behalf of the appellant the evidence relied upon by the appellant was none else, other than Ex.PW-1/C and Ex.PW-1/A. With reference to Ex.PW-1/C it was highlighted that admittedly the bank opened the account pursuant to receipt of the Board Resolution, Ex.PW-1/C. With reference thereto it was attempted to be brought home that the bank accepted Raj Shukla to be a Director on the Board of the company. With reference to Ex.PW-1/A and linking the same to Ex.PW-1/C, contention urged was, and the same is repeated before us, that the document Ex.PW-1/A issued under the admitted signatures of Raj Shukla, while authorizing Ashok K. Shukla to institute the suit on behalf of the appellant, records that Ashok K.Shukla is a Director of the appellant. Elaboration made is that if Ex.PW-1/A was not to be treated as a valid authorization it could be considered as proof of Ashok K. Shukla being a Director of the appellant.

30. Indeed, Ex.PW-1/A records that Ashok K.Shukla is a Director of the appellant.

31. Ashok K.Shukla deposed on behalf of the appellant as PW-1. He tendered his examination-in-chief by way of an affidavit. In said affidavit by way of evidence he proved Ex. PW- 1/A.

32. We have gone through the cross examination of Ashok K.Shukla conducted by the respondent. Indeed, we do not find any challenge to the contents of said document i.e. Ex. PW- 1/A.

33. Thus, the contents of Ex.PW-1/A recording that Ashok

K. Shukla is a Director of the appellant has gone unchallenged.

34. Ex. PW-1/A may not be treated as an authorization in favour of Ashok K.Shukla to file the suit on behalf of the appellant. But, its contents recording Ashok K.Shukla to be a Director of the appellant having remained unchallenged. The authority of Ashok K.Shukla to institute the suit on behalf of the appellant flows from the provisions of Order 29 Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

35. The appeal is allowed.

36. Decision of the learned Trial Judge on issue No.1 is reversed.

37. Issue No.1 is decided in favour of the appellant and against the respondent holding that the suit has been signed, verified and filed by a duly authorized person.

38. As noted hereinabove the respondent has not filed any cross objections nor has any cross appeal been filed in relation to other issues decided against the respondent.

39. The appeal stands disposed of decreeing the suit filed by the appellant against the respondent No.1. The decree would be in conformity with the decision of the learned Trial Judge on issue No.5 and 6. The rate of interest would be as awarded by the learned Trial Judge while discussing issue No.6 i.e. @ 9% p.a. The interest payable would be till realization.

40. Appellant would be entitled to cost all throughout.

41. TCR be returned.

PRADEEP NANDRAJOG, J. SUNIL GAUR, J. AUGUST 12, 2008 mm