Full Text
Crl . Appeal No. 159/1994
Date of Decision: 14th AUGUST, 2008 MCD ..... Petitioner
Through: Ms. Maninder Acharya, Advocate
Through: None.
JUDGMENT
1. Whether Reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? No
2. To be referred to the Reporter or not? No
3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the digest? Yes
JUDGMENT
MANMOHAN, J: (ORAL)
1. The present appeal has been filed under Section 378(4) of the Code of Criminal Procedure for setting aside the judgment dated 17th September, 1993 passed by Shri. R.S. Arya, Metropolitan Magistrate, New Delhi.
2. Briefly stated, the material facts of this case are that a criminal complaint under Sections 313(5) and 461 of the Delhi Municipal 2008:DHC:2368 Corporation Act, 1957 read with Sections 34/120B of IPC was filed against fifteen accused persons by MCD.
3. The allegations in the complaint were that on 22nd December, 1986 at about 9.00 a.m. Shri Milap Chand Garg, Naib Tahsildar, MCD along with Shri Tara Chand, Patwari and Shri R.K. Sharma, ZE carried out an inspection in agricultural village Zafarpur Kalan and found that the accused persons were carving out residential plots in their agricultural land for the purpose of selling it to individuals under the name and style of ‘Dabur Enclave’. According to the appellant, the agricultural land was owned by the accused persons jointly, who entered into a conspiracy with the common intention of carving out plots, roads and streets for construction of residential building without seeking either any prior permission or sanction of plans from the MCD.
4. Out of the fifteen accused persons ten were discharged at the initial stage and the complaint proceeded only against five remaining accused persons - who are the Respondents in the present appeal.
5. The Trial Court acquitted all the accused on the ground that not only was the sanction of prosecution bad in law but the prosecution had also failed to prove its case beyond doubt.
6. In my opinion, the first finding of the Trial Court that the sanction for prosecution was bad in law is untenable. The Trial court has held that the sanction for prosecution was without application of mind because not only was same undated but it did not specifically mention Section 313 (5) of the Delhi Municipal Corporation Act, 1957.
7. I have perused the sanction order PW2/A and PW2/B and I find that in the initial note prepared by Shri Milap Chand Garg, Naib Tahsildar, both the sections 313(5) as well as 461 of the Delhi Municipal Corporation Act were mentioned. It is true that the Deputy Commissioner while ultimately sanctioning the prosecution has mentioned only section 461 of the DMC Act but to my mind the ultimate sanction has to be read in conjunction with the proposal that was mooted. I find that the Deputy Commissioner while according sanction to prosecute had not recorded any dissent with regard to the initial note put up by the Naib Tahsildar. Consequently, the proposal and the sanction have to be read together. Moreover Section 461 is only a punishment section and an accused can be punished under this section, only if he is charged separately under a substantive section of the DMC Act. I am further of the view that the complaint and the sanction have to be read together. In fact, on a harmonious reading of both the documents I have no doubt that what has been sanctioned is prosecution of the accused under Section 313(5) of the DMC Act as the same is the substantive and charging Section.
8. However, on merits the Trial Court has concluded that the prosecution has failed to prove its case beyond doubt. The relevant reasoning of the Trial Court is reproduced hereinbelow for ready reference:- On perusal of the cross-examination of PW[5] Tara Chand Patwari an eye witness I find that the same is discrepent and not safe for basing conviction of the accused persons. He stated that there was no complaint of any person, that any of the accused persons had sold land to him. He further stated in the same breath that the complaint was in writing. Here he is self contradicting. After this statement Ld. AMP pointed out that no such complaint is on the file. PW[5] further stated that one Prabhu had complained to the department and Tehsildar could tell if he recorded the statement of Prabhu. Here Prabhu is one of the accused persons and certainly a Co-owner of the land who is now accused would not like to lodge such complaint. Moreover, there is no such complaint proved by the prosecution. Even Tehsildar who is PW[2] Mr. Milap Chand Garg Naib Tehsildar, did not state that one Prabhu had complained to the department. There is one more important witness of the prosecution who is PW[7]. He is Mr. Ranbir Singh, Revenue Patwari. The statement on oath of PW[7] in cross-examination has damaged the prosecution case. He admitted having received the application for mutation from that of the previous owners to the new owners somewhere in the month of August, September, 1986, and the mutation was accordingly, done. He further admitted that while making mutation he had in his possession the said application as well as the Municipal record before him. He stated that he prepared Khatoni Ex. PW7/A on 24.3.87. He further stated that he had visited the site in question and he saw the agricultural activities going on. The date 24.3.87 on which Ex. PW7/A was prepared is very material and significant viewing the date of occurrence which is 22.12.86. On 24.3.87 or thereafter, the Patwari testifies, that agricultural activities were going on, on the land in question. Then, where stands the ‘DABUR ENCLAVE’? Besides this, he mutated the land in question in the name of New Owners as shown in Ex.PW7/A, after the date of occurrence and certainly at that time no ‘DABUR ENCLAVE’ existed. With these above observation and discussion I conclude that the prosecution case is not free from the shadow of reasonable doubt. The benefit of doubt goes to the accused persons. All the five accused persons are acquitted. Bail bonds stand discharged.”
9. In view of the discrepancies in the evidence of PW[5] as well as the subsequent mutation carried out by the Revenue Authority, I am of the view that the Trial Court was correct in concluding that the prosecution has not been able to prove its case beyond doubt and the benefit of doubt must enure to the benefit of the respondents.
10. Consequently, the present appeal is dismissed. MANMOHAN, J AUGUST 14, 2008 rb