Municipal Corporation of Delhi v. Ramey

Delhi High Court · 18 Aug 2008 · 2008:DHC:2372
S. Ravindra Bhat
Execution Petition No. 93/2004
2008:DHC:2372
civil appeal_dismissed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court held that vague and unsubstantiated allegations of fraud cannot defeat execution of a decree confirmed by the Court under Section 47 CPC.

Full Text
Translation output
Ex.P.93/2004 Page 1 HIGH COURT OF DELHI
Date of Decision: August 18th , 2008
EXECUTION PETITION NO. 93/2004
MCD ..... Decree Holder
Through : Mr. Sanjeev Sabharwal with Mr. Alok Singh, Advocates
VERSUS
RAMEY ..... Judgement Debtor
Through : Mr. Amit Gupta, Advocate
CORAM:
Mr. Justice S. Ravindra Bhat
JUDGMENT

1. Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes

2. To be referred to the Reporter or not? Yes

3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? Yes Mr. Justice S. Ravindra Bhat (Oral) EA No. 323/2007

1. This application under Section 47 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) objects to maintainability of the present execution proceedings filed by the decree holder Municipal Corporation of Delhi (MCD) for execution of a decree 2008:DHC:2372 Ex.P.93/2004 Page 2 arising out of an award dated 5th October, 1993. The award was made Rule of Court by judgment dated 11th April, 2002 in Suit No.2752/1993.

2. The applicant, judgment debtor objects to the maintainability of the execution on the ground that the ex parte award as confirmed by the ex parte order of this Court was procured by fraud. According to the applicant the parties had entered into an agreement on 21.01.1992 whereby the judgment debtor was to provide services by way of disposal of carcasses of animals to the MCD. The MCD alleged that the judgment debtor did not take charge of the contract and sought to levy damages.

3. The dispute was referred to arbitration. The judgment debtor contends that even though he participated in the arbitral proceedings but on one crucial day he was unrepresented, as a result the arbitrator decided against him. The award was thereafter referred to the Court under the provisions of the old Arbitration Act. The judgment debtor was not represented before the Court even though served. The court therefore, after considering the materials on record and pleadings, and affirmed the award. The decree holder MCD approached this Court in these circumstances for execution.

4. The applicant/judgment debtor appears to have approached the Division Bench in a belated appeal being FAO (OS) 242/2005, which was dismissed on 7th August, 2006, inter alia on the ground that it was highly belated being filed 1203**** after the last date of prescribed for filing such appeals. In the course of the order the Division Bench in its order also expressed itself on the merits, stating that even on merits the appellant Ex.P.93/2004 Page 3 (judgment debtor herein) failed to make out any case for interference with the judgment of the learned Single Judge passed on 11th April, 2002.

5. Mr. Gupta, counsel on behalf of applicant contends that the objections to the award were maintainable on the ground that it was procured by fraud. Counsel relied upon a document styled as a copy of minutes of meeting dated 24.06.1992 and contended that the MCD had appointed a Committee to examin the judgment debtor’s grievances. He relied on the final paragraph of the said document to show that the Committee decided that the judgment debt or had agreed to pay the contractual amount for the months April to July 1992 on the assurance by MCD that it would provide assistance as required within one month. Counsel contended that this amounts to novation of contract in terms of Section 62 of the Contract Act and a material document t was withheld from the scrutiny of the arbitration proceedings as well as from the Court by the MCD. It was therefore contended that the MCD played a fraud which disentitles it to press these execution proceedings.

6. One cannot have a quarrel with the proposition that a fraud can be set up as a valid ground to avoid a decree even co-laterally. Nullity of decree can be pleaded in execution proceedings (See Kiran Singh Vs. Chaman, AIR 1954 SC 340). Later judgments of the Supreme Court have also confirmed to this view. The question here is whether the facts alleged of such kind, as to persuade the Court to delve further into the matter and determine whether fraud, as alleged, took place. Ex.P.93/2004 Page 4

7. The materials on the file of the Court disclose that the judgment debtor was throughout casual in prosecution of the proceedings. He was unrepresented at the time when the award was made; though served he was also unrepresented when the matter was finally decided by the Single Judge. He filed a belated appeal about three years after the award was made Rule of the Court. The Division Bench considered his appeal both on the question of delay as well as on merits and dismissed it. The applicant/ judgment debtor now seeks to agitate the merits by cleverly styling it as challenge to the basis of the findings and order making it as Rule of Court as having been procured by fraud.

8. Learned counsel for the applicant was unable to point out as to when the copy of minutes of meeting, sought to be relied upon, was secured by the judgment debtor. No particulars in this regard have pleaded; the averments are conspicuously vague and unspecific.

9. The ground for fraud, particularly when it relates to legal proceedings, pre-supposes an exacting standard which the litigant alleging, as to specify. In this case having regard to the pleadings in the application, the Court is unpersuaded that any of the grounds which would entitle stoppage and/or dismissal of execution proceedings under Section 47, or for drawing an inference that the decree was a nullity – the only ground on which execution can be avoided can exist. The pleadings are vague, materials are lacking and the requirements of having to specifically over material particulars have not been complied with. Ex.P.93/2004 Page 5

10. In view of the above, this Court is of opinion that the application is unmerited; it is accordingly dismissed. EA No.351/2004 No further orders are required to be passed in the present application as the same has become infructuous in view of the order passed today in EA No.323/2007. Ex. P. 93/2004 The judgment debtor is directed to file an affidavit within four weeks disclosing his assets and banks accounts with relevant particulars. List on 4th November, 2008.

S. RAVINDRA BHAT, J.

AUGUST 18, 2008 mb