Full Text
CS(OS) 1760A/1995 & IA No.3974/1996 ANANT RAJ AGENCIES ..... Plaintiff
Through : Mr. Harish Malhotra, Sr. Advocate with Ms.Namita
Chaudhary, Advocte
Through : Ms. Anusuya Salwan with Ms. Monica Sharma and Ms. Renuka, Advocates
JUDGMENT
1. Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes
2. To be referred to the Reporter or not? Yes
3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? Yes Mr. Justice S. Ravindra Bhat (Oral) IA No.3974/1996
1. In this proceeding the defendant/Delhi Development Authority (DDA) challenges the legality and correctness of an award dated 20th July, 1995, 2008:DHC:2421 CS (OS) No.1760A/1995 Page No.2of 14 published by the sole arbitrator, appointed by the parties.
2. The brief facts, essential for deciding this case are that the claimantplaintiff (hereinafter referred to as the Contractor) was awarded civil works i.e development of land at Rohini, Phase I, SH: providing and lying water supply distribution lines in Sectors IV and V. According to the agreement the work was to be completed on 26th March, 1983. However, it is an undisputed fact that for varied reasons the time period was not adhered to. The DDA apparently granted extension of time without levying compensation though it had the power to do so. The work was completed on 01.10.1985. The contractor raised several claims and ultimately the matter was referred to arbitration by the DDA. The arbitrator entered upon the reference on 13.03.1992. The parties to the proceedings lead evidence and on 20.07.1995 and the impugned award was made and published. The contractor had raised nine heads of claims with two heads of additional claims in arbitration. The DDA had initially contended in the arbitral proceedings that the disputes were "excepted" matter and that the claims were time barred. The arbitrator over-ruled both the objections and published his award on the merits.
3. The DDA, through its counsel contends that the findings with regard to claim No.2 are without foundation. It was contended by Ms.Anusuya Salwan, CS (OS) No.1760A/1995 Page No.3of 14 counsel for DDA, while relying on Clause 7, the award of Rs.47,306.28 was not justified in the facts and circumstances. It was contended that the claims of the contractor in the final bill were barred by limitation and that the arbitrator ignored Clause 7 which enjoined him (the contractor) to submit the bill within one month of the date fixed for completion of the work or of the date of the certificate furnished by the Engineer In-charge.
4. Learned counsel next contended that the award for the sum of Rs.1,97,130/- under the head claim No.3 was untenable. She relied upon the Additional condition No.1 which stipulated that the contractor should have been acquainted with the proposed site of the works and studied specifications and conditions before submitting the tender. It was submitted that the amount awarded to the contractor, are in the nature of damages which cannot be sustained having regard to the various decisions of the Court.
5. Learned counsel next contended that the findings and the award in respect of claim No.4 are unsustainable in law as the arbitrator had termed it “infructuous expenses”. The amount of Rs.1,20,000/- was awarded against the DDA. Counsel submitted that this finding is unsupported by any evidence. It was urged that even assuming that the contractor had a legitimate claim, the existence of such claim did not absolve him from leading evidence in support CS (OS) No.1760A/1995 Page No.4of 14 of it. Thus in the absence of evidence and any reasoning in support, the arbitrator should not have awarded a sum of Rs.1,20,000/- in favour of the contractor for so called infructuous expenses.
6. Learned counsel submitted that uniform interest @ 18% per annum with quarterly rests under claim Nos. 5, 8 and 9 was completely unjustified. It was submitted that the contractor had preferred separate heads of claim in arbitral proceedings towards pre-suit, pendent lite and future interest; instead of applying his mind and awarding reasonable interest (assuming the contractor was entitled to any amount) the arbitrator awarded a uniform rate of interest which works in excess of 20% p.a., based on the formula adopted. Learned counsel relied upon recent judgments to say that upholding of such award of higher rate of interest under the present circumstances is unfeasible.
7. Learned counsel submitted that the award of Rs.3,01,143.51 in favour of the contractor towards first additional claim is also not tenable in law. The contractor had urged that the extension of contract resulted in deprivation of opportunity to make reasonable profit. Counsel contended that adoption of hypothetical mathematical formula to arrive at a figure of Rs.3,01,143.51 which was ultimately awarded on this head, was not correct. She relied upon judgment of this Court reported in Delhi Jal Board Vs. Subhash Pipes Ltd., 2005 CS (OS) No.1760A/1995 Page No.5of 14 (2) Arb. Law Reports 213 and Avtar Singh Chadha Vs. Municipal Corporation of Delhi, OMP 296/2006 decided on 21st May, 2007. Learned counsel further relied upon the judgment of the Supreme Court reported in Bharat Coking Coal Ltd. Vs.L.K. Ahuja, 2004 (5) SCC 109.
8. Ms. Salwan, lastly submitted that the award of 8% interest from 01.04.1986 till the date of payment on the sum of Rs.1,00,000/-, was unjustified. The arbitrator had allowed this claim on the ground that the contractor had to maintain a fixed deposit for a sum of Rs.1,00,000/- to comply with the stipulation for keeping alive a bank guarantee. The DDA contends here that the bank guarantee had in fact lapsed and that in any case the fixed deposit itself earned interest.
9. Mr. Harish Malhotra, learned senior counsel for the contractor resisted the opposition to the award. He submitted that having regard to the limited jurisdiction of the Court, the findings in the award cannot be interfered. Learned counsel submitted that the approach of the arbitrator cannot be faulted as unreasonable and that the findings were supported by the evidence as well as materials on record.
10. Learned counsel pointed out that the findings of the arbitrator regarding the culpability of the DDA in regard to the various delays which led to CS (OS) No.1760A/1995 Page No.6of 14 extension being granted without levy of compensation has not been impugned. The arbitrator found that even according to the records of the DDA there was delay of 920 days on its part. The counsel submitted that the discussion in this regard is elaborated in the findings concerning claim No.3. It was submitted in these circumstances, the award for the sum of Rs.47,306.28, can hardly be characterized as arbitrary; in any event the DDA's objections in this regard are without basis. Counsel submitted that as far as findings on claim No.3 for the award of Rs.1,97,130/- is concerned, the reasoning is sound. It was submitted that the contract entered into by the parties stipulated for compensation only as regards as escalation in labour cost by way of Clause 10 (C). In the circumstances the arbitrator was justified in awarding the sum of Rs.1,97,130/- as against the claim for Rs.12,98,100/-.
11. It was further submitted that the formula adopted, in the absence of any compensatory stipulation to the contrary, is valid and legal. Learned counsel relied upon the previous judgments of this Court in Metro Electricals Corporation Vs. Delhi Development Authority, New Delhi, AIR 1980 Del 266, and also the judgment in Delhi Development Authority Vs. S.S. Jaitley (2001 (1) Arb. LR 289 (Del). Counsel also submitted that the entire issue was considered in Delhi Development Authority Vs. U.Kashyap, 1998 VII AD (Delhi) CS (OS) No.1760A/1995 Page No.7of 14 300, where it was ruled that decision in Metro Electricals Corporation's case (supra) and subsequent judgments, where the arbitrator had awarded amounts in the backdrop of Clause 10 (C) but in the absence of any other stipulation, permitting award of compensation for other items, was justified. The said decision upheld the previous judgments in that regard even while ruling that in contracts where subsequent stipulations i.e. Clause 10 (CC) had been added, the aggrieved contractor could not claim on the basis of a formula alien to such a stipulation.
12. Learned counsel submitted that the objection to claim No.4 is also not tenable. It was urged that the arbitrator’s basis for awarding Rs.1,20,000/- was factually the determination of 30 months delay. The award relied upon the Hudson in Building and Engineering Contracts, Xth edition in support of the award of Rs.1,20,000/-. Counsel contended that the reasoning cannot be characterized as arbitrary. He also relied upon the Division Bench ruling of this Court in Delhi Development Authority Vs. S. S. Jaitley case (Supra) in this regard.
13. So far as the objections to claim Nos. 5, 8 and 9 i.e. interest for different periods are concerned Shri Malhotra contended that at the time when the contract was being performed the prime lending rates were high and the award CS (OS) No.1760A/1995 Page No.8of 14 in this regard cannot be considered excessive or illegal.
14. Learned counsel submitted that the award concerning additional claim was fully justified. He relied upon the judgment reported as Dwarka Das Vs. State of Madhya Pradesh, AIR 1999 SC 1031 and a previous judgment of the Supreme Court in M/s A.T. Brij Paul Singh & Bros Vs. State of Gujarat, AIR 1984 SC 1703. It was submitted that in these judgments the Supreme Court upheld awards where 15.damages had been granted on the head of loss of profitability. The above factual matrix shows that there is practically no dispute on the facts. The admitted facts are that there was delay of almost of about 30 months in the performance of the contract. However, this delay was found to be due to inaction and omissions of the DDA, by the arbitrator. The arbitrator also ruled that the DDA records established that the admitted delay was 960 days. On the basis of this material and also the circumstance that extension of time for performance was granted to the contractor without levy of compensation, arbitrator concluded that the DDA’s conduct was not free from blame which has formed the basis of the findings of claim No.2 which relate to various heads concerning preparation of final bill. The claimant/contractor had demanded for release of no less than 13 heads terms as extra items for which CS (OS) No.1760A/1995 Page No.9of 14 the DDA had withheld amounts from it. Though the contractor claimed a sum of Rs.36,54,080/- on account of final bill, what was finally awarded was Rs.47,306.28. The arbitrator has adduced reasons as against each head of claim allowed in favour of the contractor. The DDA has not been able to point out any infirmity in this reasoning or establish through material that such findings were unsupported by evidence. In these circumstances, neither the award nor the approach of the arbitrator as regards this head of claim can be faulted.
16. The DDA attacks the award of Rs.1,93,130/-, in claim No.3 found in favour of the contractor. The contractor had claimed Rs.12,98,100/- on account of damages for the work done during the extended period of the contract. In view of the finding that the actual delay is of 920 days, the arbitrator reasoned that the claimant was justified in demanding the damages. He then went on to apply the prevalent cost index to the value of work done on the basis of the IIIrd Running Account bill (RA Bill) and also took into account the final bills. After applying the formula, he awarded a sum of Rs.1,97,130/-.
17. The contract with the DDA stipulated only grant of escalated labour charges in clause 10 (C). Numerous previous decisions of this Court starting from Metro Electricals Corporation Vs. Delhi Development Authority, New Delhi CS (OS) No.1760A/1995 Page No.10of 14 to DDA Vs. U.Kashyap (supra) hence spoken of the legality of such damages, since the escalation clause in the contract (as existing during those days) only neutralized higher labour costs, but nothing else. Therefore, the award cannot be characterized as illegal or amounting to legal misconduct under the Arbitration Act, 1940. Learned counsel for the DDA could not dispute that this proposition is far too well settled by now. In these circumstances, it is held that the objections to the award of Claim no.3 are unfounded.
17. The next ground of challenge relates to claim no.4 where the arbitrator had awarded Rs.1,20,000/-. DDA’s argument here cannot be accepted for more than one reason. The Arbitrator in the opinion of the Court indicated sufficient reasons in support of the award, on this head of claim. He reasoned that the contractor was entitled to reckon 30 months delay. All that the arbitrator did, as far as this claim is concerned was to award Rs.4,000/- per month for 30 months, on account of manager's salary ( apparently a presumptive one which cannot by any means can be called unreasonable under the circumstance) for each of those 30 months. The second ground why this objection is untenable is that the similar awards have been upheld previously by this Court. Undoubtedly in view of the judgment in S.S. Jaitely case (supra), the objections to the award under claim No.4 are without any CS (OS) No.1760A/1995 Page No.11of 14 foundation.
18. The objections of the DDA to claim nos. 5, 8 and 9, in the opinion of the Court are substantial and worthy of acceptance. The arbitrator has applied 18% interest per annum with quarterly rests for all the three purposes i.e. presuit, pendent lite as well as future interest, though there might have been some justification at some point of time when the prime lending rates were high, the arbitrator was not justified in awarding such a uniform rate which cannot but result in hardship, when the award was published in 1995. The Supreme Court too has in recent past held that award of high rates of interest is not warranted. In the circumstances, this Court hereby modifies the award to the extent of rate of interest; in respect of all the three periods indicated which shall stand substituted to 12% p.a. (but without quarterly rests).
19. The arbitrator had awarded a sum of Rs.3,01,143.51 towards the loss of profitability (Additional Claim No.1) on application of a hypothetical formula. This pre-supposed that during the extended period, the contractor was deprived of legitimate profit. The grant of such amount presumes that the contractor would have been prevented from carrying out other works. The grant of such presumptive damages in the opinion of this Court in such circumstance is without justification. The Supreme Court in its judgment CS (OS) No.1760A/1995 Page No.12of 14 reported as Bharat Coking Coal Ltd. Vs.L.K. Ahuja case (supra) held as follows:
20. Aside from the above decision, it would be also important to recollect that the grievances of a contracting party about wrong doing by the other party, amounts to a complaint of breach. The principles for awarding damages are embodied in Sections 73 and 74 of the Contract Act. In such a case, the aggrieved party would have to establish through some evidence the loss in monetary terms which has been suffered by it. It would not be open for it to claim a certain amount and co-relate it with abstract formula not sanctioned by CS (OS) No.1760A/1995 Page No.13of 14 law. The decisions of the Supreme Court relied upon by the contractor namely Dwarka Das Vs State of Madhya Pradesh & Another and M/s A.T. Brij Paul Singh & Bros Vs. State of Gujarat (supra) were rendered in circumstances where the contract was rescinded. However, here the Court is dealing with the case where the contract was extended with mutual consent. Due to this important distinction, the Court is of the opinion that the rationale supported in these two judgments of the Supreme Court cannot apply in the present case. Besides this Court is also fortified in its finding by the previous judgments of this Court in Delhi Jal Board and Avtar Singh Vs. MCD (Supra) referred to above.
21. Another reason why such formula may not be acceptable is that unlike Section 74 - which supported parties reasonable pre-estimate of damage, Section 73 prescribes the statutorily mandated formula, i.e. the difference between the contracted price, and the price on date of breach. The claimant in cases falling under Section 73 would have to prove the amount, by some evidence. Though adoption of formulas as was done in this case is a convenient method of arriving at some figure, the danger of accepting it would be to universalize an approach, which does not have statutory basis. Besides, there would be fluidity in standards, leaving each arbitrator to chart his own course. CS (OS) No.1760A/1995 Page No.14of 14
22. As far as the last challenge to the additional claim no.2 is concerned, here the objections made by DDA in the opinion of the Court are merited. The arbitrator did not take into consideration the fact that the contractor kept the amount of Rs.1,00,000/- in the fixed deposit which undeniably earned him some interest. In the circumstances the award of further interest for almost a 20 year period was unjustified.
23. In view of the above conclusions, the objections of the DDA have to be partly allowed. The award in so far as it pertains to additional claim Nos. 1 and 2 are hereby set aside. The award of interest is modified from 18% with quarterly rests (claim nos. 5,[8] and 9); it shall, however, be substituted with direction to pay 12% interest per annum for the said periods. IA No.3974/1996 is allowed in the above terms. CS (OS) No.1760A/1995 The award is made rule of the Court subject to modifications indicated in the order in IA No.3974/1996. A decree shall be drawn in the above terms.
S. RAVINDRA BHAT, J.
AUGUST 21, 2008 mb