Sharda Nigam v. Daulat Ram College

Delhi High Court · 27 Aug 2008 · 2008:DHC:2471-DB
A.K. Sikri; Manmohan Singh
RFA No. 945 of 2003
2008:DHC:2471-DB
civil appeal_allowed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court held that an employer cannot recover excess salary paid due to its own error if the employee is not at fault, setting aside the trial court's decree for recovery.

Full Text
Translation output
Unreportable HIGH COURT OF DELHI RFA No. 945 of 2003
Date of Decision: August 27, 2008 Dr. (Mrs.) Sharda Nigam . . . Appellant through : Mr. O.P. Saxena with
Mr. K.K. Nigam, Advocates
VERSUS
Daulat Ram College & Anr. . . . Respondents through : Mr. S.K. Luthra, Advocate
CORAM :-
THE HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE A.K. SIKRI
THE HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE MANMOHAN SINGH
JUDGMENT

1. Whether Reporters of Local newspapers may be allowed to see the Judgment?

2. To be referred to the Reporter or not?

3. Whether the Judgment should be reported in the Digest? A.K. SIKRI, J. (ORAL)

1. Daulat Ram College (hereinafter referred to as the „College‟), who is the respondent herein, was the plaintiff in the suit filed by it against the appellant for recovery of Rs.3,13,016/- on the ground that while implementing the recommendations of the 5th Central Pay Commission, the pay of the appellant was wrongly fixed as a result whereof she was given excess salary than the salary which should have been paid on proper fixation. In this manner, it was stated in the plaint that a sum of Rs.2,24,926/- was over paid and claiming 2008:DHC:2471-DB sum of Rs.2,24,926/- along with interest @ 6% p.a. from the date of service of notice of demand dated 13.11.2000 when the appellant was asked to refund the said amount. In this appeal, said judgment and decree of the learned ADJ is impugned.

2. It is not necessary to state the fact of the matter in detail. Suffice is to note that the appellant was working as the Reader in the Department of Political Science of the College, from where she had retired on 31.7.1995. Without any break and with effect from 1.8.1995, she was re-employed for a period of five years as per the Rules and Regulations contained in Statutes and Ordinances of the University of Delhi. The 5th Central Pay Commission, which was constituted by the Central Government to undertake the exercise of revision of pay of the Central Government employees, submitted its report which was accepted by the Government with certain modifications with effect from 1.1.1996. University Grants Commission also decided to extend the benefit of these revisions as suggested by the 5th Pay Commission to the teachers of the Central Universities. It was in this backdrop that teachers of Delhi University also were given pay revision with effect from 1.1.1996 and in this manner pay of the appellant also was revised. Pay of the appellant was fixed at Rs.14,940/- in the pay scale of Rs.12000-18300 and her salary and allowances were disbursed accordingly for a certain period. Subsequently it was found that her pay was wrongly fixed and basic that she was over paid Rs.2,24,926/-, details whereof were given in the plaint. In these circumstances, vide communication dated 13.11.2000, she was asked to refund the aforesaid amount. As the appellant did not oblige, the College filed the aforesaid suit, which has been decreed by the trial court.

3. We proceed on the basis that the basic pay of the appellant initially was wrongly fixed as Rs.14,960/- whereas it should have been Rs.13,260/- and that she was over paid a sum of Rs.2,24,926/-. The only question is that if the College of its own committed the error in fixing the pay, is it permissible for the College to seek refund of the amount already paid. The appellant had contended in this behalf that the Supreme Court had laid down the principle of law in a number of cases to the effect that in these circumstances payment already made cannot be recovered though wrong can be rectified and the correct salary, at reduced rate, can be given for future period. We find that all these judgments are discussed by the learned trial court in the impugned judgment. However, the learned trial court distinguished those judgments and did not follow the dictum thereof on the premise that the directions contained in those judgments were given by the Supreme Court in its extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 142 of the Constitution of India, which power did not lie with the civil court. It is here the learned ADJ committed error which resulted in passing of the decree against the

4. No doubt, the Supreme Court is vested with wide powers under Article 142 of the Constitution and it can give directions to subserve the justice in a particular case. In exercise of the powers under this Article, the Supreme Court may pass such decree or make such order as is necessary for doing complete justice in any „cause‟ or „matter‟. Such a power is normally used sparingly, but is generally exercised by the Supreme Court to do substantial justice. This plenary power of the Supreme Court cannot be curtailed by any statutory provision. The technicalities cannot stand in the way of rendering complete justice to the parties. However, at the same time, such a power which is available to the Supreme Court under Article 142 of the Constitution cannot be exercised by other courts. The moot question is as to whether the cases in which directions were given not to recover the excess salary paid by the mistake of the employer were the directions under Article or it was a principle of law laid down which would become law under Article 141 of the Constitution to be followed by all the High Courts and Subordinate Courts. For this purpose, it would be necessary to scan through these judgments.

5. First case to which we shall refer is the judgment of the Supreme Court in Shyam Babu Verma & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors., (1994) 2 SCC. That was also a case where the Court found that excess payment was made to Pharmacists Grade B on wrong application of terms of the recommendations of the 3rd Central Pay Commission with effect from 1.1.1973. It further held that they would become entitled to the pay scale of Rs.330-560 only after a period of 10 years. After clarifying this issue, the Court addressed the question of recovery of excess payment made to these petitioners and held that since the petitioners had received the pay in the pay scale of Rs.330- 560 since 1973 due to no fault of theirs and that scale was being reduced in the year 1984 with effect from 1.1.1973, it would not be just and proper to recover any excess amount which was already paid to them. In the first blush this may appear to be a direction on the facts of this case though at the same time reason for non-recovery was also specifically assigned, namely, the payments were made to the petitioners in the said case in the higher pay scale “due to no fault of theirs”. However, even if there was any scope of doubt as to whether this was a direction under Article 142 of the Constitution or whether it was a principle of law laid down to be followed by other courts, the dust stands settled by the Supreme Court in its subsequent judgments. Consistently, the aforesaid principle is followed by the Apex Court as well as various High Courts, including this Court, namely, if the excess payment towards salary or allowances is given to an employee on wrong fixation, but not because of any error/falsity which could be attributed to the concerned employee, recovery of excess payment is not to be made though mistake can be corrected and salary can be re-fixed, which would have future application only.

6. It is not necessary to discuss all these cases. Our purpose would be served by referring to the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of Col. (Retd.) B.J. Akkara v. Govt. of India & Ors., 2006 AIR SCW 5252 as various earlier judgments are taken note of in this case. The question which was formulated, under somewhat similar circumstances, by the Supreme Court ran as follows: “The last question to be considered is whether relief should be granted against the recovery of the excess payments made on account of wrong interpretation/understanding of the circular dated 7.6.1999?”. After formulating this question, the Court answered the same in the following manner:- “This Court has consistently granted relief against recovery of excess wrong payment of emoluments/allowances from an employee, if the following conditions are fulfilled [Vide Sahib Ram vs. State of Haryana (1995) Supp 1 SCC 18, Shyam Babu Verma vs. Union of India (1994) 2 SCC 521, Union of India vs.

M. Bhaskar (1996) 4 SCC 416 and V. Gangaram v. Regional

Joint Director, AIR 1997 SC 2776: a) The excess payment was not made on account of any misrepresentation or fraud on the part of the employee, b) Such excess payment was made by the employer by applying a wrong principle for calculating the pay/ allowance or on the basis of a particular interpretation of rule/order, which is subsequently found to be erroneous. Such relief, restraining recovery back of excess payment, is granted by courts not because of any right in the employees, but in equity, in exercise of judicial discretion, to relieve the employees, form the hardship that will be caused if recovery is believing that he is entitled to it. As any subsequent action to recover the excess payment will cause undue hardship to him, relief is granted in that behalf. But where the employee had knowledge that the payment received was in excess of what was due or wrongly paid, or where the error is detected or corrected within a short time of wrong payment, Courts will not grant relief against recovery. The matter being in the realm of judicial discretion, courts may on the facts and circumstances of any particular case refuse to grant such relief against recovery.

26. On the same principle, pensioners can also seek a direction that wrong payments should not be recovered, as pensioners are in a more disadvantageous position when compared to in-service employees. Any attempt to recover excess wrong payment would cause undue hardship to them. The petitioners are not guilty of any misrepresentation or fraud in regard to the excess payment. NPA was added to minimum pay, for purposes of stepping up, due to a wrong understanding by the implementing departments. We are therefore of the view that Respondents shall not recover any excess payments made towards pension in pursuance of circular dated 7.6.1999 till the issue of the clarificatory circular dated 11.9.2001. Insofar as any excess payment made after the circular dated 11.9.2001, obviously the Union of India will be entitled to recover the excess as the validity of the said circular has been upheld and as pensioners have been put on notice in regard to the wrong calculations earlier made.”

7. It is manifest that the Court restated the principle following Shyam Babu Verma (supra) and other judgments viz. if the two conditions, as reproduced above, are satisfied, the recovery of the excess payment cannot be made by the employer. The two conditions are that the excess payment was not made on account of any misrepresentation or fraud on the part of the employee and that such excess payment was made by the employer by applying the wrong principle for calculating the pay/allowance or on the basis of a particular interpretation of rule/order which was found to be erroneous. The Court further clarified that this relief was not because mention, this principle in equity laid down by the Supreme Court has to be applied across the board in all the cases of public employment. It is not in dispute that the respondent College fits into the description of „another authority‟ within the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution. It is affiliated to the University of Delhi which is a statutory body. Therefore, the College is supposed to act as a model employer. Had it take an action for recovery of the amount from the future salary of the appellant, the appellant could have approached this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution by filing a writ petition. In such a writ petition, the Court could have set aside such a move on the part of the College. Simply because the College chose to file a civil suit for recovery of the excess amount paid and it is tried by the civil court, the legal position would not change. The learned ADJ, therefore, was wrong in holding that the principle laid down in Shyam Babu Verma (supra) would not be applied in a civil suit. Both the aforesaid principles squarely apply in the present case as well and there is not even a dispute about the same. We are, therefore of the opinion that the College was not entitled to recover the excess payment which had already been made and, therefore, suit for recovery of the amount was clearly not maintainable.

8. The upshot of the aforesaid discussion would be to allow this appeal and set aside the impugned judgment and decree of the trial court. It

9. On 19.7.2004, interim order was passed by this Court directing the appellant to furnish a bank guarantee in the sum of Rs. 2,00,000/-. The appellant has furnished the bank guarantee, which shall stand discharged. No costs.

12,495 characters total

(A.K. SIKRI) JUDGE (MANMOHAN SINGH) JUDGE August 27, 2008 nsk