Full Text
CS (OS) No. 1490/2005
Date of Decision: 28.08.2008
TOTAL ….… Plaintiff
Through: Mr. Manav Kumar, Advocate
JUDGMENT
1. Whether reporters of Local papers may Yes be allowed to see the judgment?
2. To be referred to the reporter or not? Not Necessary
3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? Not Necessary RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW, J.
1. The Plaintiff, a company incorporated under the laws of the Republic of France instituted the present suit for restraining the infringement of its registered trademark and corporate name. The cause of action for institution of the suit was the incorporation of the Defendant No. 4 (in the suit as originally filed) in the name of Total Gas Private Limited. The suit, besides against the Defendant No. 4 Total Gas Private Limited was also filed against the Defendants NO. 1, 2 and 3 as Directors of the said Total Gas Private Limited and 2008:DHC:2493 However, vide order dated 4th August, 1999, the said Defendant NO. 5 was deleted from the array of Defendants. The Defendant No. 2 Shri Vijay Kumar Gupta applied vide I.A. No. 13618/2006 for deletion of his name from the array of Defendants and vide order dated 11th May, 2007, his name was deleted from the array of Defendants on his representation that he had nothing to do with the Defendant NO. 4 Total Gas Private Limited. Thus, the suit survived against the Total Gas Private Limited as the Defendant No. 3 and against Shri Krishan Gupta and Shri Ashok Jain as Defendants No. 1 and 2, respectively, vide amended memo of parties dated 1st September, 2007.
2. Defendant Shri Krishan Gupta was proceeded ex parte vide order dated 4th August, 1999. The Defendants Shri Ashok Jain and Total Gas Private Limited filed a written statement and on the basis of their written statement, issues were framed on 14th March, 2001. However, the counsel earlier appearing for the Defendants Shri Ashok Jain and Total Gas Private Limited sought discharge on 31st January, 2005 and upon the failure of the said Defendants to appear in spite of service of court notice, they were also proceeded ex parte on 27th May, 2005.
3. The suit was thereafter, on change in pecuniary jurisdiction of courts, transferred to the district court. The Plaintiff applied for amendment of the plaint and whereafter, the suit came back to this court. Notwithstanding that all the Defendants had been proceeded ex parte, court notice was again issued to all the Defendants. The Defendants, i.e., Shri Krishan Gupta, Shri Ashok Jain and Total Gas Private Limited failed to appear in spite of court notice and were again proceeded ex parte on 11th May, 2007 and the Plaintiff was ordered to lead ex parte evidence. The Defendants remain ex parte.
4. The Plaintiff has examined its constituted Attorney Shri Sudhir
5. It is further in evidence that the Plaintiff is having multinational operations in oil exploration and production, refineries, transport of oil, liquefied petroleum gas, natural gas, manufacture and distribution of industrial lubricants and petroleum products and industrial oils. It has further been stated by the witness of the Plaintiff that a key part of the worldwide business of the Plaintiff is exploration, production, refining and marketing of natural gas.
6. It is further in evidence that the Plaintiff was incorporated in its name was changed in 1985 to TOTAL COMPAGNIE FRANCAIS des PETROLES and thereafter, in June 1991 changed to the present corporate name of ‘TOTAL'. The witness has deposed that the Plaintiff has since merged in 1999 with a Belgium based company PetroFina and changed its name to TotalFina and yet again in 2002 to TotalFinaElf and in 2003 to Total S.A.
7. It is further in evidence that the Plaintiff has been carrying on business in various countries through its subsidiaries named Total Lubricants International, S.A. (France), Total Gas Marketing (UK), Total Middle East, Total Petroleum Inc. (USA), Total South Africa and Total Espana (Spain). The Plaintiff is carrying on business in India in the name and style of Total Lubricants India Pvt. Ltd.
8. It is further in evidence that though the word TOTAL was added to the Plaintiff’s corporate name in 1985, as aforesaid, but the Plaintiff, even prior thereto, since the year 1950, was using the word TOTAL as a trademark for marketing its lubricants, industrial oils, motor fuels, LPG etc. The word TOTAL is also the house mark of the Plaintiff. The Plaintiff has proved the advertisements brought out by it of its products under the brand name of TOTAL, as Ex. P-5.
9. The Plaintiff has also proved registration of the trademark TOTALL and TOTAL under the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, 1958 vide certificates dated 30th November, 1954 and 24th May, 1982, respectively for greases, lubricants, fuels, motor spirit and oil products being derivatives from petroleum. The Plaintiff has registered the said trademarks in other countries also.
10. The Defendants, in the written statement earlier filed by them, had stated that the Defendant Total Gas Private Limited was merely incorporated and no business was commenced by it and that the present suit was filed immediately thereafter.
11. It is the case of the Plaintiff that the corporate name adopted by the Defendant Total Gas Private Limited was identical to the corporate name and trademark of the Plaintiff; that the business of the Defendant is identical to the Plaintiff; that the trade channels of the Plaintiff as well as of the Defendant’s business are the same and both the businesses operate through common trade consumers.
12. It is thus the case of the Plaintiff that the Defendant has intentionally adopted their corporate name to take advantage of the goodwill of the Plaintiff and in an attempt to ride its business activities on the strength of the Plaintiff – the Defendants are not entitled to do so.
13. The Defendants, of course, denied having carried on any business. However, the Defendants did not come forward to change their name and chose to remain ex parte. Defendants are carrying on any business. Thus the grievance of the Plaintiff which subsists is with respect to the corporate name TOTAL adopted by the Defendants.
15. The evidence of the Plaintiff remains unrebutted. The Plaintiff upon registration of TOTALL and TOTAL has acquired rights under Section 28 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999. Under Section 29 (5) of the Act, registered trademark is infringed by a person if such person uses such registered trademark as his tradename or part of his tradename or name of his business concern or part of the name of his business concern dealing in goods or services in respect of which the trademark is registered. Thus, the continuance by the Defendant of its corporate name would amount to infringement of the registered trademark of the Plaintiff. The counsel for the Plaintiff has relied upon Montari Overseas Ltd. vs. Montari Industries Ltd. 1996 PTC (16)
16. The Defendants who were intending to carry on business in the same products as in which the Plaintiff has been carrying on business, are deemed to have been aware of the Plaintiff and the brand name/trademark of the Plaintiff. The action of the Defendants of using the trademark of the Plaintiff as part of their corporate name, appears to be intended to deceive the public into believing that the Defendant was, in some manner, connected with the Plaintiff and/or to pass off their goods and business as that of the Plaintiff.
17. The Plaintiff has, therefore, made out a case for grant of permanent injunction restraining the Defendants from infringing the Plaintiff’s registered trademark and corporate name TOTAL. A decree for permanent injunction is accordingly passed in favour of Plaintiff and against the Defendants restraining the Defendants, their agents, directors and servants from carrying on business in the goods/products/services with respect to which the Plaintiff’s trademark is registered, under the corporate name ‘Total Gas Private Limited’ or a name deceptively similar thereto and/or from in any other manner using the mark TOTAL or a mark deceptively similar thereto in connection with their business. A decree for mandatory injunction is also passed against the Defendants directing the Defendants to, within six months herefrom, change the said corporate name to some other name which does not contain the word TOTAL and to have the said change recorded with concerned
18. The Plaintiff has also claimed punitive damages of Rs. 5 lacs. The counsel for the Plaintiff has relied upon Time Incorporated vs. Lokesh Srivastava & Another 2005 (30) PTC 3 (Del) and Microsoft Corporation vs. Yogesh Papat & Another 2005 (30) PTC 245 (Del) to contend that the Plaintiff is entitled to punitive damages to discourage and dishearten persons such as the Defendants who are infringing intellectual property rights. I have already found that the action of the Defendants of using the corporate name of which the trademark of the Plaintiff is a part, was intended to take advantage of the goodwill and business of the in the sum of Rs. 50,000/- only to the Plaintiff. The Plaintiff has not made out any case for grant of relief of delivery. The same is declined. The Plaintiff shall however be entitled to costs of the suit from the Defendants. Decree sheet be drawn up accordingly.
RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW (JUDGE) August 28, 2008 smp