Full Text
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
CS (OS) No. 1574/2006 & IA Nos.8992-8993/2006, 13731/2006, 2066/2007
Date of Decision: August 29th , 2008 AMRIT KAUR ......PLAINTIFF
Through : Mr.K.T.S. Tulsi, Sr. Advocate with Ms. Susha Unni, Advocate
Through : Mr. R.M. Bagai, Advocate
JUDGMENT
1. Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes
2. To be referred to the Reporter or not? Yes
3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? Yes Mr. Justice S. Ravindra Bhat: 2008:DHC:2500 CS (OS) 1574/2006 Page 2 IA No.7743/2007
1. This order proposes to dispose of an application, (IA 7743/2007) filed by the defendants, for rejection of the plaint, under Order VII, Rule 11 (d) Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereafter called “CPC”) on the ground of its being time barred.
2. The plaintiff a decree partitioning properties mentioned in Schedule A (to the suit) and other properties which may come to light in the course of the trial in these proceeding, which might have been purchased out of funds of the assets owned by her father, by metes and bounds, and declared her to be entitled to 1/5th share of the partitioned property. The plaintiff also claims a decree for rendition of accounts.
3. The plaintiff avers that Desh Raj Singh, her father was born in
1918. He went to Karachi for earnings and started his transport business there in a small scale. After partition, he started his business in Delhi under the name and style of “Karachi Taxi Co”. The plaintiff’s father and his family were living at 34/42, Punjabi Bagh, New Delhi. It is averred that the defendants, all sons of the said CS (OS) 1574/2006 Page 3 Desh Raj Singh, after attaining majority, joined him in the business and were inducted as Directors of the company. It is also averred that from the earnings of the said business, her father Desh Raj Singh acquired properties listed in Schedule A. With advancing age, Desh Raj Singh’s interest in the business started to wane. Accordingly, the first defendant, being his eldest son, started acting as the Karta of the Hindu Undivided Family.
4. The further material averments in the plaint, are extracted below:
5. Learned counsel for the applicant defendant submits that the plaint has to be rejected. Being an action seeking enforcement of rights in the joint family property, the relevant provision concerned is Article 110 of the schedule to the Limitation Act, 1963 (“the Act”) which prescribes that the period of limitation is 12 years. Counsel submitted that the period of limitation begins when the exclusion (from the property) becomes known to the aggrieved party or the plaintiff. He submitted that according to the plaintiff, immediately after her father’s death, she was excluded from her share in the properties left by him. As such the cause of action for the suit commenced from 19-8-1988; the limitation thus expired on 18-8-
2000. CS (OS) 1574/2006 Page 8
6. Learned counsel submitted that the plaintiff did not have any cause of action to approach this court and file the suit. Being a daughter of the late Desh Raj Singh, she was not a coparcener, in the Hindu undivided family. Counsel submitted that the plaintiff could not take advantage of amendment to Section 6 of the Hindu Marriage Act, since it was brought into force in 2005, and operated prospectively. Learned counsel submitted that the court should exercise its power under Order VII, Rule 11 and reject the plaint, to avoid what is a patently frivolous and vexatious litigation, filed speculatively.
7. Mr. K.T.S. Tulsi, learned senior counsel for the plaintiff, urged that the suit clearly reveals a cause of action. At the stage of considering whether a suit can be entertained or rejected, the court cannot look into the feasibility of the plaintiff’s case on merits; it has to merely consider the averments in the plaint, and proceed on the assumption that they are correct. It was submitted that the averments in the plaint show that the late Desh Raj Singh had acquired properties; after his death, the defendants took charge of CS (OS) 1574/2006 Page 9 those, as well as the family business. The plaintiff’s brother, Amrit Pal Singh, died in 1993. Thereafter, the defendants became dishonest, and started to deny her rights. The plaintiff made several attempts, including the one recently, in 2007, to seek her rights, but all of them failed. As a result, she filed the present suit. The same is within the period of limitation prescribed by law.
8. Article 110 of the Schedule to the Act provides that a suit by a person excluded from a joint family property, to enforce a right to share therein is twelve years. The starting point is when the exclusion becomes known to the plaintiff.
9. It has been held that the object underlying this Article is to afford protection to a member of a joint Hindu family against prejudicial action by the other members of the family behind his back with respect to his interest in the family property. It has been held that this provision, prescribing the period of limitation, and the conditions of its applicability also apply to suits for partition (Radhoba –vs- Aburao AIR 1929 PC 231). It has also been held that “exclusion” is a fact specific circumstance, to be seen in the light of CS (OS) 1574/2006 Page 10 materials on record in every case. However, what should be seen by the court is the intention of the persons so seeking to exclude the plaintiff, from the enjoyment of his (or her) share (Haresh –vs- Hardevi 1927 (1) ILR 49 All 763; Velayudhan –vs- Velumpi Kunji, ILR 1958 Ker 389 (FB) and Marudhanayagam Pillai –vs- Sola Pillai 77 Mad LW 697). This court too, had applied a similar criteria, when considering whether the suit was time barred, and in the judgment reported as Ramesh Chand V. Tek Chand & Others 115 (2004) DLT
193.
10. In this case, the plaintiff avers, clearly enough that her entitlement arose upon the death of Desh Raj Singh, in 1988; she further submits that: “14. That, it appears that, soon after the demise of Sh. Desh Raj Singh and Shri Amrit Pal Singh defendant No.1 became dishonest and in collusion with defendant no.2 started carrying on the family business in an arbitrary manner, detrimental to the interest of HUF.” In the averments prior to the above allegations, it was contended that the family properties were acquired by the late father, who had, after becoming advanced of age, left its management to the first CS (OS) 1574/2006 Page 11 defendant, who acted as the Karta. Even if the plaintiff’s right to seek partition assuming there to be one, were to be reckoned on the later date indicated, i.e after the death of the late Amrit Pal Singh, (who died in 1993) the suit was time barred, having been filed only in 2006.
11. When the court has to consider whether or not to reject the plaint, it is guided by the principles evolved by the Supreme Court in
The Court had held that if on a meaningful, not formal, reading of the plaint it is manifestly vexatious, and meritless, in the sense of not disclosing a clear right to sue, the Court should exercise its power under Order VII Rule 11 of the Code taking care to see that the ground mentioned therein is fulfilled. In Roop Lal Sethi v. Nachhattar Singh Gill, (1982) 3 SCC 487, the Court observed that when the plaint discloses no cause of action, it is obligatory upon the Court to reject it; yet the rule does not justify the rejection of any particular portion of a plaint. CS (OS) 1574/2006 Page 12
12. Later again, in ITC Ltd. v. Debts Recovery Appellate Tribunal, (1998) 2 SCC 70, it was held that the basic question to be decided in dealing with an application filed by the defendant under Order VII Rule 11 of the Code is to discern if a real cause of action has been set out in the plaint or something illusory has been projected, to get out of the said provision. Saleem Bhai and Others v. State of Maharashtra and Others, (2003) 1 SCC 557 is an authority on the issue that the Court can exercise its powers under Order VII Rule 11 of the Code at any stage of the suit before registering the plaint or after issuing summons to the defendant at any time before the conclusion of the trial and for that purpose averments in the plaint are germane and the pleas taken by the defendant in the written statement would be wholly irrelevant. It was also held in Mayar (H.K.) Ltd. & Ors -Vs- Owners & Parties, Vessel M.V. Fortune Express & Ors 2006 (3) SCC 100 that the provision, the Court would be justified in rejecting the plaint where it does not disclose a cause of action, where the relief claimed is undervalued and the valuation is not corrected within a time as fixed by the Court, where insufficient CS (OS) 1574/2006 Page 13 Court-fee is paid and the additional Court-fee is not supplied within the period given by the Court, and where the suit appears from the statement in the plaint to be barred by any law.
13. The averments in the plaint are sufficient to deduce that the even according to the plaintiff, she was excluded from enjoyment of the joint family properties immediately after her father’s death. The suit is, significantly enough, not accompanied by any document; it does not also rely on any document. No list of documents has been filed in the last two years. Further, the plaintiff does not advert to a single specific date when the defendants were asked to give her the share in properties, and when they refused. The entire case set up is on an oral demand. No notice, of lawyer, or even of the plaintiff, is relied upon. Thus, on a meaningful reading of the plaint, it has to be concluded that the allusion of demand in 2007, when other parts of the suit show that the grievance about the plaintiff’s share having arisen in 1988, is an attempt to get over the question of limitation.
14. In the opinion of this court, an overall reading of the plaint shows that the alleged cause of action for filing this suit, for CS (OS) 1574/2006 Page 14 enforcement of the plaintiff’s rights in the Schedule A properties, according to her, arose in 1988; at best in 1993. In either case, the suit, filed in 2006 is clearly time barred. Therefore, the application IA 7743/2007 has to succeed; it is accordingly allowed. For the same reasons, the plaint in CS OS 1574/2006 is rejected. All pending applications are also dismissed. The parties shall bear their own costs. DATED: 29th August, 2008 S. RAVINDRA BHAT, J.