Full Text
M.A. No. 12326/2007
Date of Decision: 9th September, 2008 # RANJIT CHAUDHARY ...... Petitioner
! Through : Mr. S.K. Sharma, Adv.
^ Through : Mr. Y.K. Aggarwal, Adv. for R-1
JUDGMENT
(1) Whether reporters of local paper may be allowed to see the judgment? (2) To be referred to the reporter or not? (3) Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest ?
JUDGMENT
ARUNA SURESH, J. (Oral)
1. By way of this petition, petitioner Sh. Ranjit Choudhary seeks quashing of Complaint Case NO. 94/1/03 under Section 138 of the Negotiable 2008:DHC:2608 Instruments Act titled “Sanjeev Thareja v. Bombay Bazaar” and proceedings conducted therein which is pending adjudication in the court of learned Metropolitan Magistrate Ms. Navita Kumari.
2. Epigrammatically, on 10.12.2002 a cheque bearing no. 168979 was issued by M/s Bombay Bazaar, respondent no. 2 company drawn on Punjab and Sindh Bank for a sum of Rs. 35,531/- in favour of the complainant, respondent no. 1 Sanjeev Thareja and Sons (HUF), in lieu of the commission payable to the complainant in terms of an agreement inter-se them of establishing distribution centre at Lajpat Nagar. Complainant presented the above said cheque to its banker who informed the complainant that the cheque stood dishonoured for „Funds Insufficient‟. Complainant sent a legal notice dated 11.2.2003 to the respondent no. 2 company as well as the petitioner and respondent nos. 3 to 9 who were the directors of the respondent no. 2 company calling upon them to pay the amount of the bounced cheque. The accused persons sent a reply to the said legal notice. Consequently complainant filed a complaint somewhere in May 2003. The trial court took cognizance of the offences and summoned the accused persons including the petitioner. On 6.3.2007 learned Metropolitan Magistrate issued nonbailable warrants against the petitioner and other accused persons. Hence, the present petition.
3. It is submitted by the counsel for the petitioner that the cheque in question was signed and issued by respondent no. 4 Vijay Tata who was the director/CEO of the respondent no. 2 company M/s Bombay Bazaar. Also the petitioner had sent a reply on 25.2.2003 to the advocate of respondent no. 1 company against the legal notice of demand of payment dated 11.2.2003 in which it was stated that petitioner had resigned from the company w.e.f. 14.9.2002 and a copy of Form-32 was also attached thereto. It is further submitted that petitioner has not been served with the notice of the case and it is only recently that petitioner came to know of the non-bailable warrants issued against him by the trial court.
4. It is further argued by the counsel for the petitioner that the date on which the cheque was issued that is 10.12.2002; the petitioner had already resigned on 14.9.2002. Even during his tenure as a director, he was not involved in the day to day functioning of the company.
5. Learned counsel for respondent no. 1 controverted the submissions advanced by the counsel for the petitioner by challenging the relevancy and admissibility of Form-32 produced by the petitioner, Form-32 being prepared by the company was not a public document. In support of his contentions respondent has relied on the Budhamal Bhansali @
6. Reply dated 25.2.2003 sent to the complainant by the petitioner mentions that there was shuffling in the constitution of directors of the company and respondent no. 4 took over the charge of the company whereas petitioner had resigned with effect from 14.9.2002. He also stated in the reply letter that the cheque no. 168979 dated 10.12.2002 was issued by respondent no. 4 Vijay Tata, Director of Bombay Bazaar after the resignation of the petitioner. Form no. 32 filed with the ROC Mumbai gave the status of the petitioner in the respondent no. 2 company that he had resigned on 14.9.2002.
7. It is clear that petitioner had resigned long before the cheque was issued and the production of Form-32 filed with the Registrar of the Companies by the petitioner to establish his resignation is also sufficient for this petition to succeed. The respondent has not given any evidence on record to show that the petitioner was involved in the functioning and conduct of the respondent No. 2 company any time either after the resignation on 14.9.2002 or till after the cheque was issued.
8. It is pertinent to mention that Form-32 was submitted to the Registrar of Companies by respondent no. 4 Vijay Tata as director of the respondent no. 2 company. Certified copy of Form-32 is a public document as per section 74 of the Evidence Act and the Court has to presume as to the genuineness of such certified copies as per section 79 of the evidence act when no counter credential is projected by the complainant.
9. In Dr.(Mrs.) Sarla Kumar Vs Srei International Finance Ltd.) 132 (2006) DLT 363, the cheque was issued in 2003 and the petitioner ceased to be the director of the Company in 1994. A certified copy of Form-32 issued by the Registrar of companies was filed by the petitioner and this court held that form 32 it was a conclusive proof that the petitioner resigned in 1994 and was not the director at the material time and quashed the proceedings against the petitioner.
10. This view was again upheld in another judgment of this court H.R. Kapoor v. Securities and Exchange Board of India 149(2008) DLT 591 wherein petitioners filed petitions under Section 482 Cr.P.C. and filed certified copies of Form-32 and it was observed by the court that the document Form-32 being a public document, which can be easily verified even on inspection of the records of the company with the Registrar of the Companies, does not require elaborate evidence on trial.
11. In J.N. Bhatia v. State 139 (2007) DLT 361 this court pointed out that Form-32 if filed before the issuance of the dishonoured cheque then such Form- 32 can be safely acted upon to quash the complaint.
12. In light of the above considered precedents by this Court the judgment of Budhamal Bhansali @ B. Bhansali v. The State of West Bengal and Anr. (supra) cannot be considered as a good law.
13. In the present case Form-32 was filed with the issued. The cheque pertaining to the case was drawn between the period 10.12.2002 to 29.1.2003 and during that period, the petitioner did not function as Chairman or Director of the accused company and he was also not in-charge of and responsible for the affairs of the company when the cause of action arose for non payment of the cheque amount on receipt of respective statutory notices. It is a settled law that only a person who is responsible for conduct of business of the company at the time of commission of the offence can be made liable for the offence. Acceptance of resignation and filing of Form 32 with registrar of companies establishes the fact that a person ceased to be the director of the company. Criminal liability cannot be fastened on the petitioner after he ceased to be director of the company.
14. Hence in light of the facts and circumstances of the case, the petition is allowed. The complaint case NO. 94/1/03 only against the petitioner as well as the nonbailable warrants dated 6.3.2007 issued only against him are hereby quashed.
15. Attested copy of the order be sent to the trial court.
ARUNA SURESH (JUDGE) September 09, 2008 jk